[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference taveng::bagels

Title:BAGELS and other things of Jewish interest
Notice:1.0 policy, 280.0 directory, 32.0 registration
Moderator:SMURF::FENSTER
Created:Mon Feb 03 1986
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1524
Total number of notes:18709

896.0. "Michelin wipes Israel off the map" by CIMNET::TOBIN_D () Wed Feb 28 1990 14:49

    The following is from the February 1990 Hadassah Framingham Chapter
    Bulletin:
    
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
                                   DID YOU KNOW . . .
    
    The following information is a direct quote from the January Boston
    CAMERA.  We feel it is of sufficient interest to present to you.  It is
    entitled ISRAEL EXPUNGED!
    
    The renowned Michelin Guide is marketing a map, available at local
    bookstores, labeled "Northeast Africa, Arabia (#954>) that omits the
    state of Israel (Jordan and Egypt are included).  Out of apparent
    concern for the sensibilities of Arab customers who would like to see
    Israel obliterated, Michelin has also omitted from a long column of
    regional cities, Jerusalem, Tel Aviv, Haifa and so on.
    
    Friends of Israel - and of decency - may want to inform Michelin that
    they will not purchase Michelin products (tires, guidebooks, maps) as
    long as the company promotes Arab intentions to "wipe Israel off the
    map."   Let your local bookstore know about the problem.  Letters from
    them and from you can make a difference.
    
    	Pneu Michelin
        46 Av. de Buteil
        75341 Paris
    	France
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    
    What's your reaction?
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
896.1too bad...TOTH::CHERSONtake giant stepsWed Feb 28 1990 15:5410
896.2NOTIME::SACKSGerald Sacks ZKO2-3/N30 DTN:381-2085Wed Feb 28 1990 16:209
    re .1:

    I don't think that all Sears tires are made by Michelin.  They only
    advertise some lines as "Made by Michelin."  BTW, according to a
    note in CARBUFFS, Uniroyal and B.F. Goodrich were recently bought
    by Michelin.

    I too was about to buy Michelins, but will look elsewhere (and write
    a letter).
896.3Didn't there used to be a town there?DOCSRV::STARINAway the boarding party!Wed Feb 28 1990 16:4610
    Re .0:
    
    Too bad Michelin didn't take parts of Lebanon out of their
    guide.....considering what the 16" shells from the guns of the USS NEW 
    JERSEY did to the Syrian missile batteries located on Lebanese soil
    in 1983.
    
    Mark
    Chief Radioman
    US Navy Reserve
896.4Policy time...CLT::CLTVAX::dickDick Schoeller - Failed XperimentWed Feb 28 1990 17:5013
Shalom Y'all,

While I decry what Michelin has done, and while I personally would support
a boycott of their products, we are not allowed to encourage others to
participate in a boycott in DEC notesfiles (though my reading indicates that we
are allowed to mention our own participation).  Because of that policy,
I have hidden note .1.  We can, however, encourage people to contact Michelin
and let them know what they think.

As a side issue, Kleber tires are also made by Michelin.

Gavriel
_who_recently_bought_Michelin_tires_8^{(
896.6TOTH::CHERSONtake giant stepsWed Feb 28 1990 19:575
    re: .4
    
    So edit my note to remove the verb "advise".
    
    --David
896.7more about MichelinRICKS::MCALLENLou Slips Inked ChipsThu Mar 01 1990 01:5026
    Could anyone clarify where these particular Michelin
    travel guides are distributed? Is this guide for
    world-wide distribution, Mideast-wide, North-Africa only ?
    
    Yes, initially (some years ago) ALL Sears-Roebuck
    radial-ply tires (not bias-ply) were manufactured and
    private-labeled for Sears by Michelin, I believe.
    This is no longer (exclusively) the case.
    
    Other interesting facts or allegations about Michelin:
    
    Certainly Michelin was a major, and probably the dominant,
    operator of rubber plantations in French colonial Indochina.
    
    Also, it is rumored that throughout the USA's Vietnam
    intervention, some (or many) Michelin rubber plantations
    continued to operate in Indochina, markedly unscathed
    by the widespread military hostilities. Where (North/South),
    whether, and how this could have been true is a bit mysterious.
    Of course, nasty little "wars" emit many unfounded rumors.
    
    As an aside, I'd like to hear how/whether various Arab oil
    countries influenced American oil firms, such as Aramco,
    to adopt anti-Israeli or anti-Zionist positions, publicly
    and/or behind the scenes. I've started a topic (899.*) for
    that. 
896.8NOTIME::SACKSGerald Sacks ZKO2-3/N30 DTN:381-2085Thu Mar 01 1990 16:231
    Out of curiosity, what country does the map give Israel to?
896.9What I readDDIF::LUWISHThu Mar 01 1990 23:2029
    From what I could gather from the CAMERA newsletter, Israel is not
    omitted from the map itself, but rather from the "maplet" on the cover
    which shows the area enclosed by the map.  On this maplet, the
    countries are indicated by name, and a number of major cities are
    indicated by name and "dot".  The name "Israel" is omitted, as well as
    all cities within Israel.  I do not know whether Israel's boundary is
    shown (if so, it would be the pre-1967 boundary, of course), but if it
    is omitted, you can assume that Michelin has given Israel to Jordan.
    
    It is possible that Michelin used some clever device, such as a
    trademark or compass rose, to obscure Israel on this little map, so as
    to have a defensible reason for leaving out the items of text mentioned
    above.
    
    This obvious attempt at appeasing anti-Israel tire-buyers is an insult. 
    If Israel were in fact omitted from the large, unfolded map as well, it
    would be an outrage.  Actually, it would be an outrage committed
    against Jordanian, Lebanese and Syrian Arabs, who might get seriously
    injured if they accidentally wandered across the Israeli border as a
    result of using such an inaccurate map!
    
    Firestone makes a good tire, and they're owned by Bridgestone of Japan.
    And Rand McNally makes a good map, and they're not even in the tire
    business.  I mention these names solely for informational purposes, as
    I obviously would never discourage anyone from purchasing products from
    a company that would prefer the extinction of my people and its
    homeland.
    
    Ed
896.10NOTIME::SACKSGerald Sacks ZKO2-3/N30 DTN:381-2085Fri Mar 02 1990 16:538
re .0,.9:

Has anybody actually *seen* this map?  If Israel is on the map itself, but
not on the cover, how would that appease anti-Israel map buyers (or tire
buyers)?  Who buys maps for the cover?

Strange as it sounds, I guess I'll have to track down the map before
I buy tires.
896.11ExplanationWORDY::GRACEWait, I'm LIVING in Grace-land!Fri Mar 02 1990 19:136
    Is this a case of Israel not being in "Arab North Africa"? It is not an
    Arab country. Or is this a technicality that they maybe adhering to.
    I'd like to see this map and find out. If it is the case, then a letter
    of explanation is in order.
    
    Russ
896.12BOLT::MINOWGregor Samsa, please wake upSun Mar 04 1990 01:548
I tried finding this map in the Harvard Square Map Store, but the
only Michelin maps I saw had Israel.  However, I didn't look closely
at the cover, but only the contents.

It's of course possible that they publish differnt maps for different
parts of the world.

Martin.
896.13Let me check this at my library...SUTRA::LEHKYI'm phlegmatic, and that's cool.Mon Mar 05 1990 17:567
    The local correspondent will check this up. However, as with many other
    Industrial bodies (DEC included), I wouldn't be surprised if Michelin
    were counting Israel as "European" country.
    
    Surprisedly yours,
    
    Chris
896.14It's JordanRADVAX::WAKYOnward, thru the Fog...Thu Mar 08 1990 23:288
re: .8

>>    Out of curiosity, what country does the map give Israel to?

From the picture in the CAMERA report - Jordan.  It shows Egypt, with Cairo
largely noted, Suez in between, and Jordan, with Amman largely noted.  

Waky
896.15Still lookingSUTRA::LEHKYI'm phlegmatic, and that's cool.Fri Mar 09 1990 12:2411
    Hmmm... My bookstore up here does seem to have "normal" Michelin maps
    of the area. Could it be that you ran across one destined for arabic
    countries?
    
    Remember, many people in Europe have two passports, for instance,
    because some arabic countries wouldn't grant you access if you had an
    Israel visa. I do ignore whether the reverse is true, as well.
    
    Searchingly yours,
    
    Chris
896.16Any New Info about Michelin?IAMOK::ROSENBERGDick Rosenberg VRO5-1/D7Fri May 04 1990 16:166
    Does anybody have any new information about Michelin? I may be in the
    market for some new tires and "used" to like Michelins.
    
    Thanks,
    
    Dick
896.17SUTRA::LEHKYI'm phlegmatic, and that's cool.Fri May 04 1990 17:125
    My Michelin Atlas shows Israel, no sweat.
    
    Reportingly yours,
    
    Chris
896.18fixed in next releaseTAVENG::GOLDMANMon May 14 1990 21:406
   I read a short article a few weeks back in the Jerusalem Post.
   It seems that someone in California (I think) was upset that Israel 
   was left off the map and got on Michelin's case about it.  I 
   don't recall if the article said that they actually apologized 
   but they did acknowledge the issue and had it fixed to the person's 
   satisfaction.
896.19Wrap Up on the storyJAIMES::WAKYOnward, thru the Fog...Tue Jun 12 1990 19:3831
From the Int'l J. Post 02June '90

PUTTING ISRAEL ON THE (MICHELIN) MAP       by Tom Tugend/LA

Jerusalem and Tel Aviv, as well as Ashdod and Netanya, have reclaimed their 
rightful places in the Michelin Guide, to the great satisfaction of a feisty 
Los Angeles journalist who blew the whistle on their exclusion.

A couple of months ago, Herb Brin, publisher of Heritage, a Jewish weekly,
picked up Michelin map No. 954, titled "Northeast Africa, Arabia."  What he 
found, or rather did not find, set his blood aboiling.

When Brin's blood boils, the result is usuaslly a pugnacious editorial, which 
in this case appeared under the unequivocal headline, "Michelin stinks."  
Referring to the map, Brin noted that "Israel does not appear, nor does 
Jerusalem.  The name Amman is shown where Jerusalem ought to be.  Other cities, 
such as Tel Aviv and Haifa, are also omitted.

"Michelin did what the Arabs could never do on the battlefield - wipe Israel 
off the map.  But Michelin should live so long.  And since we have a reputation 
about not mincing words in such matters, we repeat: Michelin stinks."

The editorial found its way to Michelin's U.S. headquarters in South Carolina, 
and within six weeks a Kevin F. Clemens, manager of media relations, wrote back 
a soothing letter and included the latest update of the controversial map, 
released in April.

"As you will see," Clemens wrote to Brin, "your concerns have been addressed."  
And indeed, on the new version of the map, the legend "Israel" appears in large 
print.  All major Israeli cities are listed, and a sharp-eyed reader may even 
spot Kiryat Gat, Dimona and Hadera.