[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference taveng::bagels

Title:BAGELS and other things of Jewish interest
Notice:1.0 policy, 280.0 directory, 32.0 registration
Moderator:SMURF::FENSTER
Created:Mon Feb 03 1986
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1524
Total number of notes:18709

160.0. "Yehudim in the major leagues" by NONODE::CHERSON (Imagination tires before nature) Mon Jul 14 1986 13:06

    This note may not much bearing on those outside of North America,
    so proceed if you want to.
    
    Hasn't anyone taken notice that in acquiring Tom Seaver, the Red
    Sox have their first Jewish player since Jeff Newman.  Or how many
    of you were aware that Tom Seaver is Jewish? 
    
    Oakland also had, albeit temporarily, a Jewish manager in Jeff Newman.
    Just rambling.
    
    David
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
160.1ZEPPO::MAHLERMichaelMon Jul 14 1986 13:093
    I didn't know he was Jewish.

160.2Shame!NONODE::CHERSONRude boyMon Jul 14 1986 13:143
    Shame on you, and you're from the NY/NJ area?
    
    D.C.
160.3Who?GRAMPS::LISSFred - ESD&P Shrewsbury MAMon Jul 14 1986 14:204
    Who's Tom Seaver?
    
    			8-)
    
160.4Funny, he doesn't look it!BAXTA::SPECTOR_DAVIMon Jul 14 1986 15:154
    
    Re: .0
    
    	Who cares ?
160.5pulling my leg, are you?ULTRA::OFSEVITDavid OfsevitMon Jul 14 1986 15:278
    re .0
    
    	If this were true, my Father (who followed baseball very closely
    until he died, and who was nothing if not proud of Jewish athletes)
    would have taken notice.  But he never did, so I assume this is
    fiction.
    
    		David
160.6I don't think soNONODE::CHERSONRude boyMon Jul 14 1986 15:4915
    re: .5
    
    David, I don't believe that this is fiction, I'll double check in
    the Jewish Almanac.
    
    re: .4
    
    Why not?  Not all the notes in this file have to deal with "Sturm
    und Drang" topics.  When I folowed baseball closely as a kid, I
    always made an extra effort to find the Jewish players.  Anti-Semites
    always maintained that Jews were too "frail" to play sports, I always
    tried to counter those accusations(mostly by getting myself killed
    in football).
    
    David
160.7S'more sports trivia....15748::MAGENHEIMMon Jul 14 1986 20:2326
    What team was Sandy Koufax on?
    
    Just for interest sake, "The Book of Lists", by David Wallechinsky,
    Irving Wallace and Amy Wallace have a section entitled "Harry Stein's
    All-Time All-Star Argument Starter (5 All-Time Ethnic Baseball Teams)",
    which include the Latins, the Poles, the Blacks, the Italians as
    well as the Jews (who Harry Stein is, I don't know).  Nevertheless,
    they include:
    
    	Ed Reulbach (1905-1917), rhp	Rod Carew (1967-   ), 2b
    	Sandy Koufax (1956-1966), lhp   Buddy Myer (1925-1941), ss
    	Larry Sherry (1958-1968), rp	Al Rosen (1947-1956), 3b
    	Johnny Kling (1900-1913), c	Sid Gordon (1941-1955), lf
    	Hank Greenberg (1930-1947), 1b	Benny Kauff (1912-1920), cf
    					George Stone (1903-1910), rf
    
    	(in proper batting order, after the pitcher)
    
    This was actually reprinted from ESQUIRE Magazine (July, 1976).
    No doubt some of the above will live in infamy...    %^}
    
    What I'd like to know is, has there ever been a Jewish major league
    hockey player (considering 99.44% are French-Canadien)?
    
    Anita
    
160.8To set the record straight...STAR::TOPAZMon Jul 14 1986 22:5015
     
     re .7:
     
     I haven't a clue why you think most hockey players are French-
     Canadian; however, you are mistaken.  The largest percentage of hockey
     players (in the NHL) are English-speaking Canadians (which makes sense
     -- more than 65% of Candians are native English-speaking). American-
     born players are now nearly as common as French-Canadians, and there
     are also many Europeans (esp. Swedes, Finns, and Czechs).
     
     Two Jewish ex-NHL players that come to mind are Ross Brooks
     (goaltender with the Bruins in the mid-70s) and Larry Zeidel (played
     with the Flyers in the late 60s).
     
     --Don
160.9A thousand pardons...15748::MAGENHEIMMon Jul 14 1986 23:316
    I stand corrected (I guess), though that wasn't the gist of the
    reply.  
    
    Regardless, thanks for the info on the hockey players!
    
    Anita
160.10You're right!NONODE::CHERSONSmartasses union, local 6.78Tue Jul 15 1986 16:259
    re: .8
    
    Your're absolutely right, and the duck will come down and give you
    $50!
    
    P.S.: I'm still checking on Seaver.  By the way Anita, Koufax played
    on the Brooklyn/LA dodgers.
    
    David
160.11Pitch on Shabbot ??17922::POTUCEKCLASSIFIEDTue Jul 15 1986 19:118
    Posing a question ...
    
    If Tom Seaver is Jewish,,,, is it not forbidden for him to pitch
    on Shabbot ???
    
    /jmp
    
    
160.12STAR::TOPAZTue Jul 15 1986 20:148
     
     re .11:
     
     In a World Series (late 50s or early 60s), Koufax and Sherry both
     stayed away from the ballpark on one of the game days that coincided
     with Rosh Hashanah or Yom Kippur.  
     
     --Mr Topaz
160.13Shamsky tooWHAT::DIAMONDThu Jul 17 1986 08:439
    Art Shamsky (sp.) I think was Jewish too.  I seem to recall that
    he stayed away from a World Series game for the same reason as Koufax
    and Sherry.  Was Sherry a pitcher, could they adjust his rotation
    like they might have been able to do for Koufax.
    
    I'd be very surprised if one was able to find any very observant
    Jew in any professional sport or at a world-class level.  The training
    normally requires seven day attention, and many competitions are
    on Shabbat.                                     
160.14Tall, Dark and Yiddish15748::POLIKOFFArnie PolikoffThu Jul 24 1986 14:553
    	Are there any Black Jewish basketball players? N.Y. has a large
    Black Jewish population so I thought there may be some who are pro
    basketball players. 
160.15Mac-cabi, Mac-cabi!NONODE::CHERSONSmartasses union, local 6.78Thu Jul 24 1986 17:1011
    As far as the U.S. is concerned, I don't think that there are Black
    Jewish basketball players.  However there is one who plays for the
    Maccabi-Tel Aviv team(which plays in the European pro league). 
    
    His name is Aulsie Perry, he was the center for them when last I
    remember.  I think that when he converted, he adopted a Hebrew name,
    but people still referred to him by his English name.  By the way
    before coming over to Israel he used to be a benchwarmer in the
    old ABA.
    
    David
160.16Kevin McgeeTAV02::CHAIMLe'ChaimMon Jul 28 1986 03:0711
    Re: .15
    
    Many of the formerly non Jewish BB players who come to play on Israeli
    teams "convert" so that they may be included in European games.
    So I really wouldn't consider these as Jewish Black BB players.
    
    There is one player, Kevin Mcgee, who according to the Israeli press
    is Jewish by virtue of the fact that his mother is Jewish.
    
    Cb.
    
160.17Convert for a job?????YOUNG::YOUNGTue Jul 29 1986 13:0515
    Huh?  Why do players have to convert to be included in European
    games?  Do they not accept non-Jewish Israeli players?
    
    Israel only recognizes Orthodox conversions, and then only by
    certain Rabbis.  Who performs these conversions?
    
    I've thought this entire note to be a bit hypocritical. The idea
    of rooting for a basketball player because he is Jewish offends
    me a bit; he could be an otherwise terrible person and even a
    lousy ball player.  But to convert to a different religion for a
    job (or for Jews to allow/encourage this!!!) seems very wrong to
    me.
    
    				Paul
    
160.18So what??NONODE::CHERSONSmartasses union, local 6.78Tue Jul 29 1986 14:0419
    Re:-1
    
    Take it easy Paul, when Chaim was referring to conversions of
    basketball players, he qualified that word with quotation marks(refer
    back to .16).  Imported players can play for there respected clubs
    during the regular season and league playoffs, but they are restricted
    from playing on the national team of that country.  In order for
    the Maccabi-Tel Aviv imports to play on the Israeli national team
    in international competition, they had to "convert", and by virtue
    of the Law of Return they can become citizens, Le Voila.
    
    By the way I wrote the basenote, and I've never seen anything wrong
    with rooting extra hard for Jewish athletes, they're my
    brothers/sisters whether they are good people or not.  Besides there
    aren't that many that obtain major status, and have to run up against
    racial stereotyping on their way up there.
    
    David
                                              
160.19Max BaerDELNI::GOLDBERGTue Jul 29 1986 15:353
    Max Baer, a heavyweight challenger for the title in the mid-30s,
    wore a Star-of-David on his boxing trunks.  Anyone know whether
    or not he was Jewish?
160.20I'm not sureNONODE::CHERSONSmartasses union, local 6.78Tue Jul 29 1986 16:287
    Re:-1
    
    I'm not sure about Max Baer, but two other famous boxers from that
    era were Jewish, one was ("Slapsie")Maxie Rosenbloom, and the other
    was Benny Leonard - one of the greatest welterweights ever.
    
    David
160.21Goldie Locks and the 3 Baers15748::POLIKOFFArnie PolikoffTue Jul 29 1986 20:392
    	The Baers are Jewish. Max, Buddy and their m and dad. Also wasn't
    Goldie Locks Jewish like Goldie Hawn and Goldie Mair?
160.22Conversions and Goldie LocksYOUNG::YOUNGWed Jul 30 1986 17:1817
    Re: .18
    
    I can understand rooting for the Jewish players, just as I can
    understand rooting for the U.S. team in the Olympics.
    
    It still doesn't answer my question about who converts basketball
    players orthodox, knowing that they are not converting because they
    belive in Judiasm.
    
    Re .21
    
    No, Goldie Locks wasn't Jewish; if she was she would not have eaten
    the porridge, it could have been traif.  Also, she is Goldie Locks,
    not Goldie Lox.
    
    				Paul
    
160.23"Our Athletic People"USFSHQ::WSUKERNEKWed Jul 30 1986 17:2332
    I've always found this topic to be interesting. Listed below 
    are famous athletes that are  'Our People':
    
    US Olympians: 
    		  Mark Spitz
    		  Mitch Gaylord
    
    Football: 
      		Sid Luckman
    		former Colts and Rams owner, Carroll Rosenbloom
    
    Soccer: 	
    		Mordecai Shpiegler
    
    Basketball:
    		Red Holzman
    		Henry Finkel  (ex-celt)
    
    Baseball:
    		Ron Blomberg
    		Joe Gordon
    		Elliot Maddox
    		Bill Singer
    		Steve Stone
    		Ken Holtzman
    
    Why is it that the majority of Jewish baseball players are pitchers?
    
    BTW- Tom Seaver does not belong to the above group!
    
    Warren
    
160.24More on thisNONODE::CHERSONSmartasses union, local 6.78Thu Jul 31 1986 16:4313
    re:.23
    
    It's still not decided as to whether Tom Seaver is Jewish or not.
    he could be a "closet Yid" for all we know.  And btw, that list
    of Jewish athletes that you listed is very incomplete.
    
    re:.22
    
    I don't know who does the converting, and frankly don't care.  If
    it's a for-real conversion, then obviously it would have to be an
    Orhtodox one.
    
    David
160.25Hank Finkel?? A nice guy, but...ULTRA::OFSEVITDavid OfsevitFri Aug 01 1986 14:0019
    re .22
    
    	Uh, Henry Finkel is definitely not a triple-O (One Of Ours).
    Else why did he cross himself before he shot free throws?
    
    	I'll give you a few Jewish pro basketball players, though:
    
    		Dave Newmark
    		Neil Walk
    		Dolph Schayes
    		Danny Schayes
    		Red Holtzman, Red Auerbach (coaches)
    		Larry Brown
    
    I'm sure there's more.  Back in basketball pre-history (before 1950)
    there were a lot of top Jewish players.  Some of the Original Celtics
    (from the '20s) were Jewish, I believe.
    
    			David
160.26oopsULTRA::OFSEVITDavid OfsevitFri Aug 01 1986 14:021
    .25 should have referred to .23, not .22.
160.27More Triple O'sSTAR::TOPAZFri Aug 01 1986 16:589
     
     A few more BB people:
              
              Red Klotz  (player/coach of the team that always 
                          loses to the Globetrotters)
              Abe Saperstein (who started the Globetrotters)
              Maurice Podoloff (1st NBA Commissioner)
     
     --Mr Topaz
160.28More adds to the incomplete list.USFSHQ::WSUKERNEKMon Aug 04 1986 17:0516
    re .24
    
    I never claimed to give the complete list--just a few people that
    came to mind when I read the topic.  By the way, if you know the
    list is incomplete, how come you haven't added any names to it?
    
    re: Tom Seaver
    
    The fact that no one has corroborated (and more have questioned)
    David's incredible claim about Tom Seaver being Jewish leads me
    to believe that he isn't.
                                
    To add to my incomplete list:
    
    NBA Commissioner David Stern
    Tennis player Harold Salomon
160.29Seaver isn't JewishCURIE::GOLDJack E. Gold, MRO3Tue Aug 05 1986 15:124
    The Jewish Catalog and Almanac has a 6 page list of Jews in baseball.
    Tom Seaver is not listed.
    
    Jack
160.30This deserves more researchNONODE::CHERSONSmartasses union, local 6.78Mon Aug 11 1986 13:455
    After a week off, I see that people are still jumping on my case
    re: Tom Seaver being Jewish.  Yes, I couldn't find his name listed
    in the Jewish Almanac either, but I'm still not totally convinced.
    
    David
160.31Evidence please...ZEPPO::MAHLERMichaelMon Aug 11 1986 13:534
    
Drop em Tom !


160.32our very own BabeDELNI::GOLDBERGThu Aug 14 1986 14:046
    From a review in today's NY Times of a book entitled, "NAMES: A
    Collector's Compendium of Rare and Unusual, Bold and Beautiful,
    Odd and Whimsical Names", by Paul Dickson.
    
    ...Moe Solomon, who played two games for the 1923 NY Giants, is
    still known in "The Baseball Encyclopedia" as "The Rabbi of Swat".