T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
1050.1 | He'll be missed. | MACNAS::JDOOLEY | Do not take anything for granted | Thu May 07 1992 05:45 | 11 |
| He was a lot better than the previous incumbent, who was very
conservative, rich, and distant from his flock.
I grew up under the influence of Dr Brown, Caseys predecessor, and
found the contrast astounding. Eamonn Casey made religion seem REAL in
a human way that Brown could never achieve.
THe danger is that we may now get a conservative, bible thumping old
goat instead and drive more young people from religion and the church
as they are not prepared to be lectured to like in the old days.
|
1050.2 | your kiddin ! | CTHQ3::COADY | | Thu May 07 1992 09:54 | 9 |
|
Are you serious ?, whats the real scoop, or will we have to wait for
the Sunday world to give all the story ++++ a bit more ?.
Eamon was always a wild man, so to speak, but if .1 is for real, surely
he had hardly expected to get away with it.
Any idea what 'new ventures' he will take on ?
|
1050.3 | | MACNAS::BHARMON | KEEP GOING NO MATTER WHAT | Thu May 07 1992 10:55 | 11 |
| Eamon was a great Bishop. He helped the poor in many ways.
He is sadily going to be missed. It is a pity he has to pay
for one silly mistake. The unfortunate part is, he will be
remembered for this mistake and all the good he did will be
forgotten.
In answer to your second question, he is joining the missionary
service, well according to the news, it is of his own choice.
Bernie
|
1050.4 | Bishop Eamon | MACNAS::TJOYCE | | Thu May 07 1992 11:13 | 26 |
|
It IS a pity about Eamon Casey. Among the Irish bishops he really
stood out. Not that he was a great liberal or anything (he wasn't)
but he was a genuinely nice man whom you could warm to as a person
no matter what. What was particularly admirable about him was his
work on behalf of the Underdeveloped World and for the poor in
Ireland.
By his own account, he wants to devote his life to "the missions"
which means Africa or Latin America.
On the down side, the "Irish Times" is reporting payments of
large sums to a lady in Connecticut over the last 15 years -
a lady with a child. There are reports of impending litigation, with
lawyers in the U.S. and Ireland involved. This is very sad and
unfortunate, but Bishop Casey will have to explain where this
money came from, if such a thing happened. His statement this
morning told us nothing except that he was resigning "for
personal reasons".
A terrible thing to happen at this time from the point of view
of the bishops, just as they are setting out to do some whacking
with the croziers when the referendums come up on abortion and
divorce.
Toby
|
1050.5 | I hope the Pope behaved himself........ | MACNAS::JDOOLEY | Do not take anything for granted | Thu May 07 1992 13:29 | 10 |
| Also, side by side with the Bishop story on todays Irish Independant is the
news that Patrick Ryan,ex Pallotine Priest and
former candidate for Sinn F�in in the European
Parliament elections and wanted for questioning in Britain, was
arrested under section 30 of the Offences against the State Act.
He can be held for 48 hours without charge and up to 7 days on the
signature of a judge. This coincides with huge arms finds in the South
of the country. Not a Good Day for Holy Mother Church and the Truth as
She Knows It.
|
1050.6 | | BERN02::BYRNE | | Fri May 08 1992 03:13 | 8 |
| If priests in the Catholic Church were allowed to marry and not live a
"sheltered" life then maybe we wouldn't have these scandals and maybe
they would see life from the other side and support divorce!!!!
After all Bsp. Casey was able to support a "family" and do some great
work!!
Therese
|
1050.7 | So Eamon was two faced! | CTHQ3::COADY | | Fri May 08 1992 09:32 | 11 |
|
I agree, but what is interesting is that Mr Casey was not a supporter
of divorce and in fact was almost of the opposite side of the fence
when it came to all similar situations.
I had always thought he was a valuable contributor to society and I
respected his view, as I assumed he lived by it ....... obviously that
was not the case.
Any ideas on who will be the new man ( or woman ) to lead West ?
|
1050.8 | At least he didnt use a condom | DBOSW2::BRENNAN_M | I drink - To make other people interesting | Fri May 08 1992 09:52 | 7 |
|
AHH! Gerry.
But sure it could happen to a bishop!!
You mean it did!!
|
1050.9 | The Woman in Question | MACNAS::TJOYCE | | Fri May 08 1992 11:09 | 27 |
|
The woman in the case has come forward and was interviewed twice
on radio today. She is Anne Murphy of Richfield, Connecticut, with
a son Peter. She met Eamonn Casey in the mid-70's on coming
to Ireland after a painful divorce. He was a friend of the family,
and the affair seems to have begun almost immediately after she
arrived here. Their relationship lasted 18 months and fell apart
after she became pregnant. He wanted her to give up the child
for adoption, she refused. The baby was born in Dublin, and she
returned to the USA with her son. There seems to have been
constant bickering over support for the child, but he did
give her money - $115,000 at one stage.
I have no problem with Ms Murphy being interviewed, but I was
apalled to hear her 17-year old son being interviewed also.
He is certainly an innocent party and should have been left
out of the publicity. I was so disgusted I turned the radio
off.
Last we heard Bishop Casey has left for the USA. There is
an outpuoring of support - nuns critising the celibacy rule
of the church etc. There has been a call for him to return
by priests and nuns here in Galway. Looks like they are waking
up to how unrealistic the rules are! Doubtful if the hierarchy
will approve though.
Toby
|
1050.10 | The Curia's the problem | POLAR::RUSHTON | տ� | Fri May 08 1992 13:54 | 22 |
| <<Looks like they are waking up to how unrealistic the rules are!
<<Doubtful if the hierarchy will approve though.
Right on, Toby. My brother, a priest for twenty-six years in the Order
of Mary Immaculate (known as the Oblates in Canada), has constantly
held the belief that some day in his lifetime he will be permitted to
disavow celibacy. Although he is a free-wheeling spirit and a bit of a
rake with not a few female admirers, I have never doubted his ability to
maintain his vows - trying as they are!
He has devoted most of his priesthood to missions in Labrador among
Native Canadians, but has just recently returned to the temptations of
the 'south'. He, and I suspect a great many of the clergy, believe
that the only way to bring about change is through the Curia in Rome.
Without change amongst that band of fossilised bureaucrats, the status
quo will remain.
My 2p worth,
Pat
|
1050.11 | | KAOFS::G_LARKIN | dtn 621-4091 | Fri May 08 1992 14:12 | 10 |
| I may have missed this earlier, but exactly why did he decide to resign
at this stage? Was it because the lady in question was about to blow the
whistle, or because he had enough of the deception, or was there some other
reason?
The Thornbirds was never as good as this!
Gerry
|
1050.12 | | TALLIS::DARCY | | Sun May 10 1992 01:27 | 5 |
| RE: .8 You're bad Martin! ;v)
How much of that $115,000 came from moneys donated to "Trocaire"?
/G
|
1050.13 | Did he go to confession ? | BONKIN::BOYLE | Clich�s - Avoid them like the plague | Sun May 10 1992 21:40 | 28 |
| This is amazing !
This guy has SEX with a DIVORCED woman and has an ILLEGITIMATE son,
then LIES about it. He then leaves the woman to bring up a child on her
own and lets the kid grow up without a father. Absolute SCUM !
Everything the church preaches against, this guy did. After that he
stands up on the pulpit week after week and tells people how to live
their life. He tells people not to get divorced (he obviously doesn't
mind the odd divorcee himself), not to use contraception (a man of his
words, uh?) and to stay together as a family etc.
The catholic church then twists the whole story around and gets people
talking about 'the poor priests' and their voluntary vow of celibacy.
The debate should be about how the clergy have said one thing and did
the opposite and about how they should not be trusted. They have been
treated like gods in Ireland over the years, obeyed without question by
large portions of the population.
I wonder how many more renegade priests will come out of the woodwork now.
Personally I say, "Ban the Bastards".
Tony.
|
1050.14 | The latest on casey | MACNAS::TJOYCE | | Mon May 11 1992 07:49 | 30 |
|
As the story become clearer, I think many people are realising the
great wrong that Bishop Casey did to this woman and her son. What
is worse from the Church's point of view is the obvious fact that
numerous priests and nuns joined with Casey in trying to persuade
her to giving up her child, and later in helping him cover up the
truth.
One can still admire Casey for his good work and look mildly on
a weakness for sexual dalliance. But the woman was sent to
him to be looked after. She was low in self-esteem after a bitter
divorce. He abused her family's trust, enjoyed his fling while
he could, but dropped her when things got rough. A classic
case! He then dodged his responsibilities for seventeen years,
meanwhile preaching about the need for families to stick together
in particular telling women how to order their lives.
While preaching at us to have "a sense of responsibility" when
it came to sexuality, he felt it o.k. to shrug off his own
responsibilities so that he could continue his career.
Certainly he deserved to be exposed for what he was.
Now again when things are rough, he flits it to South America
without a word of self-explanation or apology to the people
of Galway. While allowing for human weakness, I think he is
being let off pretty lightly.
Toby
|
1050.15 | What precipitated the resignation .... | MACNAS::TJOYCE | | Mon May 11 1992 08:00 | 26 |
|
What brought things to a head was the determination of the son,
Peter, to "blow the whistle" on Casey. They met last year and
(according to the son), Casey was cool and distant. He went
to another room, from which a priest later emerged to ask the
boy to sign a document pledging never to bother Bishop Casey
again. [Dubious note: even if he signed it would not have
been legally binding because he was a minor].
In any event, the rejection by his father festered, and this
year he told his mother he was going to go public. She decided
to do so, and spare him the pain. Seeing him in "sound bites"
on T.V. he seems a quite mature and strong individual, and you
could easily see him going through with it. The man who is
now living with Annie Murphy rang the "Irish Times" in Dublin,
who sent their American correspondent to Ridgefield, to view
the evidence. They (rightly) decided that the illegimate son
was not a legitimate story, but that the payments were, and
started asking questions accordingly.
Ms Murphy also rang Casey and told him what was going on. She
also told him that, unknown to him, Peter and a friend had
video'd a meeting between them some years ago. This seems to
have precipitated his resignation.
Toby
|
1050.16 | | BERN02::BYRNE | | Mon May 11 1992 08:21 | 20 |
| So where does this leave everyone??
I think Bishop Casey has suffered enough, or at least will suffer
enough.
The money - where did it come from. If it was filtered from donations
to the church then it was stolen. The woman may have received $115,000
of stolen money. Where else did she expect him to get the money????
My guest is that the son was bothering him for more money and he
refused hence the "going public". Nobody gains anything from it!! Or
maybe they thought they would.
He's not the first priest to get into such a situation. I know of one
who married the woman in the same circumstances. Now even though he has
a B.A H.Dip he finds it difficult to find a job. He did the decent
thing by marrying the woman but where does it get him?? Hypocrites!!!
He's shunned and spoken about by all who know of his past!!!
|
1050.17 | Amazing ! | BONKIN::BOYLE | Clich�s - Avoid them like the plague | Mon May 11 1992 08:34 | 22 |
| I just read that the bishop was with this woman for 18 months.
Asuming they were having sex on a regular basis and she only got
pregnant once he/they must have been using contraceptives (yep, I've
got a degree in gynacology too). This only adds to his 'crimes' !
What a bastard. He's shacked up with this girl while he's a bishop !
A ripper of a story. Can you imagine him getting up out of their bed
every sunday morning, going to the church and telling all those good
catholics to behave themselves. Amazing.
This must be a great time to be in Ireland. The papers must be having a
field day. I can imagine the front of the Sunday Worst yesterday,
"Bishop caught with pants down" or something similar.
I think that the church will be very quite when the debate hots up
about divorce and abortion.
I must say I'm amazed ! I never had much time for the church and it's
brainwashing, sorry, teachings and I never trusted the clergy but this
astounded me. I'm sitting here 20,000klms away in utter amazement !
Way to go Bishop casey ! You Beauuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuty !
|
1050.18 | | WMOIS::CHAPLAIN_F | Tempus Omnia Vincit | Mon May 11 1992 09:50 | 20 |
|
Don't see what the hullabaloo is all about. This sort of thing
happens, has been happening since the inception of the Church.
I wouldn't be too hard on a man who's done his best for folks, yet
in the end succumbs to the same human weakness to which almost ALL
of us succumb.
After all, he's not a rapist or an embezzler or a child-molester
or a thief. Just a man who had sex, albeit against *CHURCH* law,
with a consenting woman who must assume her own amount of
responsibility.
Anyway...although I see a benefit in maintaining celibacy among the
priesthood, I also see a perhaps greater evil in it; that being not
just the sexual part, but the isolation that is endured by those in
the priesthood that may just be more than can be expected of a normal
man, without having him resort to darker urges.
Frank
|
1050.19 | the bonkin bishop !!!! | BONKIN::BOYLE | Clich�s - Avoid them like the plague | Mon May 11 1992 10:05 | 33 |
| re. .18
>I wouldn't be too hard on a man who's done his best for folks, yet
>in the end succumbs to the same human weakness to which almost ALL
>of us succumb.
You're right of course Frank. I'm sure he has done some very good
things in his life and the noters from Galway will back this up. My
problem with the scumbag is his HYPOCRISY. He will preach one thing and
practice the opposite.
> After all, he's not a rapist or an embezzler or a child-molester
>or a thief.
We have yet to find out where he got the dosh to keep buy the woman's
silence.
> Anyway...although I see a benefit in maintaining celibacy among the
>priesthood.........
I don't see the same benefit. What is it?
If priests want to remain celibate then that's their right. But if they
want to retain any credibility with the church-going people they should
remain true to their professed beliefs.
Tony.
P.S. Have they started making the movie yet ?
Anybody got any suitable names for it ?
- Bishop bonks Betty ???????? uh ?
|
1050.20 | | KAOFS::G_LARKIN | dtn 621-4091 | Mon May 11 1992 10:27 | 8 |
| RE Celibacy
Apparently celibacy was introduced to the Catholic Church originally as
a cost saving measure back in the 11th or 12th century. It was
considered less expensive to keep single priests than whole families.
That is the only advantage I can come up with.
Gerry
|
1050.21 | | WMOIS::CHAPLAIN_F | Tempus Omnia Vincit | Mon May 11 1992 10:37 | 22 |
|
re .19
I feel, along with Aquinas, that there CAN BE a much greater sense
of accord with spiritual principles by denying oneself such intensely
HUMAN urges as sexuality, by fasting, by isolation from the community
of people. But I also feel that such spiritual rigor will truly only
benefit the extraordinary individual. What might have been appropriate
for the Ascetic vision of the Middle Ages is probably inappropriate for
the needs of modern man, including the most well-intentioned priest.
And just by-the-by, where is the responsibility of the woman in this
affair? She consented to the sexual act and therefore bears equal
responsibility for the result. What does the woman or the child want
from this affair? What do they hope to gain in besmirching the bishop
at this late date? I think it might be worthwhile to ponder their
motives.
Thanks
|
1050.22 | Answer to a question .... | MACNAS::TJOYCE | | Mon May 11 1992 11:10 | 14 |
|
Answers to some of the above questions:
"Where did she expect him to get the money?"
That was not her problem, she just had a hungry little mouth to
feed. According to her, Bishop Casey had both a Merc and a Lancia,
and was fond of good food and drink. Was she supposed to let him
be so that he could keep up his public image? He OWED support
for the child, not just $$$$ but presence and love as well.
If publicity would lose his bishopric, he could just go and try
to get a job like the rest of us.
Toby
|
1050.23 | Re: .21 | MACNAS::TJOYCE | | Mon May 11 1992 11:20 | 31 |
| What is the responsibility of the woman?
I would say that Annie Murphy bore her responsibilities bravely,
and great credit to her. She could have given up her baby for
adoption but she resisted the bullying of Casey and his henchmen,
and refused. It's a contrast to the moral cowardice shown by
the Bishop, from whom one expects good example. She brought
up her child alone for many years, while he ignored them except
for the money he sent.
What did they hope to gain at this stage?
It is the son, Peter, who seems to hurt the most at this stage. He
has been rejected by his father and feels the pain of that. Being
young he wants to hit back, or maybe he has the notion that the
Bishop can start being a real father when he has no public image
to protect. Money doesn't seem to be an issue any more, though
they are not well off. Self-respect and not living a lie any more
may have something to do with it.
Of course, now that it is in the open, they have a good opportunity
to make money. She is to write a book, and a TV film is to be made.
She has made many TV appearances, and more will follow in the US.
Good stuff, say I, it may make up in a small way for all the years
they were ignored and put down by Eamonn Casey.
I also think they have done Ireland a major service by exposing
the hypocrisy of a leading clergyman who preached responsibility
and self-control while practising neither.
Toby
|
1050.24 | Responsibilities !!! | KAOFS::G_LARKIN | dtn 621-4091 | Mon May 11 1992 11:20 | 15 |
| re. .21
Of course the woman shares EQUALLY the responsibility of bearing the
child, but, does the fact that the woman raised the child for the past
17 years not show that she bore her share. I believe if anything she
did a lot more than her share to put up with this situation for as long
as she did without saying anything.
I think that Eamon Casey has shunned his responsibilities all the way,
up to and including the fact that he left Galway without as much as an
explanation to the people who trusted him as thier spiritual leader.
Surely he must be held accountable to them somewhere along the line.
Gerry
|
1050.25 | | BERN02::BYRNE | | Mon May 11 1992 11:41 | 19 |
| Don't forget that Bp Casey is /was a Catholic and probably believed
that if he did penance for his sins then he may be forgiven by God etc.
Who knows if he repented and got forgiveness?
Let him come out and tell us his version!!
There are after all two sides to every story.
Have there been tests and is the boy really his?
We shouldn't really condemn anyone who isn't around to speak for
himself. It's obvious he is guilty of something but I don't think
anybody has the right to write a book or make a film about somebody
unless he agrees!
As the bible says "let the man who is free from sin cast the first
stone"
I'm not on his side but I would like to hear his comments!
|
1050.26 | Bonkin Bishop | CTHQ3::COADY | | Mon May 11 1992 12:45 | 10 |
|
I agree with the last note, but I find it hard to accept that the
Catholic Church, in particular the Irish one, still refuses to accept
the realities of life, both inside & outside the church.
I must admit I like the idea of the movie " Bonkin Bishop does it 10
times per nite " or " Keep it up Eamon - ya boy ya ".
life goes on .........
|
1050.27 | dead-beat Dads | LJOHUB::HORGAN | Craicailte indiadh damhsa | Mon May 11 1992 13:55 | 13 |
|
If he lived in Massachusetts, his picture would be on the side of
an MBTA bus.
How can a man bring a child into the world and then refuse to feed
and clothe it?
I also wondered why they were going on tv so much. The truth is out,
why have their faces on every tv channel?
Julia
Julie
|
1050.28 | more cover ups .. | CTHQ3::COADY | | Mon May 11 1992 15:47 | 8 |
|
and with all the news on the carryings on of priests in this area,( the
greater Mass. area ), the Catholic church has a lot to answer to,
especially about cover-ups and all that.
But then the history of Catholic Church is littered with that & worse.
|
1050.29 | Money money money | BERN02::BYRNE | | Tue May 12 1992 02:57 | 3 |
| Re .27
MONEY!!!!!!!
|
1050.30 | Statement | MACNAS::BHARMON | KEEP GOING NO MATTER WHAT | Tue May 12 1992 05:01 | 8 |
| He has issued a statement at long last and about time, admitting
Peter is his son. He has also admitted taken seventy thousand
pounds ($110,000 approx). This money has been paid back by
some idiots with interest.
Bernie
|
1050.31 | Let them practise charity, too .... | MACNAS::TJOYCE | | Tue May 12 1992 06:56 | 17 |
|
Re: .25 and "casting the first stone" ... etc.
Now that Bishop Casey had admitted his sin, perhaps the Catholic
Church can do something about making the 5000 women per year who leave
the country for abortions more accepted.
On the streets of Dublin, very unedifying epithets like "whore",
"tart", "baby-killer" and "murderer" are being flung at supporters
of abortion, not by the Bishops themselvers (of course!) but by
their young henchmen and women, organised in a movement calling
itself "Youth Defence".
No bishop or priest has yet disassociated the Church from this
movement.
Toby
|
1050.32 | One could get paranoid thinking about it..... | MACNAS::JDOOLEY | Do not take anything for granted | Tue May 12 1992 08:49 | 33 |
| A personal view:-
My c�il� band was once hired to play at a social for the Galway
branch of the Pioneer total abstinence association, an organisation
which insists on all its' members abstaining for life from all
intoxicating liqour. Eamonn Casey was the invited guest speaker.
After giving a short speech he requested backing on a few songs and
generally got the crowd going. He may not be Pavorotti but at the
least he came across as a very human and likeable man. It seems likely
in my view that he was pressurised into covering up this affair by the
Church and the established moral guardians of this country and that he
went along with them for fear of the presumed consequences.
He has apologised in the papers today for his actions and I think it
is now in Gods hands and should be left there.
It is interesting to note that this country no longer has any
institution that it can now fully trust.
The recent pardon of Nicky Kelly has shown Ireland to be no better than
Britain in the administration of justice. The cops who beat him up are
still free and in power.........
The suite of enquiries into, among others, the beef industry, the sugar
industry and improprieties in the telephone companies property
management have cast a dark shadow of doubt over the conduct of
business here.....
Connections between these scandals and politicians have also cast doubt
over the integrity of our legislators.
Now it looks as if the Church, the one remaining institution that
people thought they could trust, has some skeletons in its closet.
|
1050.34 | | TALLIS::DARCY | | Tue May 12 1992 10:39 | 14 |
| People forget that priests are human too, just like you and me,
and fall prey to all the same vices of society. The priest and
his lover both acted irresponsible and unfortunately the son
Peter will pay the price.
Although I would agree with Frank and state that Catholic priests
should be allowed to marry if they wish. I think this would be
more natural for them, and provide them with bit more insight
into the complex world of marriage and child-rearing. Also, I
believe that women should be allowed to enter the priesthood.
In my upbringing I knew several nuns who would have made great
priests.
/George
|
1050.35 | | BERN02::BYRNE | | Tue May 12 1992 10:43 | 1 |
| I think Bp. Casey paid the price - $110,000!!!
|
1050.36 | Let the catholic leaders speak up now 1 | CTHQ3::COADY | | Tue May 12 1992 11:01 | 15 |
|
I think 110k punts = $200k, thats expensive in one way, but i'm sure
it hasn't covered the costs of rearing the child, and defo won'y pay
college fees etc.
My main issue is not with the right or wrong of it, that is personal to
both parties, but for me its the fact that Eamonn & his friends have
kept Ireland in the 1800's regarding any advances in family law and in
many cases have condemned people for what the so 'high & mighty' called
wrong.
I'd suggest to the catholic leaders, to throw in the towel and let the
country move on.
|
1050.37 | | MACNAS::JDOOLEY | Do not take anything for granted | Tue May 12 1992 13:14 | 23 |
| Our birthrate has plunged since the mid-eighties to European levels,
reflecting a higher use of artificial contraceptives.
A recent opinion poll showed 80% in favour of a limited form of
abortion in cases of danger to the mother being allowed.
Three members of the D�il have revealed that they are part of second
unions which are unofficial but the only possible way to have a second
relationship in a land without divorce. THis would have been political
suicide 10 years ago.
New tax regulations are to recognise common-law marriages and treat the
couples involved the same as officially married couples for tax
purposes.
Whether the Church likes it or not, people are thinking for themselves
now and going forward in a limited way but I still can't see the day
when abortion on demand will be available here in this island. The
surgeons involved would find it difficult to be accepted in this all
too small and intimate island, where everybody knows everybody elses
business. Perhaps only Dublin is big enough to provide the necessary
anonymity.
|
1050.38 | My 2 cents worth | MEIS::HURLEY | | Tue May 12 1992 14:19 | 111 |
|
I usually keep away from controversial subjects, but since this
seems to be "Vent your Spleen" Month in CELT, here goes.
I agree in some things that Ireland and the Catholic Church
has to change although not to the full "Anything is ok that
doesn't inconvenience me " mentality.
1) Divorce
Divorce should be allowed. Priests are allowed to be relieved
of their vows. I'm sure there is also a corollary between the
lack of Divorce and a rise in the amount of Battered wives and
Children. There seems to be a thin line between a Divorce and an
Annulment. Annulments can vary from diocese to diocese. Marriage
seems to be the only mistake that can't be forgiven.
I won't blame Irelands' Divorce situation totally on the Church.
Since 1916 on, both sides ( Republicans and Free Staters) wanted
to be more Catholic than the Pope to get the Churchs' support.
The failure on the divorce referendum a few years back had as much
to do with the Financial matters ( The wife could get the farm ? etc)
as Religious just as the problems in the North are more Economic
than Religious.
2) Birth Control
Birth Control should be allowed. I see a major distinction between
preventing conception and the Abortion of an existing human being
regardless of the stage of development.
3) Ordination
Women should be allowed to be ordained. I see no reason for
the restriction. It's indoor work - no heavy lifting. The latest
excuse that the apostles were all male doesn't fit. There were
women followers with Jesus. By the way, there is no reference
in the Bible to Mary Magdelan being a prostitute. In the third
century or so, some of the Church leaders were disturbed that a
woman could have such an active role, so the Myth of Mary as a
prostitute evolved.
On the matter of Married priests, I am opposed.
The reasons for allowing married priests seems to be:
a) There is a shortage of priests because of the celibacy
rule. priests are leaving in droves to get married.
This is one of the arguments from the 60s and 70s. Although
there is a reduction of men entering the seminary, those
that are ordained are staying. mainly because they are
older, more mature and know what they want. You don't hear
much of priests leaving lately. There are also more restrictions
and psychological testing being done for admission. Programs
like Lay Deacons and Extraodinary Ministers have helped the
situation by spreading the workload.
b) A married priest would be more experience to counsel on
family problems. Marriage counseling sessions are now handled
handled more by married couples as are some of the Pre Cana
conferences. People laugh at having to go to them, but maybe
if they had paid more though to what marriage is all about
the Divorce problem wouldn't be so great. Just as financial
and other matters are handled via the Parish Council route.
My opposition to married priests are based on two reasons.
a) There has to be a full time commitment without the
distractions of family. The priest can't make a visit
to give last rites because he's coaching his sons
soccer game. Weekend masses canceled because its the
only time the kids are off from school. Its bad enough
that priests are involve in a lot of activities so
that don't have time to visit sick parishioners in the
hospital.
b) The practical problems that would arise. Where does the
family live. Additional housing would have to be built.
Now with a Pastor and a curate, you can get away with
a two or three bedroom house. With a couple of families
there, you need the extra room. I can also see it now.
"There will be a special collection today for the Mrs
new frock". There will be more financial depends on the
priests. He'll have to have a bigger salary. Will the
parishioners contribute more? based on how Americans at
the moment feel about taxes to help their schools, I doubt
more contributions would be coming in. Also, who owns what?
The ban on married clergy was put in about the 12-13 Cent
to prevent families from inheriting Church property.
In the 60s and 70s there was a movement to have the clergy
be closer to people. Be pals. The friendliness crossed over
the line to more intimate involvement. This was the time of
the Bishop Casey/Anne Murphy affair. For some of the younger
clergy, this was the first time they came in touch with their
feelings and stared to question their vocations. A lot of
traumatic decisions were made then. I don't know what Bishop
Casey was like then. I just know of what he is doing know.
I wish him well.
The Catholic Church has survived the Roman Executions, the
Crusades, Corrupt Popes, the Reformation, kinky priests and
touchy-feely Guitar masses. It will survive the Bishop Casey
affair.
I may have problems with some of the teachings. I definitely
have problems with some of the Clergy as individuals, but so
far I haven't found a better substitute for the Church. In the
words of Brendan Behan " I would rather belong to a Church founded
on the Rock of Peter than the balls of Henry VIII".
|
1050.39 | Venting my Spleens worth ;v) | TALLIS::DARCY | | Tue May 12 1992 16:04 | 12 |
| Hmm, I don't see what's wrong with having a married priest whose
full time job is being a priest. But a beeper on him/her for
important calls. The protestant clergy seem to have no problem in
managing two careers.
Parishes in the Diocese of Boston are now sharing priests between
them. There are very few parishes with more than 1 priest if even
that. In five years, lay people will be running the parishes here
completely. You can't run the Diocese of Boston with only 10 or
so new priests each year.
/G
|
1050.40 | here comes my spleen | BONKIN::BOYLE | Clich�s - Avoid them like the plague | Tue May 12 1992 20:50 | 24 |
| re. .38
>>Birth Control should be allowed. I see a major distinction between
Birth control IS allowed in Ireland. It's not allowed by the catholic
church, which is probably a good reason to prevent priests from getting
married (population explosion).
My views on divorce are quite simple. If people don't want to be
married they shouldn't have to be. If the church has a problem with
that then tough luck.
As for ordination of women/married priests. I don't care !
They can do what they like as long as they keep their noses out of
other people's business !
As for Bishop "feed my secret family on stolen money" Casey, he is the
lowest form of scum I have ever encountered. I have no respect for
hypocrites and have even less respect for men who father children and
don't contribute to their upbringing (both financially and parentally).
Tony
|
1050.41 | Depends where you live | BERN02::BYRNE | | Wed May 13 1992 03:23 | 24 |
| re .38
Priests leaving etc.
I come from Cork city from a parish of about 10,000 (used to be when I
lived there). There have been three priests from that parish who in the
last few years have left to be married - one with a huge scandal. That
is a large percentage. One can't deny that there are less and less
priests. And lets face it - teenagers don't have anytime for the older
generation so they need younger priests!
Family ties.
I don't think doctors have any problems if they're called out when
coaching their sons' football team.
Houses
As for houses, in the above mentioned parish there are three
three-bedroomed houses each housing one priest. These houses are much
bigger than those in the same parish which house families of 12
children etc.
Therese
|
1050.42 | White Collar Crime | SIOG::ODELL | | Wed May 13 1992 06:18 | 1 |
| Brings a whole new meaning to the term ....
|
1050.43 | No change uner John Paul II | MACNAS::TJOYCE | | Wed May 13 1992 10:11 | 17 |
|
From what I hear there is a world-wide shortage of preists,
particularly in the "developed world". In the USA the average
age of priests is around the 60 mark. Heterosexual priests are
becoming a rarity as none will take vows of celibacy.
Even in Ireland, combining of parishes and calling back priests
from Africa and Latin America is only a few years away.
Don"t expect change in the lifetime of this Pope. Apparently
he will only appoint hard-line orthodox clerics to bishoprics.
Eamonn Casey probably wouldn"t be a bishop today under John
Paul II. He is adamant against clerical marriages, release of
clerics from vows, contraception, and anything that sniifs
of liberal sexuality.
Toby
|
1050.44 | | KAOFS::G_LARKIN | dtn 621-4091 | Wed May 13 1992 12:19 | 14 |
| RE: Pope John Paul II
There is much speculation regarding Pope John Paul I, and his short
lived reign (30 some days), and to the possibility that he was actually
murdered. It is believed that his views were far too liberal for him to
be in charge of the Catholic Church, and that he was about to review
all of the more conservative rules by which Catholics must abide. He
was also about to launch an investigation into the financial affairs of
the Vatican....to begin on the day that he died mysteriously. The new
Pope (John Paul II) fit in much better with the older and more
conservative 'behind the scenes' leaders.
Gerry
|
1050.45 | | WMOIS::CHAPLAIN_F | Tempus Omnia Vincit | Wed May 13 1992 13:31 | 6 |
|
re .44
Faerie-tales.
|
1050.46 | Read this first | KAOFS::G_LARKIN | dtn 621-4091 | Wed May 13 1992 13:48 | 12 |
| RE. 45
Are you sure??
Read "In Gods' Name" by David Yallop and then tell me what you think. I
wouldn't be so quick to write it off without first looking at the
'facts' as they are given in this book. It may not be totally true,
possibly a lot of speculation, but there are definitely a lot of
unanswered questions, which, by the way, the Vatican refuses to answer.
Gerry
|
1050.47 | more fuel for the fire | LJOHUB::HORGAN | Craicailte indiadh damhsa | Wed May 13 1992 16:29 | 9 |
|
I'm not sure if its the same book but, my father read something
a few years ago about the Vatican and its finances. He said they
had invested money in the pharmaceutical company that manufactured
the pill. Unknowingly, I'm sure.
Julia
|
1050.48 | | KAOFS::G_LARKIN | dtn 621-4091 | Wed May 13 1992 16:30 | 3 |
| That's the book alright. And there's a lot more too!
Gerry
|
1050.49 | Chicago catholic mafia's | CTHQ3::COADY | | Thu May 14 1992 09:45 | 7 |
|
Now from waht I heard recentky there is a lot in that book about a
certain well know Chicago cardinal ............... with a very Irish
name :=).
Gerry "the other Coadys'
|
1050.50 | | KAOFS::G_LARKIN | dtn 621-4091 | Thu May 14 1992 10:08 | 5 |
| That's right, Gerry......no relation I hope.
It's well worth a read. Gives you a different perspective on things.
Gerry
|
1050.51 | Whats in a title... | SIOG::TINNELLY | Next village America.. | Thu May 14 1992 11:26 | 8 |
|
This is a true story -)
Two auld fellas sitting in a pub in Galway the other night,
ist fella said, Aura I wonder who will get the Diocese now,
and the other lad replies "sure the son will have to get it" -))
regards PeterT
|
1050.52 | For all you Conspiricy Theorists | MEIS::HURLEY | | Thu May 14 1992 12:55 | 30 |
|
"In God's Name" never actually comes out and accuses anyone
specifically with the murder of John Paul I. It does show
how a number of individuals : the Vat Sec of State, Cardinal
Cody of Chicago, Bishop Marcincus of the Vatican Bank, P2
a Italian secret society and a number of Italian bankers and
gangsters gained by his death.
It delves a lot into the financial dealings of the Vatican Bank.
When Luciano (John Paul I) was Bishop of Venice, he saw the change
in the workings of the Bank and would have made drastic reforms.
On a more humane level, it also describes how as head of the
bishops committee on the family, he wrote a report which
recommended the Church allow artificial birth control. His
brother had 10 children and he was aware of the problem.
As Pope he would have made a change.
Another interesting book on the Vatican is "La Popessa", BY
PAUL MURPHY. It is a biography of Sr Pascalini, secretary/housekeeper
to Pius XII.
The death of John Paul I was a great tragedy. The general
consensus in that the pressures and realities of the situation
were too great on his heart and he died a natural death. The
Irish Connection has to do with the finding of the body. It
was found by a num bringing his breakfast who called in Bishop
Magee, current Bishop of Cloynes who is a candidate for Galway.
|
1050.53 | ?? | LUNER::ROBERTS | Insert coins here | Thu May 14 1992 13:07 | 9 |
|
may as well ask this here....Is the name McNamarra or is there an Irish
name that means "son of the bishop"?
Sky News had a Priest on a few nights ago and I swear he said this.
Gary
|
1050.54 | | TALLIS::DARCY | | Thu May 14 1992 13:24 | 3 |
| Son of a priest would be MacAntagart, MacTargert, McTargat, or
similar conbinations. I'm not sure what son of a bishop would
be. What's the Irish for bishop?
|
1050.55 | ang him. | MACNAS::LBURKE | | Thu May 14 1992 16:28 | 7 |
|
I think this guy should be stoned. What kind of example is this to
give to good-living Catholics like myself who lead sinfree lives while
listening to their preaching from pulpits and then poling parishoners.
I will even cast the first stone.
Les.
|
1050.56 | Stoned - in what manner ? | CTHQ3::COADY | | Thu May 14 1992 17:09 | 4 |
|
he probably was stoned :=)
|
1050.57 | Couldn't resist | TALLIS::DARCY | | Fri May 15 1992 01:51 | 3 |
| Did you heard that Aer Lingus announced a special offer this summer?
Children of celibate priests fly for free. ;v)
|
1050.58 | It's ok. Bend over I'm a priest. | BONKIN::BOYLE | Clich�s - Avoid them like the plague | Fri May 15 1992 01:58 | 6 |
| On the Channel 9 news here the newscaster announced that Eamon was
"...taking up the missionary position in South America".
|
1050.59 | hmmm?? | LUNER::ROBERTS | SON! U'r gonna jail for havintoomuchfun | Fri May 15 1992 06:18 | 5 |
|
I wonder if the "stone him" crowd is a little jealous about not having
the "time of his life" while this bishop has.
Gary
|
1050.60 | Anim an Easpaig | MACNAS::JMAGUIRE | T�g go bog � | Fri May 15 1992 08:53 | 5 |
| re: a few back
Son of a bishop: Mac an Easpaig, Mac an Giolla Easpaig
Which have been anglisied to McAnespie and Gillespie respectively.
|
1050.61 | | KAOFS::G_LARKIN | dtn 621-4091 | Fri May 15 1992 09:29 | 6 |
| RE .55
Les, Try to ignore this incident and get on with your 'sin free' life
as before. I know you.....you can do it.
Gerry
|
1050.63 | MY GOD YOUS HAVE ALL GOT VERY SERIOUS | DBOSW2::BRENNAN_M | I drink - To make other people interesting | Fri May 15 1992 13:04 | 6 |
|
You.
Peters pence takes on a new meaNING
MBR
|
1050.64 | A new language | MACNAS::TJOYCE | | Mon May 18 1992 05:24 | 12 |
|
I think The Sun (or the Star) reached a new low on Saturday
"MY NIGHTS WITH VIRGIN BISHOP" screamed the headline. Not
that Annie Murphy probably said anything of the sort, but
tabloids are capable of rather free interpretation ....
More humourously, chatting with a friend the other day about
Eamonn Casey, I used the word "bishopric" in innocence and
he almost bust a gut laughing. Guess that expression takes
on a whole new meaning now .....
Toby
|
1050.66 | It's me, NOT him | BONKIN::BOYLE | Clich�s - Avoid them like the plague | Thu May 21 1992 01:12 | 27 |
| Fellow noters and read-only people,
I have had mail from a guy who shares the same name as me who works in
Galway. Some people have read my entries here (especially 1050.40) and
asumed it was this guy who entered them. These people seem to have
forwarded a copy of the note around the Galway plant blaming the other
Tony Boyle on writing it. Mr. Boyle has become upset about this and has
asked me to "clear his name".
So, for the record :
IT WAS NOT WLDWST::BOYLE (31093::BOYLE), IT WAS ME.
I am based in Melbourne, Australia, not Galway, Ireland.
Regards,
The REAL Tony Boyle !!!!
P.S. If people have problems with what they read in Notes files, reply
in the notes file; don't extract the note and send it around the
office - especially when you're UNSURE of your facts.
|
1050.67 | | BERN02::BYRNE | | Thu Jun 04 1992 10:24 | 8 |
| WILL SOMEONE SET THE RECORD STRAIGHT PLEASE!
Are Galway and Kerry together part of the SEE of which Casey was Bishop
are are they separate?
Therese
ps think its called a SEE!
|
1050.68 | No | MACNAS::BHARMON | KEEP GOING NO MATTER WHAT | Tue Jun 16 1992 12:50 | 7 |
| Therese,
No Galway and Kerry are seperate. Eamon Casey was bishop of Kerry,
then he was moved to Galway.
Bernie
|
1050.69 | | KAOOA::GLARKIN | | Wed Jun 17 1992 08:33 | 22 |
| Bishop Casey was giving out Communmion at Mass
Body of Christ............
Body of Christ............
Body of Christ............
Then he comes to Annie Murphy........
Christ, what a body.......
Gerry
|