[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference tallis::celt

Title:Celt Notefile
Moderator:TALLIS::DARCY
Created:Wed Feb 19 1986
Last Modified:Tue Jun 03 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1632
Total number of notes:20523

739.0. "news coverage" by RDVAX::ALBIE () Wed Apr 04 1990 14:49

Need some help...

I am currently taking a Graduate level course which deals with news 
coverage of events by news organizations worldwide.   I am in process of
preparing a term paper in which I will be contrasting news coverage of the
following topics by various newspapers worldwide.

I will be contrasting the coverage by U.S. newspapers;
on  Invasion of Granada and Falkland\Malvinas war
by the New York Times, Washington Post, and possibly the Boston Globe
       (the Globe is a New England regional paper)                              

In addition to contrasting coverage by U.S. papers, I must also bring in
international news coverage from news organizations such as:

London Times, Irish Times, and manchester Guardian Weekly

The goal is to obtain not just a contrast of how U.S.News media covered 
these events, but also to contrast coverage from different 
perspectives (non-U.S. news media), as well as bring another level which 
would be right and left wing perspectives.

What I would like to know is, how could I obtain electronic copies of
the London Time, Irish Times, and Manchester Guardian Weekly (only those
articles dealing with their coverage of the above listed topics).

Thanks, Joan

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
739.1Don't believe what you readUBEAUT::BOYLETony Boyle, Melbourne, AustraliaThu Apr 05 1990 04:1211
>The goal is to obtain not just a contrast of how U.S.News media covered 
>these events, but also to contrast coverage from different 
>perspectives (non-U.S. news media), as well as bring another level which 
>would be right and left wing perspectives.

	You may be supprised to find something else.

	- An excellent example of good old British CENSORSHIP !

		  (or Media-Gagging)
739.2whose truth is it?RDVAX::ALBIEThu Apr 05 1990 13:4913
    Perhaps you are right..but will it be in a form that can be recognized?
    
    The image of the U.S. press here is that it is uncensored unless in
    wartime....that is, no formal censorship....however, that is not to
    say that what gets published by news organizations is the "truth."
    
    A quick analysis of the "sources" from which reporters/journalists
    obtain their information can often reveal whose version of reality is
    published.. So, generally speaking, reading the news is a lot of work
    just to sort out and understand the hidden meanings and nuances
    contained in a news report.  I may be surprised with the results I come
    up with after an analysis of various accounts of the topic areas I
    mentioned...but then again, I may not be...Joan
739.3USWAV1::CHAPLAINFri Apr 06 1990 08:2528
    
      Some years ago I took a course titled "International News
    Interpretation".  It was quite the eye-opener.  We compared and
    contrasted news coverage of numerous events as reported by European,
    Asian, and American sources.  Among the issues studied were the 
    downing of the Korean airliner by the Russians and the US bombing
    of Libya which took place during the time when the course was
    being given.
    
      It was fascinating to observe the biased nature of the reports.
    Coverage of the both events in American newspapers was marked by 
    almost rabid diatribe, denouncing the Russians and expressing glib
    satisfaction over the Libyan bombing.  The problem, of course, was
    that reasoned coverage of the *facts* of both events was blatantly
    absent in US papers while European and Asian publications were far
    more restrained and rational.  
    
      The major discrepancy in the American news involved the OMISSION of 
    various facts surrounding each event, such as the deviation of the
    course of the Korean airliner and the coverage of civilian casualties
    in Libya, which WERE reported in the foreign journals.  
    
      In other words, read the news with a jaundiced eye, be discriminate,
    and reserve final judgement based solely on the news coverage of 
    biased publications.
    
    Frank
     
739.4is it the same event?RDVAX::ALBIEWed Apr 11 1990 14:2714
    ref .3
    
    Basically this is the same type of course...analyzing the coverage of
    the Invasion of Grenada by various news organizations, and then doing
    the same thing with the Falkland Islands/Malvinas war coverage.
    
    Since I have to write a 20 page graduate-level research paper, it is
    expected that I provide some insight into the various reasons for these
    differences in coverage..by U.S., European, and Asian press..and assign
    some responsibility for the variances...be they cultural, governmental 
    restrictions, or even the infrastructure of the news industry...
    
    Any views of readers of this notesfile are welcome as to what you
    attribute the wide disparities in coverage....Joan
739.5celts on both sidesCLOSET::WALTERSThu Apr 12 1990 10:5114
    
    There's an interesting Celtic aspect to the Malvinas/Falklands war that you
    might come across in your studies.
    
    Argentina has a large Welsh community in Patagonia, where the Welsh
    language was (and still is) preserved.  During the Falklands war, 
    the Argentinian forces contained conscripts from this community and the
    British forces also contained its Welsh contingent.  There were some
    news reports of Welsh-speaking members of both sides talking together
    after the conflict.

    Regards
    
    Colin.
739.6who/what/whereRDVAX::ALBIEThu Apr 12 1990 11:596
    Colin, I haven't seen any mention of this in any of the materials I
    have reviewed so far...(in fact, I haven't any good source of materials
    yet from the Argentinian perspective).
    
    Could you, or other readers, point me to where I might find what you
    are referring to in your note (conscripts).  Joan 
739.7SourceCLOSET::WALTERSFri Apr 27 1990 11:0211
    
    Joan,
    
    Communications from the old country reveal that the story was
    reported in the South Wales Echo, Cardiff published by the Thomson
    Press.
    
    Regards,
    
    Colin