T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
127.1 | | TSC01::MAILLARD | | Thu Feb 05 1987 07:04 | 11 |
| Re .0: Rene, your account is essentially correct as far as facts
are concerned. I don't intend to give an opinion about its orientation
as I don't think I'm entitled to enter such a discussion, not being
Irish myself, but you sure have a problem spelling people's names.
Countess Marachev might have existed, but she sure had nothing to
do with Irish history. I think you meant Countess Markiewicz, but
I'm myself not really sure of the spelling. Also "Willie Mc Bride"
was not, to my knowledge, sung by the Furies, if such a group exists,
but by the Furey Brothers and Davey Arthur.
Please go on with the following chapters.
Denis.
|
127.2 | | KAOFS::MUX_USER | | Thu Feb 05 1987 08:45 | 8 |
| ....and the song, oddly enough, was written by a Glaswegian living in
Australia. The same man, whose name escapes me, also wrote "and
the Band Played Waltzing Matilda"
Keep up the good work, Rene.
Mike McCrohan
|
127.3 | I MADE A MISTAKE | FNYFS::AUNGIER | Rene Aungier, Ferney-Voltaire, France | Thu Feb 05 1987 08:48 | 22 |
| Denis,
I know that I have maybe in some cases spelt the name incorrectly
but unfortunately I have have all my source material here to check
the spelling. Essentially I can trying to give a brief outline and
to give the chance for people to read some books about the period.
I am no historian and its orientation Denis is exactly as it happened.
I may have skipped some things or ommitted them only because as
you may well appreciate, I don't have the time to transcribe any
books.
The group is sometimes called the Furies by Irish people but you
are correct that their full title is "The Fury Brothers and Davy
Arthur". The song is called "The Green Fields Of France", the person
the sing about is Willie Mc Bride.
Its a long time ago and I am sure that I can be forgiven for the
hopefully few errors.
Thanks anyway for pointing it out
Rene
|
127.4 | | TSC01::MAILLARD | | Thu Feb 05 1987 11:53 | 8 |
| Re .2,.3: I can't recall the author's last name right now either,
but his first name is Eric. As for the Fureys, I can well understand
why they are called the Furies: last time we had them in the folk
club I was then managing, they stopped to play only a 5AM and this
only because the bar ran out of beer. They were floating on an ocean
of empty beer bottles and Finbar was actually playing his uilleann
pipes kneeling... (it was 6 six years ago now...)
Denis.
|
127.5 | Eric Bogle | WELMTS::MANNION | | Thu Feb 05 1987 12:00 | 5 |
| It was Eric Bogle. He came from Scotland originally, Perth or Stirling,
can't remember which. His songs are beautiful but I don't like him
singing them, he's only average as a singer.
Phillip
|
127.6 | What Eric did next | WELMTS::MANNION | | Thu Feb 05 1987 12:09 | 2 |
| And then he went to live in Australia, perhaps that was Perth.
|
127.7 | A Terrible Beauty is Born | TALLIS::DARCY | George @Littleton Mass USA | Thu Feb 05 1987 14:31 | 21 |
| Thanks Rene for the history - heres a few words from the forefathers
concerning nationality and in particular languages.
Padraig MacPiarais (Patrick Pearse):
"Irish nationality is an ancient spiritual tradition, and the Irish
nation could not die as long as that tradition lived in the heart
of one faithful man or woman. But had the last repositor of the
Gaelic tradition, the last unconquered Gael, died, the Irish nation
was no more. Any free state that might thereafter be erected in
Ireland, whatever it might call itself, would certainly not be the
historic Irish nation."
Jamese Connolly:
"It is well to remember that nations which submit to conquest or
races which abandon their language in favour of that of an oppressor
do so, not because of their altruistic motives, or because of a
love of brotherhood of man, but from a slavish and cringing spirit,
from a spirit which cannot exist side by side with the revolutionary
idea."
|
127.8 | The Green Fields of France | SSGVAX::OCONNELL | Irish by Name | Fri Feb 13 1987 11:55 | 2 |
| Be forwarned...in case you ever want to learn "The Green Fields
of France", DON'T get the words from the Fureys.
|
127.9 | Eric (not in the red) | AYOV15::ASCOTT | Alan Scott, FMIC, Ayr, Scotland | Mon Feb 16 1987 11:24 | 15 |
| RE .5 etc - as I recall, Eric (what Eric did next, etc) came from
Peebles (a small town in south Central Scotland, maybe midway between
the central industrial belt and the Border area nearer England).
He got to some prominence as a writer of folk songs - agree what .6
said about him being a low-key, average-sounding performer (to my taste
anyway). What really surprised me about his biography was his
profession - he's an accountant - and that he gave up folk singing
altogether after going to Australia, to concentrate on his job. I
think he's been coaxed out of retirement occasionally, but sounds like
a strange mix of sensitive lyricist and hard-headed bean-counter.
The "Green Fields of France" is about a Scottish soldier, of course,
despite the references to 1916, greenery, etc - but the Fureys do
a pretty effective performance.
|
127.10 | Whereabouts of Eric | MEO78B::FARRELL | | Thu Feb 26 1987 23:39 | 14 |
| Eric Bogle,sad to say, lives not in Perth but in Adelaide. Also,
the husband of the late Sandy Denny (trevor Lucas not sure of the
spelling)lives there too. eric Bogle is still writing and giving
occassional tours. If Eric Bogle is average then how low do you
rate Finbar Furey ?? With so many good singers in Ireland it is a pity that
Finbar inflicts himself on the public.
The best version of the 'Grenn fields of France ' that I have heard
was from a lady whose name is pronounced June Tabor (I'll try to
get the spelling organised - only heard it on radio)
Long live he music of Planxty - they could play and sing !!
- Joe
|
127.11 | | TSC01::MAILLARD | | Fri Feb 27 1987 05:48 | 6 |
| Re .10: June Tabor IS the correct spelling. As for Finbar his voice
has never been among his strong points: He's the group's piper,
and a very good one (or at least used to be, but I don't know how
he's been playing recently; booze being another of his strong points,
his playing on the uilleann pipes might not be as good as it was).
Denis.
|
127.12 | More comments on singers/bands | SSGVAX::OCONNELL | Irish by Name | Tue Mar 03 1987 09:38 | 26 |
| I too remember when Finbar's piping was excellent. Unfortunately
the only adjective I can now apply is "showy". It lacks the emotive
qualities it used to have in the early years when he was in
competition. Personally, I can't stand the Furey's anymore. I
still like fun music, I guess what I've grown out of is music that's
fast for the sake of being fast, loud for the sake of being loud,
and excessive drinking on stage that give the *musician* the impression
that he/she's terrific, but the audience (unless they are also drunk
out of their minds) the sense that the performance has deteriorated
over the course of the evening. Sound preachy?? Well let's just
say I paid for the ticket, therefor I expect a certain level of
professionalism and a good time.
There are plenty of groups around that fit the bill: The Boys of
the Lough for one. Moloney, O'Connell and Keane (although I must
confess to being biased there -- but my musical integrity stands
intact when I recommend this group), Tannahill Weavers, DeDanaan,
Clannad, The Chieftans, Silly Wizard, Relativity, and host of solo
musicians who value and respect their audience enough to make their
music something worth sharing. June Tabor is a great singer. She's
been around for a long time and has done work with other British
singers and musicians. I think she was one of the singers in Peter
Bellamy's folk-opera "The Transports". Great stuff!
Roxanne
|
127.13 | More on the GREEN FIELDS OF FRANCE | WAGON::FEELEY | | Thu Mar 12 1987 08:53 | 11 |
|
I think THE GREEN FIELDS OF FRANCE is such a beautiful song that
any singer who is halfway decent can do a moving rendition ot it.
But I have yet to hear anyone do it any better than Liam Clancy.
I think he can sing ballads better than anyone.
By the way, Liam Clancy and Tommy Makem are singing on St. Paddy's
Day at Mechanics Hall in Worcester.
--Jay
|