[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference rusure::math

Title:Mathematics at DEC
Moderator:RUSURE::EDP
Created:Mon Feb 03 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2083
Total number of notes:14613

1818.0. "English 50 pence piece question" by WARNUT::THOMASA (Wow I,ve got a colour ....) Fri Dec 03 1993 05:25

Hi all,
	Sorry if this is the wrong conference for such trivia, but 
I seem to recall someone on the TV the other day claiming that the 
English 50 pence piece was a special mathematical object that despite
not being circular has a constant radius, and thus if a car tire was made 
in the same shape, the car could be driven with out any "bumping up and down"


	Looking at a 50 pence piece in my hand ( a 7 pointed coin with the
opposite edges to the point being cut from some sort of arc from a much large
circle) its very hard to believe what I saw on TV.

	Does anyone know more about this mathematical curiosity ?

	regards

	Andy T  
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1818.1FORTY2::PALKAFri Dec 03 1993 08:4529
    This kind of thing is quite common. The coin has a constant width. It
    doesn't really have a constant radius, as it doesn't have a centre. You
    couldn't make a wheel or tyre with this shape (as there is no 'centre'
    to it, and it rotates about various points), but you could make a
    roller with this cross section, and the roller would support something
    at constant height above the ground. Of course the C of G of the roller
    would go up and down as it rotates, so you wouldn't get a truly smooth
    ride out of it.
    
    Non-circular coins are usually made in this way, as they can be handled
    by slot machines much more easily than it they did not have a constant
    width.
    
    The sides of the 50p piece are not arbitrary arcs - the centre of the
    circle from which the arc is formed is at the opposite corner on the
    coin. The 'diameter' of the coin is the radius of the arc.
    
    If you have the coin resting on one edge and rotate it slightly the
    opposite corner will remain at the same height above the surface. As
    you continue to rotate the coin it will come to a point where it rests
    on a corner. As it rotates further the highest point on the side
    opposite this corner will always be the same height above ground.
    
    This is one of the simplest forms of shapes with constant width. You
    can make more complicated ones which have arcs of different radius and
    are based on irregular polygons.
    
    Andrew
    
1818.2FORTY2::PALKAFri Dec 03 1993 08:5518
    The 20p coin is a similar, but slightly more interesting shape.
    
    It also has 7 sides, but the sides dont meet at a point. Each 'point'
    is somewhat more rounded. The coin is really much more like a 14 sided
    figure, with each side being an arc. There are 2 radiuses of these
    arcs, used alternately. A small one of about 4 mm, and a larger one of
    about 17mm. The result is much rounder than the 50p piece.
    
    The actual curve may be more complicated still, involving a
    continuously variable 'radius' to the arc - its not easy to tell from
    the sample in my pocket.
    
    Actually the 50p might also be such a shape, with radii of about 0.5mm
    and 30mm. This would remove the 'sharpness' of a corner, which would be
    subject to rapid wear resulting in a variation of diameter which might
    be difficult for slot machines to deal with.
    
    Andrew
1818.3RTL::GILBERTWed Dec 08 1993 13:302
    Can you give an example of a closed curve with constant width
    such that the boundary isn't made of circular arcs?