[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference rocks::weight_control

Title: Weight Loss and Maintenance
Notice:**PLEASE** enter notes in mixed case (CAPS ARE SHOUTING)!
Moderator:ASICS::LESLIE
Created:Mon Jul 09 1990
Last Modified:Tue Jun 03 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:933
Total number of notes:9931

521.0. "Common Diet Myths & REAL facts" by DELNI::BASSETT (Design) Thu Oct 12 1989 21:57

    MYTH: Dieting is more important thatn exercise.
    FACT: Not so.  Lack of exercise is the single biggest reason why people
    	are over weigth.
    
    MYTH: Salt is Fattening.
    FACT: Salt has no calories so it's not fattening -- although it can
   	 cause some people to retain water.
    
    MYTH: You can trust your calorie guide.
    FACT: Diet books that provide lists of foods and the number of calories
    	they contain usually give calorie counts for portions that are much
    	smaller than those you're likely to eat.  You should weigh food portions
   	to make sure you're getting an accurate calorie count.
    
    MYTH: Dieting is always difficult.
    FACT: It doen't have to be.  The key to successful dieting is finding
    	the fatty foods you can easily cut down on.  Make choices you can live
    	with.
    
    MYTH: When you diet you'll have to give up favorite foods.
    FACT: Wrong.  You can actually continue eating favorite foods, but in
    	smaller amounts.  When you do indulge in a favorite fatty food,
    	compensate by cutting out another fatty food you don't like as much.
    
    MYTH: Health foods are low in calories.
    FACT: Some of the so-called health foods are very high in fat.  A bowl
    	of granola cereal, for instance, has around 600 calories.
    
    MYTH: Salad bars are excellent for dieters.
    FACT: Salad dressing can make a salad high in fat and calories.
    
    MYTH: Diet specials in restaurants are good choices if you're trying to
    	lose weight.
    FACT: Most of the so-called specials in restaurants actually contain
    	more calories than you'd get with a simple turkey samdwich, salad and
    	apple.
        
    

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
521.1Good TipsATSE::BLOCKLooking for Galt's Gulch...Thu Oct 12 1989 22:3520
    
>    MYTH: Salad bars are excellent for dieters.
>    FACT: Salad dressing can make a salad high in fat and calories.

    Well, I agree with your fact, but I also feel that the "myth" is also
    fact.  Salad bars are great, *if* you know what foods are fattening and
    which aren't.  Cheese and meats add calories fast, as do prepared salads
    (such as cole slaw and tuna).  Salad dressing is okay in moderation; just
    don't use gobs of it.
    
    A lot more restaurants are having more realistic diet specials these days
    -- it's not that unusual to see broiled chicken with veggies on a menu. 
    What's really important to successful weightloss and maintenance is
    knowing what's really in the foods you eat -- how fatty they are, or how
    much protein they have -- and how much of the various nutrients and food
    groups you should be getting.

    Beverly
    

521.2LESLIE::LESLIEBlackadder the 7thFri Oct 13 1989 05:0077
    
    Well I'm astonished at .0 and have felt constrained to reply with what
    I consider the REAL facts to be. Feel free to argue.
    
    - Andy ��� Leslie
    ======================================================================
    
>    MYTH: Dieting is more important thatn exercise.
>    FACT: Not so.  Lack of exercise is the single biggest reason why people
>    	are over weigth.
    
    FACT: Diet and exercise go hand in hand. Overeating for the level of
    exercise you take is the single biggest reason for obesity.
    
>    MYTH: Salt is Fattening.
>    FACT: Salt has no calories so it's not fattening -- although it can
>   	 cause some people to retain water.
    
    FACT: Salt causes *all* mammals to retain water in order to cope with
    the addition minerals in their body. A pint of water weighs a pound and
    a quarter.  Inordinate amounts of salt can cause other digestive
    illnesses.
    
    
>    MYTH: You can trust your calorie guide.
>    FACT: Diet books that provide lists of foods and the number of calories
>    	they contain usually give calorie counts for portions that are much
>    	smaller than those you're likely to eat.  You should weigh food portions
>   	to make sure you're getting an accurate calorie count.
    
    FACT: Trust the calorie guide that states the weight tested to give the
    calorific value. If you limit your calorific intake by weight, this
    WORKS. (I know! Believe me!)
    
>    MYTH: Dieting is always difficult.
>    FACT: It doen't have to be.  The key to successful dieting is finding
>    	the fatty foods you can easily cut down on.  Make choices you can live
>    	with.
    
    FACT: Achieving a permanent weightloss is difficulty because it
    involves changing your exercise and eating habits PERMANENTLY.
    "Dieting" in itself is intrinsically USELESS.
    
>    MYTH: When you diet you'll have to give up favorite foods.
>    FACT: Wrong.  You can actually continue eating favorite foods, but in
>    	smaller amounts.  When you do indulge in a favorite fatty food,
>    	compensate by cutting out another fatty food you don't like as much.
    
    FACT: If your favourite foods are calorific and fat laden then you must
    change your diet PERMANENTLY to retain any weightloss. Cutting out
    foods that are better for you in terms of saturated fats and calories
    is a BIG mistake.
    
>    MYTH: Health foods are low in calories.
>    FACT: Some of the so-called health foods are very high in fat.  A bowl
>    	of granola cereal, for instance, has around 600 calories.
    
    FACT: "health" food is generally hype, Cultivate the ability to read
    labels.
    
>    MYTH: Salad bars are excellent for dieters.
>    FACT: Salad dressing can make a salad high in fat and calories.
    
    FACT: This is true. If you choose to accompany your "good" foods with
    high-cal high-fat foods, your "diet" is bunk.
    
>    MYTH: Diet specials in restaurants are good choices if you're trying to
>    	lose weight.
>    FACT: Most of the so-called specials in restaurants actually contain
>    	more calories than you'd get with a simple turkey samdwich, salad and
>    	apple.
    
    FACT: Common sense never stopped you ordering the right foods in a
    restaurant. Taking somebodys word that a dish is low-cal when it
    blatantly isn't is NOT common sense.
    

521.3- shape yWMOIS::FAVREAUFri Oct 13 1989 08:2613
    
    
    re. 521.0
    
    I see we read the same magazines.  I received my new issue of SHAPE
    yesterday and keyed in on the same article.  If I had the issue
    here I would add to this note the writers/analayzers of Myth & Facts.
    People tend to view things differently once they know who wrote it.
    
    ...
    val
    

521.4pounds .ne. fatCNTROL::JENNISONFri Oct 13 1989 09:2714
    
    re .2
    
    	Regarding salt, it will make you retain water.  Retained water
    	will make you "weigh" more.  But, retaining water shouldn't make
    	you overfat.  I believe that is the 'myth' they are trying to
    	dispel (as they mention water retention).
    
    	BTW, I think you're doing great.  Keep it up! (or should I say
    	down?  hmm...)
    
    Karen
    

521.5A pint's a pound, the world aroundATSE::BLOCKLooking for Galt's Gulch...Fri Oct 13 1989 11:3220
	Andy,

	Are you sure a pint of water is 1� lb?  I always thought it was
	exactly 1 pound.  It's one of the few such relationships I keep
	track of easily (see the title).

	I also disagree that it's necessary to cut out favorite foods 
	permanently.  They should be kept to reasonable portions; a 
	good food plan has room for such things (inn WW it's handled as
	weekly optional calories).  No, I shouldn't count ice cream as 
	milk + fat, but if I can never have it, I'll start feeling 
	deprived and go back to my old, uncontrolled ways.

	The rest of what you said I agree with, though I think some of 
	it is just saying what .0 said in a clearer way.	

	Beverly


521.6LESLIE::LESLIEBlackadder the 7thFri Oct 13 1989 12:154
    Ah..... a US pint is 16 fl oz. whereas a UK pint is 20!
    
    Explains the weight diff.

521.7LESLIE::LESLIEBlackadder the 7thFri Oct 13 1989 12:2020
    I didn't mean "cut out favourite food permannently", but then again,
    maybe I did. 
    
    The habits one gains over the years are the key to obesity - if your
    favourite food was high in cholesterol and you were tested and shown to
    be dangerously high in cholesterol, would you find it easier to cut
    down or cut it out? 
    
    Having answered that question, we should realise that obesity is more
    life-threatening than cholesterol, although they both go hand in hand
    in assisting stuff like heart disease to kill us.
    
    Personally, I'd prefer none to a tantalising taste. I always was a
    more-ish person and if it tasted good - I had more!
    
    A change of eating habits should be just that, in my opinion.
    
    - Andy ��� Leslie
      VMS CSSE Newbury

521.8If you can control the portion, allowing a litle is okayATSE::BLOCKLooking for Galt's Gulch...Fri Oct 13 1989 18:4126
	For some people, for some foods, it's definitely better to avoid 
	them completely.  I used to be that way with sugar (in any form),
	but over time I've found that I can have it once in a while, after
	meals.  

	I think it's unrealistic to say "never eat it if it's bad for you."
	This is the mindset that causes people to give up on diets, because
	they feel deprived, either in everyday life or on social occasions.
	Any slip is a major infraction; you're a failure, so you might as 
	well give up.

	I agree wholeheartedly that it's necessary to learn proper eating 
	habits, rather than a diet, but that has to include being livable
	(whatever that means to you).

	Over the past 5 days, since I've been able to eat wheat, I've found
	that I'm not thinking about food all the time, and I'm not hungry
	very often.  I think a lot of this is a result of the fact that I 
	no longer resent being unable to have things I want.  I can look 
	at them and decide that I don't really want that now, since I know
	it'll be there later when I really do.  It's a liberating experience.

	Beverly


521.9ANT::ZARLENGAnow I *have to* clean the house!Fri Oct 13 1989 22:5310
	Excellent base note, DELNI::BASSETT!
    
    Myth: Exercise has to make you sweat.
    Fact: Low intensity exercise, like walking at a slow pace will
	    burn a higher percentage of fat, than a high intensity
	    exercise, like running.
    
    -mike z

521.10ANT::ZARLENGAnow I *have to* clean the house!Fri Oct 13 1989 23:0019
.2>    FACT: Diet and exercise go hand in hand. Overeating for the level of
.2>    exercise you take is the single biggest reason for obesity.

    	Sort of.  People who exercise regularly, have more flexible
    metabolisms, they can eat even more extra calories than the amount
    consumed by the exercise, and still not gain the extra calories
    as weight.

        
.2>    a quarter.  Inordinate amounts of salt can cause other digestive
.2>    illnesses.

    	Only people with kidney dysfunction ened worry about salt intake.
    
    	This has been discussed at length in either MEDICAL or HOLISTIC.

    -mike z