[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference rocks::weight_control

Title: Weight Loss and Maintenance
Notice:**PLEASE** enter notes in mixed case (CAPS ARE SHOUTING)!
Moderator:ASICS::LESLIE
Created:Mon Jul 09 1990
Last Modified:Tue Jun 03 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:933
Total number of notes:9931

400.0. "DOES ANYONE HAVE BIG BONE DEPRESSION?" by ERLANG::MAHONEY () Wed Feb 15 1989 11:22

I was wondering if anyone else had this problem.  BIG BONES - AND WEIGHING
    MUCH MORE THAN YOU LOOK LIKE YOU WEIGH AND BEING VERY SELF CONCIOUS
    ABOUT IT.  My whole family has big bones - mostly from my fathers
    side - my mother is pretty average.  I have wide shoulders and long
    arms and fingers.  I went thru a chubby stage when I was about 13
    -I am now 21 and then got taller and thinned out.  The problem is
    that I get really self concious about the numbers on the scale.
     I graduated high school weighing 148 5feet 7 inches but wearing
    size 7's and 5's - about the same as my girlfriend who weighed 115
    pounds and had small bones.  I was always self concious about it
    and would never tell anyone how much I weighed.  I got married two
    years ago and slowly gained almost 20 pounds but could still fit
    into 7's and 9's.  The main reason I think was lack of excercise
    - I excercised all the time before I got married but now with working
    full-time and taking care of a husband and a house time is limited.
     I wouldn't even tell my husband how much I weighed until a few
    months ago.  He always said I looked good.  Well 6 weeks ago I joined
    weight watchers with my mom - she is 51 and is getting middle spread
    but she wears a 12 or 14.  Well in six weeks I have lost 14 pounds
    and now I fit into clothes that I wore in high school when I was
    my thinnest.  7's and 5's.  But I still weigh 155.  My goal is 140
    and by then I am not sure what size I will be in.  But I am still
    very self-concious about the numbers.  I was just wondering if anyone
    else had this problem and how you get around it.  I have a feeling
    that even when I get to 140  I won't be happy with that number but
    will be wearing 5's and 3's.  I don't want to be skinny skinny but
    I can't get the numbers out of my head.

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
400.1Lucky you!HPSRAD::LEWISWed Feb 15 1989 11:4518
    I suspect you've answered your own question. The numbers on the
    scale mean absolutely nothing. If *you're* pleased with the way
    you look then that's all that matters. If it will make you feel
    better, look into having a bodyfat test done. That will tell you
    how much of your weight is muscle and how much is fat. If you're
    wearing 5's and 7's I'd guess most of your weight is muscle. And
    if that's true, you don't want to weigh any less as that could bring
    on health problems -- from too low bodyfat.  You may want to check 
    other things like cholesterol levels and such to assure yourself that 
    you're healthy. 
    
    Then, if people comment about your weight just nod your head and
    say something about how lucky you are and how you carry your weight
    well. 
    
    I'm pea-green with envy, personally.
    

400.2Percentage of fatRIPPLE::KOTTERRIRich KotterWed Feb 15 1989 14:3610
    A better measure for you, and, in my opinion, for everyone, is the
    percentage of your body mass that is fat, not weight. It is recommended
    that women should shoot for 22% and men for about 15%, unless you are
    some kind of athlete, who often get much lower. You can find clinics
    that determine this number with an electronic device that measures the
    resistance of your body or by measuring your buoyancy under water in a
    "dunk" test. 
    
    Rich

400.3Inches?COOKIE::WILCOXDatabase Systems/WestWed Feb 15 1989 17:519
I understand what you mean, but don't find it depressing.  While I don't
have "big bones", I do carry my weight extremely well.  At 5'6", 153 I can
wear size 9s, but I do not feel as good as I do at about 135-140.  I have
found it somewhat of a disadvantage to be able to carry it this well because
it's real easy for me to put on 10 pounds then another 10...I have also
found quite a dramatic difference in body inch measurements with just 10
pounds.

400.4Weight isn't the only indicator (or even the best)ATSE::BLOCKBeverly (was Kasper for a while) BlockThu Feb 16 1989 11:2316
    I'll second what .2 said about getting a body fat measurement.  If your
    site has a fitness center, they probably have the gizmo to do this. 
    MKO's Life Center does body composition analysis as part of the fitness
    workup when you join; they give you a printout showing what sort of shape
    you're in using a number of different factors, and giving you goals to
    work for.

    The number on the scale really is not the most important thing.  I can
    sympathize with being paranoid about the numbers, but getting down to
    some arbitrary weight at the expense of your health is not a win.

    Good luck,
    Beverly


400.5I know exactly what you mean!!AVANT::BERTOTThu Mar 16 1989 12:5616
    I know exactly what you mean.  I also have a large frame, and I
    am 5'6".  I always felt FAT.  Same reasons too my friends weight
    would be 115, I had a friend in HS who weighed 98 lbs.  At 134 I
    felt like a PIG.  But it was the number, I never considered what
    I *looked* like.  I felt like this for years, I gained enourmous
    amounts of weight, I've gone over 200 lbs.  Then I met this girl who
    was in tremendous shape.  She was 5'4" and weighed 125-140 depending
    on how much she was working out.  She also had large bones.  I looked
    at her and I said to myself....self you can look just like that
    and weigh 135!!!  I went on a self imposed diet which began Dec
    10, 1987, I have lost 70 lbs with 24 left to go.  I know I'll get
    there and I can't wait.  I think it's been stated very well here
    that body fat and cholestrol (sp) are your best indicators.  I am
    sure you'll look terrific!
    Elaine

400.6big bonesTUNER::BUCKINGHAMTue Jul 11 1989 16:348
    I have big bones, broad shoulders, long arms and legs.  I went to
    weight watchers and lost 34 pounds.  The weight watchers goal they
    gave me was 122-145 pounds.  I used to be self conscience about
    having a large frame, but now I don't care.  As long as I'm healthy,
    life is to short to be worrying about things I can't change.  And
    my big bones is something I can't change.