T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
89.1 | FAD DIETS | AKOV77::SHAHBAZI | | Tue Jul 21 1987 14:39 | 24 |
| I've been on many diets in my life (loosing 30 lbs. or so at a time)
on "fad" diets and I've ALWAYS gained back more!
Not to be repetitious, but Weight Watchers has a balanced, HEALTHY,
program---it is a slower weight loss; but it really works and many
who've reached goal have stayed there!
I haven't finished loosing all my weight yet, but with the class
support, etc. I'm going to continue all the way to goal (75 lbs.
more to go---lost 13 already)
Being an "experienced" dieter I knew, for myself anyway, that I
HAD TO BE IN THE RIGHT FRAME OF MIND TO LOOSE WEIGHT. Starting
a diet when I really DIDN'T want to loose weight was a waste of
time.
But this time I feel a lot stronger and am more committed to stick
with it.
Good Luck to all at becoming HAPPIER and HEALTHIER!!!
- SANDY
|
89.2 | The Rotation Diet works for me... | STAR::MCCOY | Rebel without a clause.... | Wed Jul 22 1987 17:53 | 27 |
| I have found that the Rotation Diet has worked extremely well for
me. I have been following it since the end of January, using the
pattern of three weeks "on" (i.e., one rotation) and one week "off."
I am very careful to make sure I'm eating a balanced and nutritious
diet, however, and I take a vitamin/calcium supplement as well.
I don't regard it as a fad diet at all. Rather, I see it as an
eating program that promotes a maximum amount of weight loss in
a short time span, which is important to those of us who have a
lot of weight to lose.
The Rotation Diet offers more than just a "diet." The author, Martin
Katahn, stresses exercise--something equivalent to an hour a day
walking--as well as calorie reduction in losing weight. And he
provides a couple of chapters that explain how to maintain your
weight loss.
I have never done so well in a weight-reduction program in my life,
nor stuck with anything so long. I think the varying calorie counts
keep me from becoming bored or too hungry.
Give it a try. But be sure to read the whole book to reap the benefit
of Katahn's experience and advice; after all, he *is* a psychologist.
Nothing could be simpler.
--Kirby
|
89.3 | A Vote for Rotation Diet | BCSE::SCOPA | The Major | Thu Jul 23 1987 07:36 | 21 |
| I have to agree with Kirby on all points!
I currently am in Day 5 of week #1 and have yet to be hungry. Boredum
is snuffed out by the changes every couple of days.
The book is my "Bible" as I read it over and over again. The key
to this diet is the metabolic rate. In many diets once you cut
down on your intake the body starts to slow down it's metabolism
to hold on to what it has...thus you need far less food to maintain
your body weight....but Kahan gets you to INCREASE your metabolic
rate so that you eventually will establish a lower body weight (let's
say for example you go from 200 lbs to 175 lbs or a loss of 12%
of body weight) but not significantly lower your caloric intake
by the same percentage because your body burns more calories per
24 hour period due to the increase in metabolism.
Not really a fad diet....close to Weight Watchers except that you
get that break every three weeks to teach you weight maintenance.
Mike
|
89.4 | What book | RDGENG::MCCARTNEY | End-User Support Services | Tue Jul 28 1987 04:47 | 15 |
| Does anyone have full details of the book, I'd like to try and get
hold of it here. I started with the diet about 1 month ago after
reading an article about it in a magazine, and lost 6lbs in the
first 2 weeks. In week 3 I wasn't able to stick to it because
of personal problems, but lost another 4 lbs anyway, I am now back
at work and trying to get back to normal, I'm going to watch my
diet then start the rotation again on Sunday, as I find that easier
to manage from a shopping point of view.
I don't think its a "FAD" it sound really sensible to me
Good luck
Jenni
|
89.5 | Progress on the Rotation Diet | BCSE::SCOPA | The Major | Tue Jul 28 1987 12:10 | 32 |
| I'm a little tardy with my progress report on this diet.
After 7 days I found myself down about 10 pounds and not feeling
bad at all. I followed the menus in the book 100% with the help
of my wife...who continues on the WW diet.
I noticed I was eating a lot more fruit than I normally do and boy
was I taking in the water...to the tune of almost a gallon a day.
It wasn't so bad...about a 16 oz. glass in the morning, ice tea
(no sugar) at 10, then another 16 oz. at lunch, another ice tea
at 2, and then between 16 and 24 oz at supper and all of a sudden
I found I had consumed around 80 oz.
I never drank any diet sodas although I had one (allowable) light
beer because I stayed within the calorie range.
The menus are not boring...something new all the time...chicken,
fish, flank steak, pork chops, tuna, fruits, veggies...all nutritious
stuff.
Unfortunately I had to go to a family get together and splurged
a little...but drank a lot of water. Sure I gained a little back
but a day or two back on the plan and that stuff came right off.
I doubt that I'll lose another 10 pounds after week #2 but I'm
certainly looking to lose around 5-7.
I'll try to get the basic diet guidelines in here as soon as I have
time.
Mike
|
89.6 | Another Rotation Dieter | HPSCAD::DMCARR | Raised on a PDP-9 | Thu Aug 27 1987 10:21 | 40 |
|
I'm a newcomer to this conference who has decided that 225 was most
definitely as overweight as I wanted to be. I'd taken the Rotation
Diet out of the library a few months ago, and put the principles of it
into effect about 3 weeks ago (just started the actual diet this week -
am currently on day 4). By just following Katahn's general guidelines,
I substituted my evening snacks of potato chips & whatever w/ fruit,
and began going for noontime walks here at MRO. In the 3 weeks, I was
down to 215. Now at the 4th day I'm at 210. Goal for the end of the
1st rotation is 200 or (hopefully) lower, which I haven't seen in
over a year. I'm shooting for 175-180 which I haven't seen in 10 years.
I definitely DO NOT regard this as a fad diet. For those who aren't
familiar w/ it, the basic principles are as mentioned in a previous
note by Mike, 3 week periods of dieting w/ increased exercise (walking).
For men, its 3 days at 1200 calories, 4 days at 1500, followed by a
week at 1800, then repeat the 1200/1500 for the 3rd week. Then STOP
dieting for however long you'd like. By the end of week 3 you should be
walking briskly for 45 minutes a day. The exercise is what keeps the
weight off (will let you know when I get there). For women, its
600/900/1200 calorie increments. When you feel hungry, you have a
"safe" fruit (apple, orange, tangerine, peach, grapefruit, & a few
others that I can't recall off hand).
So far, so good. The meals are excellent (at least for the men, my wife
is also on the diet w/ me & we're using the separate diet plans rather
than having the man follow the woman's diet & increase portions. She's
pretty hungry and complaining that her meals are getting monotonous -
lots of chicken the first week, but she's gonna try the alternate
menus which give more variety). She's lost 4 lbs. in 4 days.
I have to agree w/ Mike about the book being my Bible. There is something
about the way that Martin Katahn writes that just gets me motivated. I
don't regard him as just another quack trying to make a buck off a diet
book. For those who are interested, the hardcover is available at Bradlees
for $16, I found the paperback at Caldor for $4.50. Will post progress
reports in the progress note next week. I'm off for my walk.
-Dom
|
89.7 | Rotation Diet results | HPSCAD::DMCARR | Raised on a PDP-9 | Mon Sep 14 1987 10:07 | 20 |
|
Figured I'd post a progress report here after my 1st 3-week rotation
on this diet. Total loss over the 3 weeks was 15 lbs. Dropped from
215 to 200. I am absolutely sold on this diet. The weight loss, as you
can see was dramatic which kept up my motivation to make it thru the
entire 3 weeks without cheating (which I can honestly say I didn't
cheat). I was not the least bit hungry on this diet, although it was
tough going from week 2 (1800 calories) to week 3 (back to 1200 calories),
but my "safe" fruit helped me on that 1st day of week 3. I'm also up
to 45 minutes of walking a day which is the key to this diet.
This week is my maintenance week - no dieting this week, although I'm
continuing to watch what I eat. But its nice not to have to measure
quantities. Will probably go back on it next week for another 3 week
rotation and hopefully another 10-15 lb loss. Needless to say, I am
extremely happy with the results. My total loss over the past 6 weeks
has been 25 lbs.
-Dom
|
89.8 | Way to go Dom! | STAR::YANKOWSKAS | Paul Yankowskas DTN 381-1624 | Mon Sep 14 1987 11:06 | 5 |
| Congratulations on an impressive loss! Please keep us posted.
Paul
|
89.9 | Eat Less Fat and Walk | VXHDRM::SUNNY | Eat less fat and walk | Wed Sep 30 1987 09:36 | 23 |
| All year long I've been losing, gaining, losing, gaining. What I
lacked was 'commitment' and sensible guidelines. I purchased the
paperback of the rotation diet, studied it thoroughly and have started
following Martin Katahn's guidelines. They adapt well to my lifestyle
and the book itself is very encouraging. The hardest thing for me
so far is to incorporate the water...I'm not used to drinking so
much water. < 8-8 oz glasses per day> However, the 45 minute walk
with my dog in the evenings feels GREAT. At this point I only walk
at 3 MPH, but hope to work up to 4 MPH very soon. Yesterday was
my day One and I weighed in at 218. After 24 hours I had dropped
two pounds when I weighed in this morning at 216.
Katahn points out that by incorporating the diet and the excersise
program, that for every 20 pounds of fat you lose, you will gain
about 2 to 3 pounds of muscle. I haven't had _real_ muscels for
years dah-lings! ;-) This could well be a first! ;-) ;-)
I'll keep you posted...and I plan to be more active in this conference.
This time I have made the "commitment" necessary to becoming the
size I *really* want to be!
-sunny-
|
89.10 | How much has your dog lost? ;-) | SQM::AITEL | NO ZUKES!!!! | Wed Sep 30 1987 10:11 | 2 |
|
|
89.11 | Eat less fat and walk | ACE::SUNNY | Quitate de me espalda! ;-) ;-) | Wed Sep 30 1987 10:23 | 13 |
| re: -1
Funny you should ask.... ;-)
Actually, she is overweight and before we started our walks I picked
up this ungainly monster, >>who was not all that *happy* to be picked
up ;-)>> and popped onto the scales. I subtracted my weight from
our combined weight and she weighs in at 88 pounds. >> Big Puppy,
eh? << I will probably weigh her on a monthly basis, that is unless
*you'd* like to come to my home and daily weigh 80+ pounds of unhappy
puppy. ;-) ;-) ;-)
-sunny-
|
89.12 | The dog has lost part owner! | MASTER::EPETERSON | | Wed Sep 30 1987 11:00 | 2 |
|
|
89.13 | Available in Reading | MARVIN::JUBB | | Mon Mar 21 1988 05:15 | 11 |
| Re: .4
Jenni,
I hope you've found a copy of the book now, but in case you haven't...
I just found a copy in the bookshop in Union Street (Smelly Alley)
in Reading. They've several copies on the right-hand side as you
walk down, under the heading "Health", price �3.50.
Alison
|
89.14 | Serialisation in "The Independent" | MARVIN::JUBB | | Thu Apr 21 1988 02:56 | 10 |
| If anyone in the UK is interested in this diet, you may like to
know that they are serialising it in "The Independent" on Tuesdays.
It started this week (19-APR) with a preamble (basically the history
of the diet). The diet itself starts next Tuesday (26-APR). Reading
about it again has prompted me to start on the diet myself (from
today). I'll record my progress in WORDS::PROGRESS.
Ali
|
89.15 | All that bread, and no potatoes | MARVIN::JUBB | | Fri Apr 29 1988 05:59 | 11 |
| At the beginning of week 2 on this diet, it seems to be working.
I have lost 6lbs (but have stayed at my present weight (8st = 112lbs)
Most of the food is good too. I like the recipes in the book.
My boyfriend shares the meals, and enjoys them too, although he
is not on any diet. I especially like the fact that the diet includes
cheese, because if I were deprived of cheese I know I would binge!
My only complaint about week 1... no potatoes at all!! I'm looking
forward to my baked potato on day 2 (I think) of week 2.
|
89.16 | | ANGORA::ZARLENGA | Give me liberty or give me debts | Sat Apr 30 1988 10:36 | 7 |
|
.15> I have lost 6lbs (but have stayed at my present weight (8st = 112lbs)
How did you lose weight but stay at your present weight?
-mike z
|
89.17 | What I meant was... | MARVIN::JUBB | | Tue May 03 1988 02:52 | 7 |
| AAh, Mike,
What I meant was I lost 6lbs, but my weight had not gone down for
a few days.
Ali
|
89.18 | well I tried.... | IPG::HUNT | well I ordered new ones anyway.. | Tue May 03 1988 03:51 | 18 |
| Have just finished week three on the rotation diet.
I found week 2 was too much for me. There was just too much to eat.
At the end of week one I had lost three pounds but this went back
on again with week 2.
So at the end of week 3 I had lost three pounds! Unfortunately,
despite being very careful, it all went back on again in three
days. So I am back where I started.
What did I do to put it back on? Well I had a couple of glasses
of wine and a bigger portion of rice one evening. Next day I
had some baked beans and a couple of cheese scones.
It doesnt take much to put it on again....
disappointed.
|
89.19 | did you try? | COPA::CABANYA | | Tue May 03 1988 09:24 | 13 |
| Did you read the chapter in the book on increasing your calories?
The author suggests that you only raise calories by 300 a day for
3-4 days, then another 300, etc. until you're at the calorie level
at which you want to stay.
Also, he has a special (1 day I think) diet for taking off the
'week-end binge' in the book. It works!
Good luck.
mary
|
89.20 | The elusive one day diet | MARVIN::JUBB | | Wed May 04 1988 06:18 | 17 |
| re.19
Mary,
The one day diet to get rid of the weekend binge sounds just what
I need. Last weekend it was my birthday, so I ate out, and then
my (vegetarian) sister came to stay, so I had to abandon the exact
diet plans for her (the Rotation Diet does not really seem to cater
for veggies!).
However I have looked for it in my book, and cannot find it, unless
you are talking about the one day water loss diet.
Do you still have a copy of it?
Ali
|
89.21 | ok | COPA::CABANYA | | Wed May 04 1988 09:17 | 19 |
| I'll look it up tonight and either enter it or tell you what chapter.
The plan can be modified to be vegetarian. He also has a few menus
in their for vegetarians. You can subsitute beans, rice, pasta,
or other carbs (potatoes) as long as you keep the calories the same.
For example, if you are allowed 3 oz chicken (assume 210 calories),
you can subsitute the same number of carb calories (ie, 1 1/2 cups
pasta, etc.). I tried this for awhile and it worked pretty well.
Currently I'm 'resting' from the diet, ie, maintainence. I've been
doing that for about a month now and am trying to find the willpower
to cut the portions and watch the weight go away. It IS a good
diet, my problem is also the week-ends!
Good luck and I'll look it up tonight.
mary
|
89.22 | one-day water loss | COPA::CABANYA | | Thu May 05 1988 11:38 | 32 |
| If you have the book, the pages you want to study are 138-147
(Guidelines for making a successful transition to maintainance).
Point 1 He says the most important guideline is to not increase
increase food intake too quickly. He suggests after
the 21 day rotation go to 1200/1800 (woman/man) for
3 days, then 1500/2100, etc.
Point 2 One-day water loss diet (for those of us who DID increase
food intake too quickly!)
Up to 1 pound extra-lean been, fish or chicken
Up to 2 cups of low-fat cottage cheese
Asparagus, broccoli, fresh pineapple or melon
and citrus fruits.
You can use this diet for two days if necessary. You
can also eat all the named fruits and vegetables. Do
NOT follow this diet for more than 2 days.
By the way, my boss has completed either her second (or third)
rotation and has lost 30 pounds already. It works!
Good luck.
Mary
|
89.23 | | MARVIN::JUBB | | Fri May 06 1988 06:31 | 8 |
| Re .22
Thanks, Mary,
I'll give it a try next time I binge.
Ali
|
89.24 | Some hints... | HPSCAD::DMCARR | Raised on a PDP-9 | Fri May 06 1988 10:32 | 28 |
|
Diana,
Try not to get too discouraged about only a 3 lb loss. I'm assuming
that you are doing the daily walking (should be up to 45 minutes at
the end of the 3rd week). And you also should continue walking after
completing the diet. Take a week or so off, then give it another try.
My only other guess is that British ounces differ from U.S ounces
(am I correct in assuming this?).
One other suggestion: Stick *exactly* to the diet. I did so for my
first 2 rotations and found that it worked well (15 lb loss, followed
by a 10 lb loss). On the 3rd rotation I did a lot of subtituting, and
only lost 5 lbs. (of course I was also getting closer to goal & the
weight was coming off slower).
On a more personal note, I managed to put back 15 of the 40 lbs I
originally lost by giving up on the good eating habits I'd developed
during the diet (attribute it to winter blahs and the like). (At least
I didn't gain it all back & came to my senses). Well, I'm back on it
again & have already dropped 5 lbs in 5 days. So, does it still work?
Do I still endorse this diet? You bet. Hopefully, I'll be able to keep it
off this time.
-Dom
(Anybody manage to find the audio tape "Maintaining the Rotation Diet"?)
|
89.25 | | GENRAL::DANIEL | | Tue Dec 13 1988 16:18 | 36 |
| I wanted to share my experience so far with the Rotation Diet. Week One was
great; I wasn't hungry except for day Two, when I ate my "emergency fruit"; an
apple. I found that I was learning things about food combining and how much of
a food/food group I could be eating. I found the diet to be very different
from Weight Watchers. I was on Weight Watchers for only two weeks and found
that I felt awful. WW contains too much protein for my comfort.
SUBSTITUTIONS
I have problems with cow products, although the 1oz of cheese each day is not
enough to bother me. Yoghurt does not bother me but cottage cheese bothers me
very much; in the Substitute Menus of the Rotation Diet, plain yoghurt is put
in instead of cottage cheese. Goat Milk is available at the grocer, and since
it is not lowfat, I use half as much to total the same calorie amount.
I read the part of the book about water retention and the foods recommended for
being diuretic. I then realized that quite a few of those diuretic foods are
on the three-week rotation plan. My body has been ridding itself of water like
crazy. I missed work yesterday with diarrhea and I believe this is a result of
the way the diet is effecting my body.
I did not implement the exercise routine for the first two weeks (I started
week Three today...put off starting it for two days because of the diarrhea and
stomach upset) but I did start it up today. I lost four pounds in two weeks. I
consider this to be good, as the other three diets I tried over this past year
showed much slower results; I'm convinced that things that were happening in my
life and with my body before I retained 30 extra pounds have a lot to do with
having screwed up my metabolism.
Moodwise, I have noticed more mental clarity. I feel more in-control of myself
and more self-assured. I believe the diet helps attain a better life balance
in me.
Keep On Keepin' On
Meredith
|
89.26 | | GENRAL::DANIEL | | Tue Dec 13 1988 16:21 | 6 |
| I forgot to add; I am a vegetarian. There is a part of the book which says
that combining 1/2 cup of beans plus 1/2 cup of rice creates a complete protein
that is equivalent to 3oz meat. I found Lentil Pilaf by Near East Foods to be
quite delicious; it is made of lentils, rice, carrots and spices. Spices can
be a real key on the Rotation Diet.
|
89.27 | | BPOV04::BERGER | | Thu Jan 05 1989 15:22 | 24 |
|
For the past 5-6 months I've been trying to lose 10 pounds.
I've been going to the gym 5 days/week, cycling 35 minutes. I
cut down (not quite out) chocolate, ice cream, etc. and tried to
keep the calorie count between 1200-1600. I lost and gained the
same 3-4 pounds during that whole time...bummer.
I'm happy about getting into the habit of exercising regularly,
but I'm frustrated about the lack of weightloss & inches. After
reading about the Rotation Diet here, I felt that it would be the
way to finally drop those 10 pounds. I found the book in the library
but haven't been able to find it in a store - looked in Caldors,
Bradlees, Annie's Book Swap, & 2 book stores. Does anybody know
where it can be found in the Framingham to Worcester area? I
guess I could keep renewing it from the library.
Well, anyway I'm on Day 2. This is the first really strict
diet that I've been on. I'm realizing that it's important to
plan and prepare ahead. What do you do about all those 1/2
quantities (1/2 banana, 1/2 cantaloupe, 1/2 grapefruit)? Does
a banana keep for 2 days?
Audrey
|
89.28 | | MARVIN::JUBB | Ali, 830-6779 **New location at REO2-G/K3** | Fri Jan 06 1989 03:30 | 21 |
| Hi Audrey,
I hope the Rotation Diet works for you. I used it last year (like you,
to get rid of those 10lbs). It worked very well, although I have been
bad at maintenance, and binged over the holidays. I am going back on
it again at the beginning of next week. This time I intend to make the
maintenance work.
>> What do you do about all those 1/2
>>quantities (1/2 banana, 1/2 cantaloupe, 1/2 grapefruit)? Does
>>a banana keep for 2 days?
I dealt with the half quantities by cutting the whole fruit in half, and
covering the exposed flesh with cling film. I was surprised at how well
this works for bananas! (just don't put your half banana in the fridge,
though; the skin will go black!)
Good luck!
Ali
|
89.29 | | GENRAL::DANIEL | | Fri Jan 06 1989 11:59 | 6 |
| I do the same as Ali with the bananas, only I don't put them in the fridge. THe
top slice is a bit brown so I take it off; below that, it's good. The
grapefruit, I stuff in a Ziploc. There are 3 halves a week and then a melon
half. I substitute the final grapefruit half for the melon half, since good
melon this season in Colorado is hard to find, anyway.
|
89.30 | Why not special order it? | ATSE::KASPER | Does anyone *really* like fruitcake? | Fri Jan 06 1989 13:16 | 8 |
|
Any regular bookstore should be able to special order the book for you.
All they'll need is the title and author, though ISBN will make it a
little easier.
Beverly
|
89.31 | | BPOV06::BERGER | | Fri Jan 06 1989 13:46 | 14 |
|
Thanks for the advice! I'm glad today is the last 600 calorie day
for this week. I'm feeling a little light-headed and don't have
a lot of energy. I am taking advantage of my safe fruit and the
free vegetables, otherwise I think I'd have a stomach ache from
the lack of food. I have lost 3 lbs so far (yeh!) and my skin looks
and feels better too. The weekend will be a challenge, but I'm
prepared for it food-wise. Spent last night peeling, chopping,
slicing, shredding and then storing all those free vegetables.
I'm feeling pretty committed to making it thru the next 18 days.
Audrey
|
89.32 | And the vital statistics are: | MARVIN::JUBB | Ali, 830-6779 *New location REO2-G/K3 | Mon Jan 09 1989 04:42 | 7 |
| "The Rotation Diet" by Martin Katahn
Publisher: Bantam
ISBN: 0-553-17353-7
|
89.33 | 2nd Time Around | GIAMEM::BERGER | | Wed May 17 1989 14:35 | 22 |
|
Regarding .31 - I did finally find the book & made it thru two weeks
of the diet. I lost 4 lbs on the diet (138 to 134) and have kept
it off since January. Last week I decided it was time to get off
the plateau, so I'm on day 3 and have lost 3 lbs. This time around
I am taking an appetite suppressant. I've never tried one before,
I was surprised that it actually works! My stomach hasn't growled
once during these past three days on a 600 calorie diet. My goal
for this rotation is to break 130 (128-129 would be nice) & then
maintain this weight for a month or two. My long-term goal is
125 which I hope to achieve before the end of the summer.
I believe that the rotation diet works better for me than being
on a never-ending 1200 cal/day diet that's supposed to yield a 1-2
lb loss per week. For some unknown reason, it doesn't work for
me and I get really frustrated. And when I get frustrated, oh no,
watch out - fridge attack!!!
Hope to make it thru the 21 days this time.
Audrey
|
89.34 | New recipe book | MARVIN::JUBB | Ali, 830-6779 *New location REO2-G/K3 | Tue May 23 1989 09:16 | 19 |
| I picked up a copy of the Rotation Diet Cook Book which has come
out here (the UK).
I would recommend it for anyone who is using the diet, especially
if you are on it for more than one rotation, or, like me, using
the women's plan (fish, chicken, fish, chicken....). In particular
there are several vegetarian recipies in the book, and the advice
on substitutions is more comprehensive (and easier to find).
The range of "free vegetables" is larger too.
Given with each recipe is an estimation of the time it takes to make
the dish, plus information about calories, fat, etc.. in the dish.
In fact it's a useful book for anyone who is watching their weight.
Enjoy!
Ali
|
89.35 | Is anyone still out there! | AYOU48::VRANKIN | | Tue Aug 08 1989 09:29 | 10 |
| Just curious. I've just spent my lunch-hour reading through the
replies to this note. As an observer, I can't help but notice that
the original folks who started this note have 'dissapeared'. My
question is to those who have/had started this diet and then faded
into the background. What happened? Please answer as I'm seriously
considering this diet but don't want to end in failure after the
1st rotation.
Vivian
|
89.36 | It's better than many... | MARVIN::JUBB | Ali, REO2-GK3, 830-6779 | Tue Aug 08 1989 10:21 | 28 |
| Hello Vivian,
I've used this diet on and off several times, and as far as I have
ever been able to stick to a diet for more than two weeks, this one
has been a good one to follow.
If you follow it to the letter, it is a very well-balanced diet, and
I did not find myself getting bored. I did lose weight fast, too, and
the reason I did not keep it off is that I went straight back into my
bad old ways (at the moment I'm not on a particular diet, just trying to
learn good eating habits to fall back into when I next diet and stop
dieting!).
The diet does give very sensible advice about exercise, and about eating
for life, as opposed to just to lose weight, so I think it is a good
program.
A couple of drawbacks I suppose: for women it can be rather boring - fish,
chicken, fish, chicken, fish! (does this apply to you? I'm not sure if
Vivian is the male or female spelling...), and the suggestions for
vegetarians are not very imaginative. However if you buy the Rotation Diet
Recipe book which is out in paperback now, that does make things easier for
both women and vegetarians.
Good luck!
Ali
|
89.37 | On my marks, get ready, start the diet! | AYOU48::VRANKIN | | Wed Aug 09 1989 05:26 | 6 |
| Thanks for the info. FYI, Vivian is the female spelling (at least
thats what my mother told me).
Cheers, Viv
|
89.38 | Wasn't Entirely Successful | MOOV01::BERGER | | Mon Aug 28 1989 14:26 | 25 |
|
I've tried the diet twice - both times I didn't make it past the second
week, but I think I should add that I usually don't get through one week
of a strict diet. I felt hungry alot of the time on the diet and I
think the thought of reducing the caloric intake from 1200 calories in
week 2 to 600/800 calories in week 3 did me in both times. I just
didn't have the will-power or endurance to last three weeks.
The good news is the 4 lbs that I lost on the diet has stayed off. Now
I've been bouncing between 129 & 134. Seems like every time I get to
129, I sabotage my efforts by sugar/chocolate binging. What I'm
currently using as a guide is the Fit or Fat Target diet. It's a
long-term eating plan rather than a short-term weightloss plan. For
me, I have to learn to eat correctly and take sweets/fats and such in
moderation. I want to get off this cycle of being really good and then
really bad.
I'm not trying to discourage you Vivian. The book has some good
information in it and the diet may suit you. Best of luck in whatever
you pursue!
Audrey
|
89.39 | There's no time like the present | BOBBY::RANKIN | | Mon Sep 18 1989 08:52 | 12 |
| Audrey;
Could you posssibly give me/us some info regarding the "Fit or Fat
Diet"? I fall into the category of individual who constantly needs to
try different approaches to weight control. I've yet to try the
Rotation Diet (lack of committment, as is always the case). But have
decided to make a public announcement right this minute. NOW HEAR
THIS, after work TODAY, I am stoping by the book store and purchase
the rotation diet book. I WILL let you all know about my progress.
Vivian
|
89.40 | The Fit or Fat Diet | MOOV01::BERGER | | Thu Sep 21 1989 13:22 | 31 |
|
The "Fit or Fat Target Diet" emphasizes decreasing the amount of FAT
in your diet. It advises you to eat:
2 servings from the Meat group
2 servings from the Milk group
4 servings from the Bread & Cereal group
4 servings from the Fruit & Vegetable group
Your selections are, of course, low in fat and sugar. There is a food
analysis sheet that you fill out daily to determine your food intake
in regards to empty calories (sugar, fat, & alcohol), nutritious
calories, fiber, and also the percentage fat consumed. I did this for
2 weeks and it was very educational. There were days where I ate
less than 1300 calories but my fat % was greater than 25% - other days
where I ate 2000+ calories and my fat intake was only 7%! I _really_
like this plan. I haven't been filling out the sheet, but I still
try to follow the basic plan and principles. Over the past month, I
have noticed a loss in size. I try to ignore the scale now and instead
get my body fat percentage tested every 6 months, which the diet also
recommends.
The one thing that the Rotation Diet has in common with the
Fit or Fat diet is the fat reduction and the 2nd thing (just
remembered) is the emphasis on exercising. I still use some of the
recipes in the Rotation Diet - there were some good ones.
Best of luck! Let us know how it goes.
Audrey
|
89.41 | anyone out there?!! | POBOX::RILEY_R | | Wed Jul 24 1991 22:26 | 12 |
| Hello!!! Anyone out there??????
Well, I've scanning this file looking for weight loss ideas and this
one has me interested. No one has written in here for so long though
I'm having doubts!! How'd everyone do? I noticed you talked about
walking. I am getting a Stairclimber soon and I'd like to use that.
Do think that would be ok? Does it have to be walking?
Please respond!!!
Thanks,
renee
|
89.42 | still around! | SFCPMO::CABANYA | | Thu Aug 01 1991 21:58 | 17 |
| Hi Renee,
Stairclimber, or any other exercise would be adequate (including
walking). The rotation diet worked for me, but, alas, I didn't
continue the exercise & menus (maintainence) and the weight has
slowly returned (but not ALL of it thank goodness!).
So, I would encourage to try it and let us know how your doing
(give ME some inspiration to get back in it anyway!). Of all
the diets, I liked this one the best.
Remember, eat less fat and walk!
good luck.
mary
|
89.43 | Four years later, another interested reader... | MARVIN::CROWLE | Seek not answers; live the questions | Mon Nov 13 1995 12:58 | 9 |
| It's a while since anyone's added anything to this topic. But I like
the sound of this diet so I'm going to give it a try.
The first "rotation" takes 3 weeks, and the numbers suggest that a loss
of about 5 pounds should be possible in that time. Today I weigh 170
pounds exactly: on 4th December I'll add another reply and tell you if
it worked for me!
Brian
|