T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
79.1 | I get ear aches | FILTON::BAKERG | Gone Walkabout | Tue Jul 06 1993 08:36 | 7 |
|
Yeah when I had a girlfriend and she had PMT, I used to get bad ear
aches.
does that qualify?
bakes
|
79.2 | | JUPITR::HILDEBRANT | I'm the NRA | Tue Jul 06 1993 10:09 | 3 |
| Pure Fiction.
Marc H.
|
79.3 | | QUARK::LIONEL | Free advice is worth every cent | Tue Jul 06 1993 11:12 | 4 |
| I'm confused - men don't menstruate, so how could men have anything termed
"pre-menstrual"?
Steve
|
79.4 | Boy,am I confused! | MR4DEC::MAHONEY | | Tue Jul 06 1993 11:44 | 2 |
| I am also confused....
Are there some males who believe that men menstruate?
|
79.5 | | CALS::DESELMS | A closed mouth gathers no feet. | Tue Jul 06 1993 11:45 | 6 |
| RE: .3
Well, I haven't menstruated yet, so maybe my whole life is just one big case
of pre-menstrual tension.
- Jim
|
79.6 | Pre-Menstrual Phsyco! | FILTON::PERKINS_S | Carte Blanche | Tue Jul 06 1993 13:57 | 7 |
| Any guy who's had a wife/girlfriend who suffers from PMT/PMS will have
suffered.
In the past i've had semi boiling hot water poured over my crotch and
also been kicked in the crotch to mention only a few.
And for doing nothing....no provocation.Difficult to relate to it.
|
79.7 | | QUARK::LIONEL | Free advice is worth every cent | Tue Jul 06 1993 14:39 | 8 |
| Re: .6
What you describe is physical abuse, and would be, to me anyway, absolutely
unacceptable in a relationship no matter what the cause. Women are supposed
to be learning not to put up with abuse from their partners; men should
learn the same.
Steve
|
79.8 | Ah, come on guys... | GYMAC::PNEAL | Legally Challenged Pommie | Tue Jul 06 1993 15:01 | 13 |
| 'course men don't menstruate - anybody would think this was the 'box !!
I thought it was a known fact that some women can and do suffer during PMT.
My ex-wife (maybe that's the reason she's my x) during PMT would suffer
depression, anxiety and spouts of aggression which were really not her. She
suffered but as a result of her problem I suffered along. The depressions
were hard to handle but one time she attacked me with a bread knife - I was just
lucky the dog liked me.
bakes - sure, that qualifies.
- Paul.
|
79.9 | | SMURF::BINDER | Deus tuus tibi sed deus meus mihi | Tue Jul 06 1993 15:10 | 9 |
| Re .6
> Any guy who's had a wife/girlfriend who suffers from PMT/PMS will
> have suffered.
I'll thank you to speak for yourself, please. Your bandying about of
the word "any" is entirely uncalled for. My wife suffers from PMS, and
the only suffering I have ever endured because of it was concern to
ease her mental and physical discomfort.
|
79.10 | | DSSDEV::RUST | | Tue Jul 06 1993 15:26 | 31 |
| Re .8: Gee, and here I was thinking you were referring to the
theoretical "male hormone-induced mood swing" syndrome, often compared
to PMS though not tied to quite so obvious a physical phenomenon.
The whole concept of "moods" is good for hours of entertaining debate,
if one is so inclined. How much of this is "in the mind"? Since some
people can put themselves into good moods or bad ones apparently at
will, does this mean that anybody who claims to be the victim of a mood
swing is really a hypochondriac? Are we talking about quantifiable
physiological changes that are variable enough and subtle enough that
it's hard to track just what causes which? Do men's hormone levels
fluctuate in a predictable fashion, and does this have any effect on
their temperament or emotional state? How does one go about collecting
data on these phenomena - "moods" are generally quite subjective, and
two people with the same relative level of chemical imbalance [if
that's what it is] may react very differently...
Things that can affect one's mood [and which are probably under study
by some government-funded agency Even As We Speak]: colors, scents,
temperatures, sunlight, humidity, tension, blood sugar, caffeine (and
all sorts of other "chemicals are our friends" substances), and, very
probably, hormones - your own as well as those of others, whose
reactions to them may have more of an effect on your mood than their
own. So. If someone's being unusually testy, can we deduce the cause,
or should we simply back away quietly before anybody gets hurt?
Watch for my new book, "People Who Snap at People, and the People Who
Have to Work/Live/Love with Them", coming soon to a mall kiosk near
you.
-b
|
79.11 | | GYMAC::PNEAL | Legally Challenged Pommie | Tue Jul 06 1993 15:41 | 25 |
| Re .10:
"The whole concept of "moods" is good for hours of entertaining debate,
if one is so inclined."
I thought that was the whole idea behind notes - debate, entertaining or
otherwise ?
"Things that can affect one's mood [and which are probably under study
by some government-funded agency Even As We Speak]: colors, scents,
temperatures, sunlight, humidity, tension, blood sugar, caffeine (and
all sorts of other "chemicals are our friends" substances),..."
This topic was about the indirect effect of female menstruation on Men but
please feel free to start another topic on any of those subjects if you wish.
"Watch for my new book, "People Who Snap at People, and the People Who
Have to Work/Live/Love with Them", coming soon to a mall kiosk near
you."
Ah, as you're all ready so knowledgeable and experienced about the topic why
not share a few of the highlights here with us.
- Paul.
|
79.12 | | DSSDEV::RUST | | Tue Jul 06 1993 16:24 | 53 |
| Re .11:
>Re .10:
>
> "The whole concept of "moods" is good for hours of entertaining debate,
> if one is so inclined."
>
>I thought that was the whole idea behind notes - debate, entertaining or
>otherwise ?
Why, yes. Was there something in the statement you quoted to make you think
I felt otherwise?
> "Things that can affect one's mood [and which are probably under study
> by some government-funded agency Even As We Speak]: colors, scents,
> temperatures, sunlight, humidity, tension, blood sugar, caffeine (and
> all sorts of other "chemicals are our friends" substances),..."
>
>This topic was about the indirect effect of female menstruation on Men but
>please feel free to start another topic on any of those subjects if you wish.
Oh, I _always_ feel free to start new topics, thanks. But in this case
I was attempting to point out (though you seem to have missed the
tongue in cheek) that it can be very difficult to ascertain the cause
of a bad mood; even if one knows that it _is_ "that time of the month,"
it doesn't guarantee that one's significant other is pissed off because
of raging hormones rather than, say, because she spent the afternoon
being made the scapegoat for a project slip and is too furious to
speak. Therefore the distinction between the effect on a spouse or
partner of "the monthlies" and that of any other type of bad mood seems
kind of moot to me. Not to curtail anybody's discussions, of course;
heavens, no!
> "Watch for my new book, "People Who Snap at People, and the People Who
> Have to Work/Live/Love with Them", coming soon to a mall kiosk near
> you."
>
>Ah, as you're all ready so knowledgeable and experienced about the topic why
>not share a few of the highlights here with us.
>
>- Paul.
Well, I just did, actually, and you suggested I start another topic.
Ah, well... (I suppose not everybody finds the proliferation of
self-help books as amusing and worthy of parody as I do. Or perhaps
you're not blessed with 'em in the UK - if I interpret your personal
name correctly.)
Or perhaps you're just in a bad mood today? [I _won't_ use a smiley.
Jonathan Swift didn't use smileys, and everybody knew he was kidding
about eating the babies - didn't they?]
-b
|
79.13 | | SMURF::BINDER | Deus tuus tibi sed deus meus mihi | Tue Jul 06 1993 16:27 | 1 |
| He was kidding?
|
79.14 | | VMSMKT::KENAH | Escapes,Lies,Truth,Passion,Miracles | Tue Jul 06 1993 16:31 | 6 |
| >He was kidding?
Of course he was -- everybody knows that Irish babies are too tough
and gristly to make good eating.
andrew
|
79.15 | | DSSDEV::RUST | | Tue Jul 06 1993 16:32 | 3 |
| Re .13: <snicker...>
-b
|
79.16 | | VMSMKT::KENAH | Escapes,Lies,Truth,Passion,Miracles | Tue Jul 06 1993 16:42 | 26 |
| From .0:
>Does the phenomenen of Male pre-menstrual tension exist ? Fact or fiction ?
>
>Do you (Men) suffer as a consequence of PMT ?
From .11:
>This topic was about the indirect effect of female menstruation on Men but
>please feel free to start another topic on any of those subjects if you wish.
When I read the base note, I did not see that the second question
referred to *female* PMS. My immediate reaction was "Before you start
berating us, make up your mind."
Of course, making up you mind won't help. This is Notes; it is an
anarchistic medium of communication, and you, despite your efforts to
control the path of discussion, have no control. So, relax and enjoy
the ebb and flow of the conversation.
I have heard that men may have emotional cycles, similar to women. I
have heard that these cycles generally are more long-term than women's
cycles (90 days versus 28-30). I have never seen or read any definite
research that provided real evidence that these emotional cycles exist.
andrew
|
79.17 | Its' ok, I'm loosing my mind. | GYMAC::PNEAL | Legally Challenged Pommie | Tue Jul 06 1993 17:20 | 24 |
| Re.-a couple.
Yeah, you're right - It's a bad day. In fact it's a bad week. It used to
be fun coming to work (and working in Germany) - now I don't know which ways up.
You ever have that feeling ?
My jobs been in question for 8 months - I've been driving a rationalisation
project and rather than rationalise people I've been pushing hard in other
directions - with some success - but that's meant not doing what management want.
I haven't won any friends in high places but I've been doing the right thing. I
got back from vacation last week and was told the projects dead. Now what ?
I'm at rock bottom.
On top of that the wife works for a magazine as a journalist which has just
been launched on the stands and the chief editor quit last week. With the CE
gone the driving force behind the mag goes away and who knows what will happen.
Both our jobs are in jeopardy and I guess the strains begining to show.
But back to the topic ?
- Paul.
|
79.18 | | FILTON::BAKERG | Gone Walkabout | Wed Jul 07 1993 07:00 | 7 |
|
I'm getting another ear ache.
sorry Paul
bakes
|
79.19 | bakeys got an achy | GYMAC::PNEAL | Legally Challenged Pommie | Wed Jul 07 1993 07:29 | 6 |
|
<---- me too.
sorry 'bout the ache bakes
- Paul
|
79.20 | | HDLITE::ZARLENGA | Michael Zarlenga, Alpha P/PEG | Wed Jul 07 1993 21:28 | 10 |
| Men suffer MORE from their ladies' PMS than the woman does!
I mean, even when you KNOW what it is ... even when you look at the
calendar and you say "yup, it's been 27 days since she flipped her top
last ..." you can't tell her or she'll go ballistic!
Best thing you can do is slip her a Mydol mickey finn. And QUICK!
Ever see the In Living Color when they guy comes home and his wife has
PMS? He calls 911 and they tell him to jump out the window!
|
79.21 | so strange | VAXWRK::STHILAIRE | wandering spirit | Thu Jul 08 1993 10:04 | 10 |
| I think it's strange that so many women get bitchy from PMS. All I
ever do is get over sensitive. If somebody looks at me the wrong way I
feel like crying, and I start thinking that the world is full of mean,
rotten people who hate me for no reason. But, I don't act bitchy, I
just feel sad and cry easily. So, I don't think any of the men I've
ever been involved with suffered from it. Although, I suppose some men
may find over sensitive women annoying!!
Lorna
|
79.22 | | HANNAH::OSMAN | see HANNAH::IGLOO$:[OSMAN]ERIC.VT240 | Thu Jul 08 1993 12:18 | 16 |
| > I think it's strange that so many women get bitchy from PMS. All I
> ever do is get over sensitive. If somebody looks at me the wrong way I
> feel like crying
Lorna, I'm surprised that you think it's strange.
My experience is that there's such a fine line between being "bitchy" and
being sensitive. If I'm emotionally stressed, I can react either by feeling
like crying or feeling like lashing out at someone. Sometimes I even feel
like doing both.
/Eric
|
79.23 | people suffer most from their own problems | GOLLY::SWALKER | | Thu Jul 08 1993 12:21 | 41 |
| > Men suffer MORE from their ladies' PMS than the woman does!
Wow, that seems like an incredibly presumptious remark!
(Unless, of course, you've been on both sides of the equation).
I've never had a problem with it that I know of, but I have
friends who claim to have PMS problems, and I *know* they suffer
more than I do from being in their company. I can leave the room,
escape from it, and they *cannot*. I'm only a temporary target,
but they have to pick up the pieces afterwards. Big difference.
Reading these notes, I wonder what vacuum I've been living in. I
mean, I went to a women's college, even, spent 4 years living in a
mostly-women environment, and I've seen very little of the sort of
PMS symptoms that men often describe in here. I find myself
wondering if this is exaggeration, or whether there's something
about PMS that makes women single the men in their life out for
special private torture.
I also find it interesting that none of my SOs have ever admitted
to any personal experience with PMS in past girlfriends, but some
men of my acquaintance seem to think all their girlfriends have had
it something fierce. (You can draw your own conclusions about
this).
> Best thing you can do is slip her a Mydol mickey finn. And QUICK!
BTW, Mike, to my knowledge, Midol is for cramps, not PMS. Perhaps
I've just led a really sheltered life here, but I think it's more
common for cramps to occur during one's period or right (like the
day or two) before, whereas PMS is the week before. Not to put you
in this category necessarily, but it amazes me how many men seem
to think that PMS occurs during women's periods.
I wonder whether some of these "PMS" claims result not from
anything physiological, but from men using a woman's menstrual
cycle as ammunition in an argument, or as an excuse to discount
her opinions. Shoot, I'd go ballistic too! Any time of the month!
Sharon
|
79.24 | | CVG::THOMPSON | Radical Centralist | Thu Jul 08 1993 12:41 | 6 |
| RE: .23 I sometimes wonder if PMS is like an accent. People with
accents never notice the same accent in others. Perhaps women just
don't notice PMS in other women unless it gets extreme? Just a theory
to wonder about.
Alfred
|
79.25 | | DSSDEV::RUST | | Thu Jul 08 1993 12:41 | 31 |
| Your mileage may vary but... in my experience, Midol does help with
"that snappish feeling," which is what I've noticed as my main PMS
symptom. [It's sporadic, too; happens only every other time or so,
leading me to believe that each ovary has its own little peculiarities.
I have _no_ idea if there's a scientific basis for this.]
The difficulty about it all is that the very nature of the problem
ensures that it's going to be hard to cope with. Does it help to say,
"Oh, it must be 'that time' again"? Not on your life; if one is already
feeling touchy [whether that _is_ the cause or not], such a statement
sounds patronizing in the extreme, and I've never been able to tell
whether I hate it more when I'm in a bad mood due to hormones ("Well,
so what if it _is_ 'that time,' get the hell out of my way!") or when
it isn't ("What are you talking about? What on earth makes you think
there's only one possible reason for me to be kicking the dog? Get the
hell out of my way!").
Sort of like trying to talk to a guy who's driving the car under trying
circumstances and is getting more irritable by the minute. Telling him
"It's OK, I know how testy you get when you're lost" isn't likely to
evoke a positive reaction, whether he _is_ lost or not.
So what _do_ you do? Options would be to offer assistance if desired
(something general, like "Can I get you anything/do anything?" rather
than "Can I get you some Midol/Shall I go ask that person for
directions?"), or to go away quietly, or to behave as if nothing were
wrong and allow the other person to cope as best they can.
[Acknowledging that a person appears to be in a foul mood is fine;
making assumptions about the reasons can be risky!]
-b
|
79.26 | | HDLITE::ZARLENGA | Michael Zarlenga, Alpha P/PEG | Thu Jul 08 1993 13:25 | 3 |
| re:.23, Sharon
Me? Presumptuous! Heavens no! ;')
|
79.27 | | GYMAC::PNEAL | Legally Challenged Pommie | Thu Jul 08 1993 13:27 | 14 |
| Re.23
It could be that some men use the symptoms to improve their position in an
argument but or denigrate women in someway. You could be right. I try hard
not to do this but my wife (I married again 7 years after the first broke up)
does act extremely sensitive and anxious during these times.
As an example, if we leave the house she'll ask 'did you lock the door ?' which
is ok. By about the sixth or seventh time it's a little trying and she's only
like it at that special time. I'm just very careful not to loose my patience.
If I've had a bad day at work - which is just about every day lately - I have
little left to comfort her monthlies.
- Paul.
|
79.28 | | GYMAC::PNEAL | Legally Challenged Pommie | Thu Jul 08 1993 13:28 | 4 |
| oops,
<---- that should have read 'to comfort her during her monthlies'
|
79.29 | How about an off-cycle chat? | CARTUN::TREMELLING | Making tomorrow yesterday, today! | Thu Jul 08 1993 13:41 | 6 |
| I find that whatever the situation, the stressee is often not able to
discuss the situation in a detached and rational manner. Waiting until the
heat of the moment passes, then bringing it up in the spirit of 'what can
we do differently next time' is often more productive. Your mileage may
vary....
|
79.30 | | GOLLY::SWALKER | | Thu Jul 08 1993 14:19 | 43 |
| re: .24,
Conversely, I've often wondered if PMS is like Santa Claus: a plausible
explanation to those who haven't been there, but one less often
entertained by those who have the facts.
My mileage varies on accents, too: although I don't notice similar
accents in English speakers as accents per se, I speak Russian with
an accent, and I *definitely* notice other American accents in Russian.
There are a lot of reasons for stress and tension which have nothing to
do with PMS. If you look at it as "one more stressor on the pile", I
think that's probably about right. (For some women, obviously, it's
going to be more noticeable, either because it's a much larger
stressor, or because they operate at a very high stress level
otherwise, and it's enough to push them over the edge). To speak in
grossly generalities, I think that women are more likely to treat PMS
this way, whereas men are more likely to treat it like rabies. If
someone reacts to your stress by treating you like you're rabid, it
is only going to make the situation worse, which is my theory for why
some men seem to have PMS antennae that can pick up signals on Mars.
:-) ("Her! She's got PMS, I can tell! Over there by that crater!
Get out of her way, she's going to bite someone's head off any minute
now!")
And then there's the "it's monthly" argument. If you get stressed when
your mortgage payment is due, which happens monthly, is it necessarily
PMS? (Or is it Pre-Mortgage Syndrome :-)
I have actually witnessed interactions where the woman later said it
was PMS, but in the actual interaction she seemed perfectly reasonable
(if on a slightly quicker fuse than usual), and the man seemed touchy
in the extreme, scared, and irrational. (I would have thought *he*
had the PMS!). He, on the other hand, probably thought her PMS was
terrible, whereas the truth might have been that he didn't know how to
deal with her when she got stressed out.
I think PNEAL (Paul?) had a point when he said that when he's using all
his resources dealing with his stress, that it's harder to deal with
his wife's. I think a similar statement can be made about all of us.
Sharon
|
79.31 | | GOLLY::SWALKER | | Thu Jul 08 1993 14:55 | 7 |
| re: .27, Paul
You might try taking a B vitamin before you head home. I've found them
extremely helpful when I'm under a lot of stress.
Sharon
|
79.32 | | VAXWRK::STHILAIRE | wandering spirit | Thu Jul 08 1993 15:42 | 21 |
| re .22, well, in my experience, what *I* was saying is that PMS does
*not* make me lash out. I, also, would not say that PMS makes me feel
"emotionally stressed." What I have noticed is that PMS seems to make
me feel hypersensitive. For example, if I have PMS, and a co-worker
were to make a negative crack about my outfit, I would feel really
hurt, and might even cry a little on the way home about how rude people
can be. But, at another time of the month, I might just make some
crack back at them like, "Yeah, you're no fashion plate yourself. You
should stop shopping at K-Mart" or something similar, and not give
another thought to it ever. Things just hurt me a lot more when I have
PMS, but they don't make me feel like lashing out, they just make me
feel like sitting down and crying and feeling sad about what a mean,
cruel world I live in. Things that I would normally just shrug off,
will really hurt my feelings. I would describe this as oversensitive,
not emotionally stressed, and I don't really think of them as the same
thing. When I said I was surprised, I guess I'm surprised that I seem
to react differently than most other women. I guess I don't think
oversensitivity and lashing out are as close to each other as you do.
Lorna
|
79.33 | | PENUTS::DDESMAISONS | | Thu Jul 08 1993 18:11 | 15 |
|
>>When I said I was surprised, I guess I'm surprised that I seem
>>to react differently than most other women. I guess I don't think
>>oversensitivity and lashing out are as close to each other as you do.
Agreed, Lorna. I react the same way you do. Pretty much cry at the
drop of a hat. And I don't equate that with being "bitchy". Just
emotional.
Mike, you don't know what suffering is, kiddo. *^)
Diane
|
79.34 | | WAHOO::LEVESQUE | A voice to slice us down | Fri Jul 09 1993 13:35 | 29 |
| Sharon-
I'm having difficulty figuring out whether you don't believe that PMS really
exists or whether you think that men really don't have it so bad (not as bad
as the women who are actually having it.) Can you clarify that for me?
It almost sounds as if you think that PMS doesn't really happen, but then
you'll remark that women seem to be suffering more than men.
While I don't wish to assert that men suffer _more_ than women with PMS,
I really don't think it matters because men do suffer the effects of PMS
at the hands of women who have it. Are we to claim that it doesn't matter that
men suffer because women are suffering more? I don't think that holds any water,
particularly in light of the fact that a single woman suffering from the
effects of PMS may cause suffering in a number of people in her personal sphere
of influence. So even IF it were true that she suffered more than anyone else,
it would be quite a stretch to assert she suffered more than the aggregate
amount of suffering she caused in those around her.
My experience with PMS is that there is nothing you can do and whatever
you try to do will only exacerbate the situation. A classic application of
Murphy's Law.
FWIW- My wife will also exhibit the irritableness that characterizes her
symptoms of PMS when she is excessively hungry. Once I noticed that we were
able to minimize it by ensuring she never went too long without something
in her stomach. And at least two of her daughters share this trait.
The Doctah
|
79.35 | | GOLLY::SWALKER | | Fri Jul 09 1993 14:23 | 13 |
| No, I definitely think PMS exists. However, I think men are often
casual in their diagnoses, and that it is not nearly as prevalent as
some men would have us believe. I think that very often it is
something else more easily corrected, like a tendency towards low blood
sugar (the crabbies you mentioned when you go too long between meals; I
get that too, and the symptoms are indeed very similar to PMS).
While I would acknowledge that it's no piece of cake to be around
someone with raging PMS, I still think it's worse on the sufferer
themselves. Not, of course, that it's a contest.
Sharon
|
79.36 | Just airing some thoughts | GYMAC::PNEAL | Legally Challenged Pommie | Fri Jul 09 1993 16:48 | 21 |
| Re.35
Sharon, I'm sure the wife would raise some objections if I asked her to take part
in a controlled experiment but in my opinion it's a lot more than a casual
diagnosis.
Women would have arrived at the answer through intuition whereas Men I feel get
there through some kinda logic. If you've lived with somebody for any length of
time then you KNOW their ups and downs. When they get ratty. Why they get ratty
and that if you want to start an argument just leave the toilet seat up. I
mean you KNOW what's going down.
PMS is a little like that. You can talk, rationalise, discuss, argue the whole
month long until you sense that build-up of tension. It's a little like a wind
blowing under the door. Check the calendar and Bobs yer Uncle. You know it'll
pass - just tread lightly.
What really annoys me is when Women say 'just be glad you don't get it' or 'be a
Man - put up and shut up'. I do in both cases.
- Paul.
|
79.37 | | GYMAC::PNEAL | Legally Challenged Pommie | Fri Jul 09 1993 16:50 | 11 |
| Ooops,
that should have read;
I am and I do.
Damn I'm a wrecked noter lately.
- Paul.
P.S. Looks like I'm on the way out. I should know my future by next week.
|
79.38 | | HDLITE::ZARLENGA | Michael Zarlenga, Alpha P/PEG | Sun Jul 11 1993 18:53 | 7 |
| .30> Conversely, I've often wondered if PMS is like Santa Claus: a plausible
.30> explanation to those who haven't been there, but one less often
.30> entertained by those who have the facts.
Must be some other 28-day cycle then.
Maybe the full moon?
|
79.39 | | FILTON::PERKINS_S | Close but no cigar! | Mon Jul 12 1993 08:21 | 9 |
| My wife says she quite often feels like hitting me when she's suffering
from PMT...she doesn't do it much anymore tho'.
I told here PMT or no PMT...if she hits me i'll hit her back!
She hasn't done it for quite some time.
And on my earlier note....I just assumed that most women suffer from
PMT at some time in their lives.....????
|
79.40 | can't prove you wrong... ;-) | GOLLY::SWALKER | | Mon Jul 12 1993 12:13 | 7 |
| > And on my earlier note....I just assumed that most women suffer from
> PMT at some time in their lives.....????
Well, strictly speaking, you realize, this is next to impossible to
prove, since you could only get a definitive "no" answer from the
dead. :-)
|
79.41 | | SMURF::BINDER | Deus tuus tibi sed deus meus mihi | Mon Jul 12 1993 12:36 | 4 |
| Even then, I'll bet, your answer won't be definitive, because there are
probably some women who do suffer from PMS but for whom it doesn't rise
above the consciousness quotient sufficiently to be recognized. Those
women might likely say no.
|
79.42 | gimme a break, dudes | TNPUBS::STEINHART | Back in the high life again | Mon Jul 12 1993 16:57 | 42 |
| I often get PMS and I do get "snappish" for a day or so. I get pretty
irritable but I mostly keep it under control, particularly if I am
aware that PMS is the cause.
Once every few months, I do lash out at someone verbally or in writing,
but I must say it sure feels good! I'm usually this meek,
mild-mannered type, and I don't lash unless the target had it coming!
I lash out about 95% less often than most men I know. :-)
Actually, men's harping on PMS kinda peeves me. While there are nasty
exceptions, including my luckily-former-sister-in-law, who use PMS as
an excuse to be awful, most women I know keep a grip on themselves no
matter how lousy they feel.
I think guys ought to give us credit for going on with our lives
despite PMS and painful, uncomfortable periods. Last time I
menstruated, I had severe cramping, no appetite, and felt generally
rotten. I did my normal work and parenting routines, and nobody was
the wiser.
I'd like to imagine men coping half as well as women do. If men had
menstrual cycles, there'd be dozens of medical studies on easing their
difficulties and companies would provide special sick days for this
purpose. ;-)
What really burns me is when I am mad, generally with good reason mind
you, and a man has pooh-poohed it as PMS. If he put a little energy
into understanding why I'm angry, there might have been some real
progress. Instead, the issue never gets resolved, I feel insulted, and
the relationship heads for demise.
If you value your relationships with the women in your lives, don't
minimize the discomforts of menstruation and the coping these women
exhibit. Don't sneer "PMS" when they are angry; Rather, try to
understand why they are angry and work to resolve issues.
Anyway, just think. No menstruation, no babies. Glad you've got your
kids? If their Moms didn't have menstrual cycles, you wouldn't be a
Little League coach today!
Laura
14-days-into-my-cycle-today
|
79.43 | | WAHOO::LEVESQUE | I set my sights and then home in | Tue Jul 13 1993 09:15 | 32 |
| Your note is filled with favorable generalizations about women and
unfavorable generalizations about men, Laura.
You begrudgingly admit that you become "snappish" on occasion as a result
of PMS, but when you really let someone have it "they had it coming."
That's a rather self-serving attitude.
And men don't comment about PMS, they HARP on it. But no matter, because
you are less nasty that 95% of the men you know.
I fully expected the old "men couldn't do half as well as women," and I
wasn't disappointed.
However, your note did in fact bring up some good points. (He says this
after picking on much of what she just said. :-)
I agree that men should give women credit for dealing with their cycle
and the physical and mental discomforts it involves. I'm sure as hell
glad that stuff doesn't happen to me, and I can generally deal with the
few days per month when emotional stress is heightened as a result of PMS.
I also think that some men tend to use PMS as the default reason for
women being angry/bitchy to relieve themelves of the burden of having to
think about what's really bothering them. Not smart.
Sometimes, however, it really is PMS at the root of the anger- making
a miniscule issue out to be mountainous. And I'm sorry, but those of us
not currently in the throes of a PMS attack cannot possibly fix all of these
things to your satisfaction when you are PMSing. It's not even sensible to
try.
|
79.44 | you feel lousy, you get irritable. simple. | TNPUBS::STEINHART | Back in the high life again | Tue Jul 13 1993 11:09 | 18 |
| What I didn't make clear in .42 is that times when I've been angry
about an issue in relationship with a man, and expressed this, I've
nearly always NOT been in PMS.
I only have PMS for a couple of days out of 28, and not even every
month. And when I have on rare occasions lashed out about something
during PMS, it has just as likely been a newspaper editorial, an
inconsiderate store clerk, and the jerk in the car ahead of me. When's
the last time YOU lashed out about such incidents? We're all human,
is all I'm saying. You don't feel good, you get irritable. I've more
often lashed out because I had low blood sugar, was hot, tired, worried
about my job. Don't you do the same?
More than one man has said, "You just have PMS. Get off my back," when
I didn't have PMS and did have a bone to pick with him. This is a good
way to find yourself back at the singles dances.
Laura
|
79.45 | | VAXWRK::STHILAIRE | a period of transition | Tue Jul 13 1993 13:13 | 16 |
| I'm convinced that if every man in the world had cramps as bad as I do
that there would be a special column on timecards, to check off, which
would be considered by everyone to be an acceptable reason for not
coming to work, and still getting paid. :-)
"Where's Jim today? We need to get this meeting started?" - a VP
"Oh, he's home in bed curled up with a heating pad. He has
really bad cramps this month." - another VP
"Oh, damn shame! Well, that's understandable. We can fill him in
later. Let's get this meeting off the ground." - first VP
Lorna
|
79.46 | | VMSMKT::KENAH | Escapes,Lies,Truth,Passion,Miracles | Tue Jul 13 1993 13:56 | 4 |
| From a comic I heard:
"If men had PMS, the budget allocation for its cure would
be bigger than the budget for NASA's moon landing program."
|
79.47 | | AIMHI::RAUH | I survived the Cruel Spa | Tue Jul 13 1993 14:13 | 2 |
| But in 1969 three times the money spent to put a man on the moon was
spent on cosmetics for women. Gee. I guess I dont get it.:)
|
79.48 | | PENUTS::DDESMAISONS | | Tue Jul 13 1993 14:17 | 6 |
|
>> But in 1969 three times the money spent to put a man on the moon was
>> spent on cosmetics for women. Gee. I guess I dont get it.:)
If you saw me at about 7 AM, you'd get it. *^)
|
79.49 | color me "pale clueless frost" | GOLLY::SWALKER | | Tue Jul 13 1993 14:19 | 11 |
| I think I'm missing the point of that last reply, George. Are you
trying to say that if women stopped wearing makeup, they'd be allowed
to go to the moon? :-)
These comparisons are so funny. Do you perchance have the figures
on how much men spent on shaving supplies in 1969, too? Or how much
out of the total spent on beer and chips was spent on beer and chips
for men?
Sharon
|
79.50 | | AIMHI::RAUH | I survived the Cruel Spa | Tue Jul 13 1993 14:45 | 2 |
| There is no real point. No more points than if men had PMS and how the
world would react to it. :)
|
79.51 | looks more important than health | VAXWRK::STHILAIRE | a period of transition | Tue Jul 13 1993 14:46 | 6 |
| re .47, simple explanation, George. Society has successfully
brainwashed most women into believing that it is more important to look
good, than it is to feel good.
Lorna
|
79.52 | For the humor challenged among you... | VMSMKT::KENAH | Escapes,Lies,Truth,Passion,Miracles | Tue Jul 13 1993 14:55 | 6 |
| George: It was a joke. It wasn't supposed to be taken seriously.
It was supposed to be funny.
Your mileage may vary.
andrew
|
79.53 | | AIMHI::RAUH | I survived the Cruel Spa | Tue Jul 13 1993 16:15 | 1 |
| I was joking too. Who is serious in the notes files?:_)
|
79.54 | | AIMHI::RAUH | I survived the Cruel Spa | Tue Jul 13 1993 16:19 | 5 |
| In reguards to beer and chips spent on the national average in 69...
Humm.. That is tuff.
Insofar as shaving cream, I think it dipped big time cause we all grew
beards and long hair.:)
|
79.55 | | HDLITE::ZARLENGA | Michael Zarlenga, Alpha P/PEG | Thu Jul 15 1993 13:21 | 5 |
| .52> It was supposed to be funny.
It was supposed to be funny to some women.
Kinda like the comic strip Sylvia.
|
79.56 | | QUARK::LIONEL | Free advice is worth every cent | Thu Jul 15 1993 15:58 | 5 |
| Re: .55
I find "Sylvia" hilarious....
Steve
|
79.57 | | WAHOO::LEVESQUE | Appellation Doctah Contr�l�e | Thu Jul 15 1993 16:14 | 1 |
| :-)
|
79.58 | | ASDG::FOSTER | Like a Phoenix Rising | Wed Jul 28 1993 10:48 | 16 |
|
I think the remark about PMS vs. NASA has to do with government
spending and research allocations which do NOT result in direct profit
for the companies involved. Since, to date, space travel has not shown
ANY level of profitability, but more a national pride, I consider it a
category unto itself. Much more comparable would be PMS and prostate
cancer. And I sense that prostate cancer isn't THAT well funded because
its embarrassing. But it MIGHT be better funded than PMS research. I
don't know.
There IS PMS research going on, and one of the possible solutions is
short-term medication such as anti-depressants. I fight a losing battle
with PMS, to such an extent that I will not go into details. While I'm
not sure that most people at work see it clearly, my family does.
Whatever I hear about in the way of medical solutions I'll report on
shortly... probably in Womannotes first.
|
79.59 | a few more thoughts | TNPUBS::STEINHART | Back in the high life again | Wed Jul 28 1993 11:16 | 27 |
| I've had some further thoughts on this topic, along the lines of "Hey
guys, if you had any idea how often women quietly endure discomfort from
PMS and menstruation, you'd be amazed."
You can add in:
o Pregnancy. If you want to know how uncomfortable or even miserable
it can be, take a stroll through PARENTING. How many of your
co-workers are quietly slipping into the ladies' room to barf, and you
never even knew? I remember standing and teaching 7 hours a day when
my hip hurt so bad I couldn't rotate on my right leg, or bend over.
When I was in the first trimester, and hardly showing, my soon-to-be-
ex said, "You are milking this pregnancy for all it's worth," when I
wanted to rest for 20 minutes after work before starting dinner.
o Post-partum. It took me months to feel normal again. Many women
cope with post-partum depression. It is bad. Very bad. Trust me.
o Menopause. How many of your relatives and co-workers are enduring
hot flashes and other symptoms? I bet you aren't even aware of it.
Now I'm not whining about how bad it is to be a woman. Overall, I like
it just fine, thank you. I am saying that your average woman has a lot
of guts and fortitude, and that your average man often doesn't even
know how much discomfort she is coping with.
Laura
|
79.60 | | MIMS::ARNETT_G | YOU! Out of the gene pool! | Wed Jul 28 1993 11:46 | 17 |
|
> I think the remark about PMS vs. NASA has to do with government
> spending and research allocations which do NOT result in direct profit
> for the companies involved. Since, to date, space travel has not shown
> ANY level of profitability, but more a national pride, I consider it a
> category unto itself.
Perhaps space travel hasn't been directly profitable, but what about
the indirect profits and contribution of our space efforts? The
miniaturiazation of computers? Use of satellites to accurately predict paths
of hurricanes, tornadoes and the like and the resultant saving of lives and
property? Various materials originally used for space-flight that are now
used in medicine and industry? How can you say that it has not been
profitable, both in value added to our lives and in money?
George
|
79.61 | You learn something new every day. | GYMAC::PNEAL | Hi, I'm DECresource 111xxx | Thu Jul 29 1993 07:18 | 6 |
| Lorna,
Can you clarify post-partum for me. I've heard of post-natal but post-partum !!
That's a new one.
Thanks
|
79.62 | | WAHOO::LEVESQUE | Bye Reg; we hardly knew ya | Thu Jul 29 1993 08:23 | 4 |
| PNEAL-
That was Laura, and post-partum is after birth. No doubt the same as post-natal.
Same difference between lift and elevator, I'd imagine.
|
79.63 | Thankyou | GYMAC::PNEAL | Hi, I'm DECresource 111xxx | Thu Jul 29 1993 11:07 | 0 |
79.64 | | AIMHI::RAUH | I survived the Cruel Spa | Thu Jul 29 1993 14:09 | 12 |
| >I think the remark about PMS vs. NASA has to do with government
>spending and research allocations which do NOT result in direct profit
>for the companies involved. Since, to date, space travel has not shown
>ANY level of profitability, but more a national pride, I consider it a
>category unto itself. Much more comparable would be PMS and prostate
Well.... Guess yha don't read much. ;) For there have been more than
computers, medicin, and lots of other business related things.
Including..... womens cosmetics.:)
Maybe its what your not reading. :)
|
79.65 | guys can cope with an occasional hurl | HDLITE::ZARLENGA | Michael Zarlenga, MRO AXP BPDA | Sat Jul 31 1993 20:48 | 9 |
| .59> it can be, take a stroll through PARENTING. How many of your
.59> co-workers are quietly slipping into the ladies' room to barf, and you
I've been known to barf after a good night on the town.
It's nothing special. The hardest part is getting rid of the monster
breath that follows.
Oh yeah, and flossing out all the decaying food residue.
|
79.66 | I needed that!? | CARTUN::TREMELLING | Making tomorrow yesterday, today! | Mon Aug 02 1993 13:44 | 19 |
| re: <<< Note 79.65 by HDLITE::ZARLENGA "Michael Zarlenga, MRO AXP BPDA" >>>
> -< guys can cope with an occasional hurl >-
>.59> it can be, take a stroll through PARENTING. How many of your
>.59> co-workers are quietly slipping into the ladies' room to barf, and you
> I've been known to barf after a good night on the town.
> It's nothing special. The hardest part is getting rid of the monster
> breath that follows.
> Oh yeah, and flossing out all the decaying food residue.
Thanks, Mike, that was so refreshing. I usually read notes during lunch...
RraAaLlPH!
|