[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference quark::human_relations-v1

Title:What's all this fuss about 'sax and violins'?
Notice:Archived V1 - Current conference is QUARK::HUMAN_RELATIONS
Moderator:ELESYS::JASNIEWSKI
Created:Fri May 09 1986
Last Modified:Wed Jun 26 1996
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1327
Total number of notes:28298

1284.0. "101 reasons *not* to call EAP" by QUARK::MODERATOR () Fri Jul 10 1992 11:36

    The following topic has been contributed by a member of our community
    who wishes to remain anonymous.  If you wish to contact the author by
    mail, please send your message to QUARK::MODERATOR, specifying the
    conference name and note number. Your message will be forwarded with
    your name attached  unless you request otherwise.

				Steve






    Well, it seems to be the season for anonymous posts, no?  Guess I'll
    chime in with my own...
    
    I've been grappling with depression for some time now.  Sometimes it'll
    hit me with almost debilitating force, and then it will go into
    remission for months.  I'll feel like I've finally overcome it, when
    *wham*: something will happen in my life which will bring it all back
    to bury me again.
    
    Sometimes I talk to my wife and friends about what's bothering me...
    almost every time, they say, "Call EAP!"  Well..... I'd love to,
    but.............. I never seem to run out of creativity when it comes
    to finding reasons *not* to call them.  Some are silly, some are
    serious, some are contradictory, but, as my wife says, "You're
    *working* at finding reasons not to call!"
    
    She's right, of course...
    
    Here's what I've managed to remember of my list so far (Okay, so
    there's only about 21 rather than 101:  anyone got any others?)
    
    	1. I keep losing the d@mned 800 number
    	  1a. And I'd die of embarrassment if a coworker saw me
    	      copying it down off the bulletin board.
    	  1b. ...or taking a brochure.
    
    	2. I can never seem to *remember* to call (except maybe
    	   at night, and even if they're on call at night, I
    	   don't want to bother them).
    
    	3. Big boys aren't supposed to *need* help.
    
    	4. You mean I'm going to call up a *total stranger* and
    	   tell him/her that I need help?
    
    	5. I'm afraid my coworkers will overhear me talking to
    	   them over the phone (and I don't want to call outside
    	   business hours; see #2)
    
    	6. My problems aren't severe enough to warrant their
    	   attention.
    
    	7. It's a really silly problem anyway, it shouldn't be
    	   bothering me.
    	   7a.  And I'd *die* of embarrassment admitting to a
    	      total stranger just how bad it *does* bother me.
    
    	8. My problems are too deep and complicated to handle with
    	   simple "counseling" -- I need to be pshrunk!
    	   8a.  And a pshrink who isn't a crank is impossible to find.
    	   8b.  And s/he will cost a fortune, which I don't have
    	   8c.  And I don't trust the ones my insurance *will* pay for.
    	   8d.  And insurance won't pay for enough to do any good.
    
    	9. I have dozens of *little* problems, and I'll probably not
    	   even remember them all to tell the counselor about them.
    	   9a.  ...and then the counselor will declare me cured after
    		quick-talking me through the few I *did* remember,
    		and I'll leave not feeling any better than before...
    
    	10. I'm afraid I'll draw some nitwit of a counselor who'll
    	   be no help at all
    	   10a. ...because DEC went with the lowest bidder
    	   10b. ...and maybe s/he will do more harm than good.
    
    	11. I'm afraid my boss or my coworkers will find out that
    	   I'm in counseling, with negative career repercussions.
    
    
    Now, I have three questions; one tongue-in-cheek, the others serious:
    
    	- Anybody got some other "winners" to add to the list? 8-)
    
    	- How can *I* summon the will to call them already?
    
    	- How can DEC, or any other institution that offers counseling,
    	  get that counseling to those who need it?  I went through much
    	  the same thing when I went to college:  there were counselors
    	  there who served much the same function as EAP, and I couldn't
    	  summon the will to visit *them* either (except once, on someone
    	  *ELSE'S* behalf...).  I am living testimony to the fact that
    	  those who need counseling the most are often the most reluctant
    	  to seek it out.  Can an institution such as DEC or a university
    	  be more pro-active in getting counseling to those who need it?
    
    Thanks, everyone!
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1284.1QUARK::LIONELFree advice is worth every centFri Jul 10 1992 11:449
The numbers are listed in the DEC phone book - they vary by
site.  When you call, all you have to say is that you'd like
to make an appointment, you don't have to tell them what it's
for, and to your nosy co-workers it sounds as if you're calling
a doctor.

Stop making excuses for yourself and just do it.

				Steve
1284.2WMOIS::REINKEthe fire and the rose are oneFri Jul 10 1992 11:498
    in re .0
    
    if you are sick you call a doctor, if you have personal problems
    look on EAP as another sort of doctor. I've been to them with
    problems, gotten referals and my life is much better after going
    to counceling...
    
    
1284.3Scared? No, terrified...BASCAS::HOLLANDS_CI'm going mad - wanna come too?Fri Jul 10 1992 12:5118
    I know how you feel - I can't ask for help either, no matter how much
    I feel that I need it. We have the added problem here in England that
    future employers are able to check with your medical record with your
    doctor, so if you seek help you're automatically labelled 'unstable'.
    
    I think the main problem with depression is the isolation - it's all
    very well to say someone to talk about it, but what if they're not
    interested? (believe me, this happens) About the last thing you can
    cope with when you're at your lowest ebb is rejection - better to say
    nothing than have the knife-twisting experience of getting up enough
    courage to confide in someone (stranger or friend), and have them turn
    away.
    
    I don't mean to sound like a complete cynic, I guess I'm just trying to
    say that I understand WHY you're coming up with elaborate excuses not to
    call. I'd admire you if you did tho'
    
    
1284.4reach out...TRACTR::QUAYLEi.e. AnnFri Jul 10 1992 14:1110
    My husband couldn't seek help either.  He, too, felt that a man
    should be able to handle his own (and his marital) problems.  Ah, well. 
    Why sigh for what might have been?
    
    I called EAP and had good experiences.  My depression no longer rules
    and ruins my life!
    
    Good wishes,
    aq
    
1284.5GET HELP NOW! ACESMK::LINEHANFri Jul 10 1992 15:1417
    Anon,
    
    Let me give you some firm advice.  I started with EAP in October of 91
    and he was so good, that I am still going to him and paying full price.
    He is aware that I have to pay him out of my own pocket and he does not
    press for payments.  Whatever you can afford whenever you can do it.
    
    It's so important to be a whole person and I have finally come to that 
    point.  I also hoped it would happen in four visits, and I would be
    cured.  It does not happen overnight.  You have to go through some
    bumps before you can rise above it all, but when you start rising above
    it all, it is a glorious feeling.
    
    Please do not wait any longer.  If you want anymore info call me or
    send me mail.  It's important to feel good about yourself.
    
    Nancy
1284.6VALKYR::RUSTFri Jul 10 1992 16:0517
    Re .0: Sounds familiar! "I can take care of my problems _myself_."
    Well, sure, maybe. You could probably make your own soap, too, but
    unless you really enjoy soapmaking it's a lot less painful to go buy
    some. 'sides, one thing you can never be for yourself is an objective
    observer. Go on - even just one visit might help. The very act of
    putting your problem(s) into words, to someone who isn't involved in
    those problems, can be an amazing relief.
    
    I eventually did contact EAP, but first I went through most of the
    reasons you list - plus my personal favorite. "If I call EAP, I won't
    be able to pretend that it isn't a problem anymore." 
    
    The good thing is, once I went to them, and realized how much my
    worries were taking out of me, I was on the road to making it _not_ be
    a problem anymore. Definitely, skip the excuses and give it a try.
    
    -b
1284.7TNPUBS::C_MILLERFri Jul 10 1992 17:264
    There are "family services" and many other forms of therapy available
    without having to go through EAP (that DEC will pay for). You can call
    your personal physician and ask for a referral and then no-one at DEC
    would know. I echo .1, stop thinking about it and just do it.
1284.8A wise man knows his limits and when to ask for help.CSC32::GORTMAKERWhatsa Gort?Fri Jul 10 1992 18:0121
    re.0
    Haven't read any of the replys yet but...
    
    Hogwash!
    
    It is *OK* to have problems we all have them but it *is not* OK
    to go on without seeking help. Do yourself a favor lose the pride
    and call EAP you have nothing to lose and everything to gain.
    
    After my divorce I used EAP to find a shrink and I'm glad that I did
    it helped me beyond measure. Nobody has to know but if they do find
    out be proud of the fact that you had the courage to help yourselfwhen
    you needed it. 
    
    PLease feel free to contact me directly if you want I would be happy
    to relate my experience with EAP if it will help.
    
    -jerry gortmaker
    CSC32::GORTMAKER
    DTN:592-5439
    
1284.9Go for it!STEREO::COCHRANECool,eclectic,live hot wire.Sun Jul 12 1992 23:527
    I've used EAP 3 times, and each time they have paired me
    with counselors who have been of immeasureable help.  I
    can't speak highly enough of them.  And besides, chances
    are some of your co-workers have been there too.  There's
    no shame in having problems you can't handle by yourself.
    
    Mary-Michael
1284.10MILKWY::ZARLENGAain't my type o'hype, baybehMon Jul 13 1992 01:0110
.6>    Re .0: Sounds familiar! "I can take care of my problems _myself_."
    
    There is a certain feeling of self-esteem and accomplishment to
    be had from handling problems by yourself - analyzing them and
    then solving them.
    
    And personally, if all I need is an ear, I'd rather turn to friends
    or relatives than strangers who get paid to listen.
    
    There is something to be said for learning self-sufficiency.
1284.11RIPPLE::KENNEDY_KAWinds of ChangeMon Jul 13 1992 03:1225
    Yes, Mike there is a certain feeling of self-esteem and accomplishment
    in "handling your problems by yourself".  But I find your answer cold
    and callous and unfeeling.  Personally, I don't know what I'd do if I
    didn't have a therapist because my friends are not always equipped to
    help me sort through whatever is going on in my life.  Sometimes there
    are deeper problems that can't be dealt with on an intellectual level. 
    It has to do with emotions and experiencing those emotions and resolving
    them and sometimes friends just can't help with those.  Depression is
    one of those emotions.
    
    I'm glad it works for you Mike.  I completely and totally disagree with
    it.  Why?  I've watched my father deal with problems exactly the way
    you are describing and now I'm watching his life fall down around him. 
    He has a wife that is brain-dead from alcoholism and a daughter that 
    won't speak to him because he chose to intellectualize everything. 
    Because he chose not to deal with the issues and problems on an
    emotional level.  Because he can't cope with emotions.
    
    To the basenoter, I apologize for bringing my own personal agenda in
    here.  It's ok to go into counseling and it's ok to find help.  There
    is nothing weak or unmanly about it.  It's human.  I hope you can work
    through your fear of looking "less than" and get the help you feel you
    need, whether it's from friends or a therapist.
    
    Karen
1284.12QUIVER::STEFANIStay within the lines, stay within the linesMon Jul 13 1992 11:5720
    re: .11
    
    I don't think Mike was blasting people who seek a therapist.  His
    assertion was that there can be some positive growth through
    self-awareness and relying on a network of friends.  I agree with you
    that this is not always feasible or ideal.  Many problems run deeper
    than be "talked through" and sometimes it's easier and/or better to
    speak to a trained professional who is detached emotionally from the
    situation.
    
    On the other hand, please don't imply that those of us who try to find
    our own insight and rely on close friends for our necessary support are
    somehow fooling ourselves or deprived emotionally.  I've had my boughts
    with depression, but I've gotten through them because of good friends,
    family support, and the silver lining eventually appearing.  It doesn't
    work for everyone, but it does work for many.
    
    Regards,
       Larry
            
1284.13Speaking as someone who prefers to tough it alone...ESGWST::RDAVISCarp per diemMon Jul 13 1992 12:1911
>    There is a certain feeling of self-esteem and accomplishment to
>    be had from handling problems by yourself - analyzing them and
    
    There's also a better chance of covering up real problems with specious
    analyses.  
    
    And friends and relatives are hardly detached observers, particularly
    when the problem involves friends and relatives.  Someone who's "paid
    to listen" may be the only reliable sanity check.
    
    Ray
1284.14Wisdom is knowing the difference.REGENT::BROOMHEADDon't panic -- yet.Mon Jul 13 1992 14:1111
    When our kitchen faucet started to split, we bought a new one and
    installed it outselves.  When the bathroom faucet started to leak,
    we got a new washer and installed it ourselves.  When the outside
    faucet started to leak, and the handle broke into pieces, we got a
    plumber, who, after only an hour and a half with a welding torch
    and forays into the basement, put on a new pipe and faucet.
    
    Somethimes -- er, some things, some times -- you do yourself; others,
    you get an expert.
    
    						Ann B.
1284.15HEYYOU::ZARLENGAain't my type o'hype, baybehMon Jul 13 1992 18:103
.12>   I don't think Mike was blasting people who seek a therapist.
    
    Of course I wasn't, Larry.
1284.16CSLALL::LSUNDELLI'm my old self againTue Jul 14 1992 01:238
    I haven't read all the comments made, but IMHO, and from past
    experiences, if there's something you don't want to do, you'll always
    find an excuse not to do it.  When you hurt bad enough and want the
    pain, no matter what kind of pain it is, to stop, then you'll do
    something about it.  Question is...how much do you want to suffer?
    
    Lynne