[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference quark::human_relations-v1

Title:What's all this fuss about 'sax and violins'?
Notice:Archived V1 - Current conference is QUARK::HUMAN_RELATIONS
Moderator:ELESYS::JASNIEWSKI
Created:Fri May 09 1986
Last Modified:Wed Jun 26 1996
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1327
Total number of notes:28298

812.0. "A problem sister" by QUARK::HR_MODERATOR () Wed Aug 09 1989 23:57

The following topic has been contributed by a member of our community who
wishes to remain anonymous.  If you wish to contact the author by mail, please
send your message to QUARK::HR_MODERATOR, specifying the relevant note number.
Your message will be forwarded with your name attached unless you request
otherwise.
				Steve

				





	This may be long so please bare with me...
	I'm not sure if I am asking for advice or if maybe I just need
	to get this off my chest.  The problem is my sister.

	My sister has always been the "problem child", I'm not sure if
	it is because she is the oldest of three. She has always caused
	a lot of pain and suffering in our family.   Until recently
	(March) her and her 8 year old daughter were living with my 
	parents.  During this time she basically did what she wanted,
	staying out all night long (knowing that my parents would make
	sure her daughter was o.k.) working when she felt like it, etc...
	My parents put up with it as they wanted to make sure her
	daughter was raised properly.

	She met a man in September, engaged in November and the family
	was notified Christmas Eve that she was going to have a baby!
	They were married in March.  She continued to drink during the
	whole pregnancy, I'm not talking a beer or two here and there..
	I'm talking drinking to the point of almost a stupor.  All of
	us have tried, to no avail, to help or, point out that she
	may be harming the baby, her standard reply "I'm 32 years old,
	I'm all grown up, don't tell me what to do".  As a result the
	baby was born early (1 month) is being monitored for 
	diabetes, and was born not knowing how to suck.  She is doing
	better, yet still very small, but I have noticed that she
	has tremors, small but there.  This baby is one month old and
	very tiny.

	Her other daughter is suffering also, as she spent 8 years of
	her life living with my parents.  She adores them, they adore
	her....Her husband has decided that she should not spend so
	much time with them, this is killing both her and my parents.
	Her daughter is also very much afraid of her mother when she
	drinks.  She hides in the closet so that her mother will not
	find her and hug her and ask her why she doesn't love her anymore.
	There are other things too.

	The killer was a week ago at my niece's christening (my brother's
	baby) a week ago.  She drank herself silly, could barely walk,
	called my parents names (filthy names) and made my brother's
	sister-in-law cry because of some very personal questions that
	she had no right asking.  Lastly she is not speaking to my mother
	because she believes that my mother told her husband that she 
	had been drinking to much and that my mother has no right as
	"She is a big girl now".

	I can't handle her much more.  I can't handle what she is doing
	to her family as well as ours.  She has caused me a lot of pain
	also, as well as my sister-in-law.  We really can not take much 
	more...

	What do we do?  Sorry for the rambling....
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
812.1FRECKL::HUTCHINSAnd on the 8th day...Thu Aug 10 1989 09:2023
    You sound as though you've identified the main problems through
    all the emotional "stuff" surrounding it.
    
    There are many notes in the file that deal with the issues surrounding
    substance abuse, dependency, so I'm not going to repeat what others
    have so eloquently written before.
    
    From what you write, your sister has problems with alcohol, which
    she is choosing to deny at this point.  Her problems are affecting
    the family, but until she admits that she has a problem, there is
    little that you can do for *her*.  What you can do for yourself,
    your parents and other family members, is to get help for yourself,
    either through books, counseling, meetings, or whatever means are
    most comfortable for you.  It's not easy.
    
    Melody Beattie and Janet Woititz have written some excellent books
    about co-dependency and families of alcoholics.
    
    If you'd like to write to me off-line, please feel free.
    
    Take care,
    Judi
    
812.2Call Al-AnonJAIMES::GODINThis is the only world we haveThu Aug 10 1989 10:2610
    Al-Anon is a program specifically designed for the family and friends
    of alcoholics -- helping them to learn how to deal with the situation
    and not facilitate it.
    
    I've never personally been involved in an alcoholic situation, but
    I have a dear friend who has found the strength and support she
    needs through Al-Anon.
    
    Best wishes for healing to all of you!
    Karen                   
812.3Go to Al-Anon, it's wonderful!FDCV06::ARVIDSONWhat does God need with a Starship?Thu Aug 10 1989 13:2410
RE: < Note 812.2 by JAIMES::GODIN "This is the only world we have" >
>                               -< Call Al-Anon >-
>
>    I've never personally been involved in an alcoholic situation, but
>    I have a dear friend who has found the strength and support she
>    needs through Al-Anon.
I second the Al-Anon suggestion!  From personal experience it is an
excellent *excellent* program!  Just do it!

Dan
812.4Sorry butGBMMKT::VACCHELLIIT TAKES TWOThu Aug 10 1989 13:329
    
    I don't want to saound like a hard *ss but......
    If your sister refuses to get help your parents can have her declared
    an unfit mother and gain custody of your niece's.  Maybe then she'll
    wake up.  Sounds to me like she doesn't care about anybody but herself.
    
    I wouldn't be so forgiving.
    
    Katrina
812.5Act now, before it's too lateSCDGAT::DUFFYEcstatic TintinnabulationsThu Aug 10 1989 14:2717
    If you're from the area, this morning's Boston Globe has an article
    about a father who adopted a child with Fetal Alcohol Syndrome.  This
    is no fooling matter.  That young baby (and its caretakers) have a
    long row to hoe.
    I will refrain from expressing a judgment re. your sister, but it
    sounds like the situation needs intervention, difficult decisions,
    group therapy/support (such as other replies have suggested, but
    I think more), and legal action.  For the sake of the family members
    and the two young children, try to avoid the "we can handle it"
    approach or the "keep the problem in the family" attitude.  Use the
    support (personal, community, legal, governmental) available to get
    out of the rut years of behavior have created, so that different
    ways of approaching this/these problem(s) can be developed.
    This is very difficult.  Use the resources at DEC (EAP) to get
    some guidance on some of the legal and social welfare issues as
    well as personal conflicts.  
    
812.6EAP?MAMTS7::TTAYLORThu Aug 10 1989 15:5312
    I agree with Katrina (.4).  She sounds like an unfit and uncaring
    mom to me ....
    
    Have you contacted EAP through DEC for help?  Give it a shot, they
    are a pretty good resource.  But still and all, I don't think Al-Anon
    will give you any help other than emotional support.  It won't change
    the situation, since your sister refuses to change her ways.
    
    Good luck.
    
    Tammi
    
812.7ACESMK::CHELSEAMostly harmless.Thu Aug 10 1989 16:0321
    Re: .0
    
    >"She is a big girl now".
    
    Yes, but age has never been a sure-fire cure for stupidity.
    
    Start documenting her condition.  Perhaps she just doesn't grasp how
    serious the situation is.  You don't say much about her husband;
    perhaps he doesn't know all about what's going on either.  If you do go
    the unfit mother route, you'll need to have evidence to demonstrate why
    she is unfit.
    
    As a big girl, she is responsible not only for herself but for her
    children.  Either she lives up to her responsibilities or she hands
    them over to someone who will.
    
    Al-Anon is a good suggestion.  Also, you might want to talk to an
    addiction counselor to find out how you can help your sister recognize
    her condition instead of denying it.  It sounds like you've all fallen
    into some patterns of behavior that you need to break; perhaps EAP can
    point you to someone who will help you break the cycle.
812.8It works, if you work itGLDOA::RACZKAC.B.Raczka /nev/dull @FHOThu Aug 10 1989 17:0337
    
    RE: .0
    
    Folks have offered Al-Anon as a resource to you.
    
    Al-Anon is another 12-Step program that will give families
    support from other families  in a similar state, 
    and methods (12 steps) to deal with the situation together.
                                                              
    You can attend alone, but it's designed for families as
    Alcoholism is a family desease.
    
    The word is 'detached'. You and your family will learn how to 
    detach yourselves from the situation and realize your sister
    isn't your responsibility.
    
    
    Another suggestion is Intervention ...
    
    Getting your sister help without taking responsibility for
    her problem is called 'intervention'.
    Intervention brings the family together with the person who
    is having difficulty along with a Doctor who by family
    direction will recommend a in-patient treatment program.
    After the person has entered treatment Al-Anon is
    recommend for the rest of the family ...this way everyone
    gets Educated/treated at the same time
    
    
    Not sure if I clarified this or not but I'd suggest getting
    your family together and deciding how everyone wants to
    approach it first
    
    Best wishes to you...if you need more info or want personal
    testimony send mail
    
    --Christopher
812.9State social services?ULTRA::WITTENBERGSo Many Women, So Little Time.Thu Aug 10 1989 17:3210
    Is she  abusing the children? It's hard to get action based on her
    scaring  them, but an MD I know had a woman bring in her niece who
    had  clearly been abused. The Doctor is legally required to report
    the  abuse  (which  she  did),  adn the child was removed from her
    parents.  I  don't know who got custody. My friend thinks that the
    aunt  was  bringing the child to her specifically to get the state
    social services groups involved. It certainly worked. (This was in
    NY, but I think the laws are similar in much of the country.)

--David
812.10Get legal assistance...DONVAN::PEGGYFri Aug 11 1989 14:1719
    You are in an extremly difficult situation.  My prayers are with
    you and your entire family, especialy your neices.  
    Intervention is a good way to go many times.  Call your doctor or 
    the local AA number. I'm sure they can give you alot of information 
    about it.  
    As far as calling Chid Protective Services...It may be better to 
    contact your own lawyer first.  If you don't have one think seriously
    about retaining one.  
    There is no garantee that any one in your family will be allowed to 
    raise the children.  They will most likely go to 1 or more foster
    homes.  CPS are not there for the family there are there ONLY to 
    see that the child/ren are not abused or neglected.  
    Above all talk everything over with your relatives and seek outside 
    help.  And remember, just because you love someone that dosen't mean
    you have to like everything that they do.  (the  reverse is equally
    true).  
    Best wishes.
    Peggy