| Title: | What's all this fuss about 'sax and violins'? |
| Notice: | Archived V1 - Current conference is QUARK::HUMAN_RELATIONS |
| Moderator: | ELESYS::JASNIEWSKI |
| Created: | Fri May 09 1986 |
| Last Modified: | Wed Jun 26 1996 |
| Last Successful Update: | Fri Jun 06 1997 |
| Number of topics: | 1327 |
| Total number of notes: | 28298 |
The difference betweeen a judgement and a view/opinion.
For example, when a judge expresses his/her VIEW, the view doesn't impact
anything. However, when he passes a JUDGEMENT, he may be affecting the lives of
the defendant and/or the plaintiff.
What does it mean when you or I say, "I don't like Jim_bob."
Is that a judgement or a view or is there no difference?
| T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 480.1 | My def | ELESYS::JASNIEWSKI | Turning down to Zero | Tue Mar 08 1988 10:37 | 10 |
A judgement is conclusive in nature while a view is merely an
observation.
Note that "I dont like Jim_bob" is an awareness of one's
reactionary feelings toward the observation, while "Jim_bob is
an ...." is conclusive in context.
Joe Jas
| |||||
| 480.2 | my judgement! | ORACLE::KHANNA | Thu Mar 10 1988 17:38 | 6 | |
RE:0
I agree with .1 but only to a certain extent! A judgement has a
degree of finality to it as opposed to a view, but that does not
mean that a view in not final and binding. In my opinion a judgement
is just a stronger form of view.
| |||||
| 480.3 | Evidence and presidence for judgements? | PSG::PURMAL | Ca plane pour moi | Thu Mar 10 1988 18:38 | 13 |
I would venture to say that judicially a judgement must be
supported by facts (laws, previous rulings, etc.) whereas a view
or opinion need not have precidence.
For example a judge may have the view that all litterbugs should
be forced to eat their litter, but they may not pass that as judgement
because the laws in force do not support that judgement.
Ouside the judical arena judgements and views are close, but
a judgement implies the inclusion of evidence.
ASP
| |||||