[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference quark::human_relations-v1

Title:What's all this fuss about 'sax and violins'?
Notice:Archived V1 - Current conference is QUARK::HUMAN_RELATIONS
Moderator:ELESYS::JASNIEWSKI
Created:Fri May 09 1986
Last Modified:Wed Jun 26 1996
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1327
Total number of notes:28298

296.0. "Is COMMITMENT such a bad word?" by CSC32::C_HAMPTON () Mon Apr 27 1987 20:36

    
Is everyone afraid of COMMITMENT?  It seems like in the past
few months most of my friends and ME are having problems with
commitments in relationships...I don't have a problem being
committed to someone it's just that when they (HE) feels that
the relationship is getting serious, e.g. I am starting to really
care for her or I am spending a lot of time with her and ignoring
other responsiblities, they WHIMP OUT!  They get scared and back
off.  Saying stupid things like "Oh, I just felt that I needed
someone to be with for a while" or after 2 months "I don't feel
like your the one I want to live the rest of my life with". 
Who gave them an alloted time frame to decide if the person is
right for them or not?

I seem to run across men that have been severely scared by
the mean and terrible things that women can do, I am amazed
what some of these guys have been through.  They can't see
me for what I am worth.  I am mistrusted in everything I say.  

And the worst part of it is that the guy will walk around moping
saying things like" I am so lonely, I want to get married",
How do they think it is going to happen if they don't give
a relationship a chance to mature?

I have a friend that just got out of a 2 1/2 year relationship
with a guy that she gave her all.  She met someone shortly
afterward (when she wasn't looking , it just happened) and
felt that the relationship was a dream, it was going so 
well that it was to good to be true!  After a month, last night,
He said he wanted to break up,  that he wasn't ready for such a 
commitment after he had been telling her all along that she was 
the best thing that ever happened to him.  Does that make sense?

I am wondering if people all over are experienceing the same
thing, or if their friends are?  Or is it just a bad year
for me?

Can anyone convince me that all us singles aren't doomed, and
that this problem isn't going to manifest itself because of
people continuely going through bad relationships?

I am to the point where I am seriously considering becoming
a NUN!

Carole (SWISOMWAGMAOCOHOTMU)

Translated to: Single Women In Search Of Men Who Aren' Gay, Married,
	       AFRAID OF COMMITMENT, Or Hung-up On Their Mothers, United
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
296.3I'm A Fool, Don't Tell My Boss!ANGORA::RTURNERHi Mom! Send Money!Mon Apr 27 1987 22:4428
    
    
    >           ... except for fools too stupid to understand ...
    
    I hereby declare myself to be a fool.  And I think I prefer to stay
    a fool if being wise means being afraid of commitment.
    
    I've always considered a fear of commitment as a sign of insecurity.
    
    For the last five months, my SO has been 1000 miles away.  We've
    only seen each other three times over this period, yet I go to bed
    smiling every night because I know that both of us are totally
    committed to our relationship.  It's my commitment that keeps me
    going every day.
    
    I admit that this kind of commitment can lead to very hurtin' times.
    But, that's a chance that I'm willing to take.  I've lived through
    it before, and I'll probably live through it again.  I just happen
    to believe in giving everything to a relationship.  If it gets thrown
    back into my face, then I'll just wipe it off and go on.
    
    Enough from this fool!!
    
    Good Luck .0
    
    Ron Turner   (*-+++++<
    
    
296.4Me, too!HUMAN::BURROWSJim BurrowsTue Apr 28 1987 00:455
        Predictably, I'll also side with the fools in this one. I fully
        believe in commitment. 'course that does you no good as I'm
        happily married, but... 
        
        JimB.
296.5GCANYN::TATISTCHEFFTue Apr 28 1987 01:2321
    <SET TONE/PREACHING_AGAIN>
    
    I think a lot of men and women (most, but who am I to know...) would
    agree, committment isn't THAT bad, pretty neat actually.  I think
    you just gotta pick 'em better ("and who am *I* to talk?" Single
    as hell...).
    
    The men I date may complain about the third degree, but I want to
    know as much as possible about their past experiences (of the romantic
    sort), not to know what they have done or had done to them but TO
    SEE HOW THEY FEEL ABOUT IT NOW.  Someone who feels they got shafted
    and has no good feelings about any of their ex's is usually someone
    who shafted themselves.
    
    If in the litany of past loves/disasters you hear _nothing_ positive
    and you hear about romances "nipped in the bud", chances are you're
    just going to join the crowd.  You never hear what REALLY happened
    anyhow, just your potential mate's INTERPRETATION of it.  Sort of
    a preview of what to expect of this person's behaviour.
    
    Lee
296.6--< we all get scared >--SSVAX::LAVOIETue Apr 28 1987 09:5732
    
    After being at the "burnt" end of a relationship, sometimes people
    get wary and afraid of being hurt again. This causes them to break
    off a relationship when it seems everything is going along fine.
    For the breaker it reminds them of when they were with "x" and they
    (male or female) can't stand the thought of going through the anguish,
    hurt, pain or even humiliation. So they end it before they get hurt
    or even get a chance to find out what is really going on. It boils
    down to being scared.
    
    We all get scared of things. When we let someone into our lives
    it make us vulnerable in the emotional aspect. Emotions once betrayed
    seem to be the hardest thing to recover. Painful memories stick
    around and you hurt. Things, places, and names remind of your SO
    and it seems hard to let go especially if you travel in the same
    social circles.
    
    From experience when my SO and I broke up I was miserable until
    I packed all of his things into a box (everything that reminded
    me of him too!) and tucked away in the corner of my closet. The
    next thing I did was to try and enjoy being single. Going places
    I hadn't when we were together. There was an eloquent story about
    breaking up in one of the supermarket mag's (Women's Circle I think).
    The fictitious lady was in mourning over her ex and she put everything
    he gave her (within reason) in a small box and buried it. After
    a year of not having these possessions to hold and cry over she
    found that she could go on with her life. It seems funny but I keep
    hearing that it takes about a year to really get over a relationship
    fully. Maybe we rush into the next one too quick and scares us away
    from commitment.
    
    
296.7--> One more thing <--SSVAX::LAVOIETue Apr 28 1987 10:0125
    I forgot to add this, it is a poem sent to me by a friend...
    
    Comes the Dawn
    
    After awhile you learn the subtle difference,
    Beteen holding a hand and chaining a soul,
    And you learn that love doesn't mean leaning,
    And company doesn't mean security,
    And you begin to learn that kisses aren't contracts,
    And presents aren't promises,
    And you begin to accept your defeats,
    With your eyes open,
    With the grace of a woman,
    Not the grief of a child.
    And you build your roads on today,
    Because tomorrow's ground is too uncertain for plans,
    And futures have a way of falling down in midflight.
    After awhile you learn that eve sunshine burns if you get too much.
    So plant your own garden and decorate your own soul.
    Instead of waiting for someone to bring you flowers.
    And you learn that you really can endure......
    That you really are strong,
    And you do have worth,
    And you learn and learn,
    With evey goodbye you learn.
296.8Loss of ControlHPSCAD::WALLI see the middle kingdom...Tue Apr 28 1987 10:4724
    
    This may be completely out to lunch, but being thought a lunatic
    doesn't really bother me.
    
    I think our culture exerts a certain amount of pressure on people
    to grow up as quickly as possible, and that the inability to commit
    is a reaction to that pressure.  We get saddled with responsibilities
    of one sort or another very quickly.
    
    A relationship is a big responsibility too, you know.  In a lot
    of cases, it may be the straw that breaks the camel's back.  One
    partner mentions commitment, and quite suddenly it dawns on the
    other one what a responsibility a relationship is.  And the gut
    reaction is to get angry or frightened because they don't want another
    thing to worry about right now, or they can't handle another
    responsibility.  People who are angry or frightened do not behave
    rationally.  Hence the phenomena of relationships sundered at the
    first mention of commitment.
    
    I've never confronted this problem myself, but I've certainly heard
    of it often enough.  Another reminder that it's a tough old world,
    and some of us are going to have to make it alone.
    
    DFW
296.9Bravo, 296.7!TSG::MCGOVERNSzechuan VanillaTue Apr 28 1987 11:027
    I think the poem in .7 says it all.  Love yourself, be true to what
    you want (not what you think or have been socialized to want), and
    stand up for yourself.  Then, as you develop more and more
    self-confidence and strength, you can develop relationships based
    on solid emotional ground.  These relationships tend to work in
    my experience (single, "committed" for 4 years, and planning marriage.)
    Takes time, though.
296.10G=>C=>L, usuallyKRYPTN::JASNIEWSKITue Apr 28 1987 13:4219
    
    	Some people are real fickle; they always want their "one way
    out". They'll wager what they have now just to roll the dice one
    more time. They dont want to give up their potential for "something
    else/more/different/whatever"... It takes a bit of maturity to give
    up the selfish, perhaps childish freedoms. I imagine, for the most
    part, that the people who have commited have found a whole lot more!
    	
    	Since maturity comes from growing through experience, perhaps
    you are simply "further along" in life than they are. Who is doing
    most of the growing in the relationship so far? Does anyone even
    want to grow or are they just riding time? Do you think you can both
    grow in the same direction? 
    
    	Commitment, Love and Growth are closely intertwined. Think about
    it.
    
    	JJJ
    
296.11Walk, then runDSSDEV::BURROWSJim BurrowsTue Apr 28 1987 13:5439
        I'm not sure that I agree with Mr. Wall's analysis that the
        pressure to grow up too quickly is at the root of the problem
        with commitments, but I do aggree that our culture does have a
        lot of pressure in this direction, and that it contributes to
        problems with relationships in general. 
        
        It seems very important to me to teach our children to savor
        each stage of life for what it is and then to go on to the next
        stage. I feel that skills at relating to other people are sort
        of hierarchical. Our skills at one tage are built upon our
        success and experience at the previous one.
        
        In the realm of romance, I think that building a marriage is
        dependant, somewhat on our previous romantic experinces. What we
        learned from all of the temporary romances helps us to build the
        permanent one. This only happens if we let the temporary ones be
        temporary. If we try to force each one to be permanent (and
        fail) all we learn is how to fail. If we enjoy each of our early
        romances for what it is and become adept at relating to those we
        love, then when one grows into something more we have something
        to go on. Romances, in turn, probably build on our successes
        at frindships, and in dealing with our family.
        
        In our culture we tend to want to get straight to the "good
        stuff". We see college merely as job training, rather than the
        unique learning experience that it is. We see kissing and
        "making out" as something we do until we can find someone
        willing to go all the way. We latch onto boyfriends and
        girlfriends, trying to make them into "steadies", fianc�es and
        spouses rather than just learning to love them.
        
        I really do think it is important to learn to walk before we run
        and to stand on our own before either. If we don't we cheat
        ourselves of an enjoyable experience, and we harm our education
        and development. On result of this general problem could easily
        be the fear of commitment or the inability to do it. There
        may be other causes.
        
        JimB. 
296.12ramblings on societal factorsCREDIT::RANDALLBonnie Randall SchutzmanTue Apr 28 1987 14:2960
    The note that follows is not a response to any particular reply, rather
    a discussion of what I see as another societal factor in general fear
    of commitment -- a fear that is certainly not limited to men! 
    
    This factor is a common belief that we can have "it" all, whatever it
    is, and that we can have it now. (Sometimes it even seems like if we
    don't have it all now, we're failures.) 
    
    Commitment means that you choose to make something a priority in your
    life.  By implication, you choose to give up other things if they
    interfere with what you've committed yourself to.  For instance,
    if you're an athlete in training for the Olympic marathon, you put
    in your mileage and your speed work every day no matter how much
    you would rather sit at home and have a beer while you watch TV.

    Most of the rest of us go through life hedging our bets. We want to get
    married and have the good things of companionship and devotion, but we
    don't want to give up the fun and freedom of the single life.  We want
    to have children, but we don't want to spend nights bringing fruit
    juice to a baby with a cold.  We want to be known as humanitarians but
    we don't want to give up our Saturday night parties to be a Big Brother
    or Big Sister to a kid without a family.  We want to be famous writers,
    but we don't want to give up the security of a regular paycheck or even
    devote the time to polishing our craft. We don't want to work at
    building up our skills and our audience over the course of years; we
    want our first book on the best-seller list. 
    
    This attitude waters down what commitments we do make.  As .11
    mentions, we don't take time to enjoy what we're doing, and I think a
    lot of it is because we're too busy worrying about the other things we
    could be doing.  We focus attention on the things we give up rather
    than on the good things to be gained by making our choices with open
    minds and then living by them. 
    
    If you look at a relationship that might, with time, grow into a
    committed relationship, and you see only the freedom you're giving up,
    the partners you will never have, the sexual variety that you might
    never otherwise experience, and the danger that after giving up all
    that, the relationship might crumble anyway, you're right to feel
    afraid of the chance you're taking.   Similarly, if you (me) want to be
    a writer, and you look only at the fancy dinners you won't be able to
    go out to any more because you won't have the money to eat out, you
    won't see that the choice itself has to satisfy you.  Letting go of
    the other things you could have been is one of the scariest things
    you can do. 
    
    True, you don't want to let other people tell you, in the words of the
    ad, that you can't have pinstripes and basketball too. You have to be
    yourself.  But you have to make sure your self isn't spread so thin over
    so many things that you never have time to enjoy the pleasures of going
    deep.  We can too easily spend a little time doing this, a little time
    doing that, and wind up being hacks of all trades and masters of none. 
 
    --bonnie
    
    * no, I'm not being hypocritical here; I did leave the DEC-womb
    for the cold cruel world and I'm only back on contract.  I would
    not go so far as to say you have to ignore the $$$ entirely. Nor
    would I rule out the possibility that for some people, the pursuit
    of $$$$ is an end in itself.
296.13You are everythingORION::HERBERTWhat a long, strange trip it&#039;s beenTue Apr 28 1987 14:5533
    Hi Carole,
    
    I don't know if this will be helpful to you, but when I was "on
    the loose" (so to speak) and searching for a wonderful male person
    to share life with, I found myself being severely disappointed with
    all of them.  The world is quite mixed up, and so are many of the
    people in it...and hard as you try, you may not be able to figure
    out one particular answer or method that will change what you are
    experiencing.  It's just very complex.  (At least, in my opinion.)
    
    I finally got to a point of throwing up my hands in disgust and
    saying..."Fine!  I can go through this life happier by myself than
    constantly putting energy into black holes (like trying to make
    something work with another mixed-up person)."  I found a quote 
    that I really like, and it was very true for me...
    
      "It is more important to be the right person, than to find the
       right person."
    
    With that thought, I set out to have a great life...me, myself,
    and I...sharing with those who were willing, but expecting nothing
    permanent, ever.  I was happier than I'd ever been.  About a month
    later, I met someone whom I became casual friends with (still expecting
    nothing and looking for nothing) and it grew into best friends and
    now we're married...although, I prefer to say we're hanging out
    together, having a good time sharing life.
    
    We often say that our relationship seems as if it will last forever,
    but who knows?  It doesn't really matter.  All that matters is being
    happy with yourself.  By not expecting anything, and not looking
    for anything...I have a strong feeling that you'll get everything!
    
    Jerri
296.14Don't despair!!VICKI::BULLOCKLiving the good lifeTue Apr 28 1987 15:3441
    Take heart, Carole--
    
    What Jerri (.13) so wisely says about living the best life for YOU
    is true.  I had to laugh about your abbreviation--about a year ago
    I felt EXACTLY the same way!!  I had had a perfectly disasterous
    relationship of 4 years, finally broke away, and was quietly washing
    up on the shores when someone made a play for me that my poor bruised
    ego just couldn't resist.  So off I went--this relationship quickly
    went downhill (those knights in shining armour have to get down
    off their horses sometime, you know);  leaving me feeling worse
    than ever.
    
    I finally realized that with all the effort and strength I was putting
    into "Making The Relationship Work", I could just as easily put
    the effort into making myself happy.  With no man in my life making
    me happy/unhappy, I found myself in a position to call the shots.
    I made a deal with myself that I wouldn't take second best again.
    I had learned from my past dealings SOME danger signs!  Just by
    my saying to myself that I really did deserve the best, and that
    committment is NOT a dirty word, I immediately felt better!  
    
    As a matter of fact, I met the person I am "happily involved with"
    thru DECSINGLES.  This time I didn't hide what I wanted ultimately
    from a relationship (I think my words were something like, "Look.
    This is what I want from a relationship, I fully intend to have
    it, and if this is something you are afraid of or don't want then
    PLEASE DON'T WASTE MY TIME!" Believe it or not, we came to a very
    workable compromise, and we are both happy with it, and best of
    all with ourselves.).
    
    I am really sorry this note is so long--it's just that I have been
    where you are before, and YES, THERE ARE MANY MORE WONDERFUL, LOVING,
    SECURE, AND HAPPY MEN OUT THERE WHO WANT AND WELCOME LOVE AND
    COMMITTMENT.  But believe me--spend time on YOU first.  Whoever
    said that phrase about being the right person first instead of looking
    for the right person is correct!!  Now's YOUR time--rejoice in it
    and what you want!
    
    You aren't alone,
    
    Jane
296.15Friends first...MARCIE::JLAMOTTEI&#039;m DifferentTue Apr 28 1987 16:4212
    Although I am not in a committed relationship right now, I have
    found happiness....and it has been through the process that the
    last few writers are talking about.  Life is good, I enjoy it and
    if anything else happens it will be more than frosting on the cake
    it will be decorations.
    
    I think that some of our problems lie in the way we meet.  We meet
    and we put ourselves in dating situations immediately.  It takes
    a strong person to insist on a period of friendship, but that is
    a way to take the time to get to know an individual.  Deciding not
    to become lovers but to remain friends is far less traumatic than
    becoming lovers and breaking up.
296.16Time is all it takes.. (Isn't it? :-))AXEL::FOLEYRebel without a clueTue Apr 28 1987 19:2519
    Wow, what an interesting topic! I'm enjoying the insight of others.
    
    Have no fear Carole as there are nice guys out there who do want
    that commitment and everything that goes with it.. But as you said,
    many have been "screwed" by previous relationships that they
    are mixed up. 
    
    Jane said it best when she said "Make yourself happy". Remembering
    the fact that no other person can MAKE YOU happy, that only YOU
    can make YOURSELF happy has helped me alot. And also what else
    Jane said about "Only deserving the very best" is key. I've found
    that I'm in that situation now.. (although I do feel a little guilty
    thinking that I'm TOO finicky) I'm kinda hoping to find "someone
    to hang out with on a regular basis" and I'll just keep shopping
    until I get what I want.. Granted, I do get sick of shopping and
    just wish someone sent it to me in the mail.. :-) :-)
    
    
    							mike
296.17What isn't commitment?YODA::BARANSKI1&#039;s &amp; 0&#039;s, what could be simpler?!Wed Apr 29 1987 15:4218
Who, me?  I've allways been a fool.  Fools Unite!

What you say about not making every relationship permanent is true...

I'd like to make a distinction between commitment, and <something else>.

Once, after being particularly burned, I decided to approach a relationship as
temporary...  I enjoyed that relationship very much.  Both of us knew that the
relationship was not "permanent".  We enjoyed each other's company without
thought of trying to make each other into respectable mates.  We spent a lot of
time together, but we still had seperate activities when one was unavailable...

Then I was reminded that the relationship was temporary by it ending; she found
someone who was 'just right'.  I found to my surprise that I was at least as
hurt as if I had been "commited" to making the relation permanent!  That idea
didn't work out so hot... 

Jim.
296.20Men more than women...?CSC32::C_HAMPTONWed Apr 29 1987 18:1324
    
    
    RE .18
    
    My view, obviously, is from the female side.  Being that most
    of my friends are females I hear the problem being with men.
    The orginal note was meant to discuss problems that people 
    are having on the subject of committment.  The example used
    just happen to come from my personal experience.  Even if
    it looks like men have the biggest problem with committment,
    based on the replys, don't take it personally you are unique
    in yourself!
    
    
    I must add, being the originator of the note, that the replys
    have helped me tremendously to view the situation as "an experience"
    in life.  I certainly hope I don't run into it again, and
    will be more cautious in the future.  I liked the reply about
    telling the person what I am looking for in a relationship
    before "getting started", I am going to try that.

    Please continue with the replys, the more views, the better!
    
    Carole...
296.21I can see the flames nowVINO::MCARLETONReality; what a concept!Wed Apr 29 1987 18:4164
    Oh no here we go with a dissenting opinion....
    
    On the question of "Why are men afraid to commit?", please read
    the book:
    
    		"Why Men Are the Way They Are
    				The Male:Female Dynamic"
    
    I don't remember the author's name but he has started many Men's
    and Women's groups across the country and was once involved with
    NOW.  He also wrote "The Liberated Man".
    
    His contention in the book is that male "Fear of Commitment" is
    a myth.  The claim that a particular male is afraid to commit is
    just a ploy to get a man to say "I'm not afraid of anything" and
    be more willing to commit.
    
    He bases his contentions on his analysis of the primary fantasies
    of both men and women.  Based on a study of the most popular male
    and female oriented magazines this is what he finds:
    
    The primary male fantasy is to have sex with as many beautiful women
    as possible.
    
    The primary female fantasy is to get commitment from a man who can
    provide for them in grand style.  (The knight on a white horse)
    
    Each sex works to manipulate the other into providing their primary
    fantasy without having to give up their own fantasy.
    
    With this reasoning the reason men would not want to commit could
    be:
    
    o He does not want to provide for the woman many of the fruits of
      his education and labors.
    
    o He does not what to give up his primary fantasy.
    
    This could be very true if the man does not have to commit to get
    sex from the woman who wants the commitment.
    
    But clearly some men do give up their primary fantasy in order to
    commit.  Why?
    
    The author maintains that a man will give up his primary fantasy
    to secure his primary need, love and intimacy.
                                                             
    I also contend that a man will commit in order to have children.
    
    I think that all that was said in the other replies is good but I don't
    really think that those answers are very satisfying.  I don't believe that
    men are as fragile as most of the other notes contend.

    I will say that many of his aguments are overdrawn and don't fit
    an awful lot of people.  I think that there are very many women
    here at DEC that can easly provide for themselves and arn't looking
    for a "Knight in shining Armor" to "Flashdance" them into securty.
    
    Ask yourself though...Would you need him to commit as much if it
    was understood that as soon as he did he could quit his job and
    that you would support him?
    
    						MJC O->
    
296.22So that's why I'm so confused!DSSDEV::BURROWSJim BurrowsWed Apr 29 1987 19:0818
        Well, now I know what's wrong with me--I have the wrong fantasy.
        It has never been my primary fantasy "to have sex with as many
        beautiful women as possible". I've fantasized about specific
        women, and when none were available about specific fantasy
        women, but never just "lots of women". 
        
        Beyond that, execpting sexy dreams (which I take it merely
        indicate that you're horny), sex _per_se_ hasn't been a big
        fantasy with me. My fantasies in the realms of relationships
        have centered around love and intimacy. (Seems I've got my
        fantasy confused with my needs, or something.) 
        
        Of course, the other possibility is that the notion that you can
        understand men and women and the differences between them "based
        on a study of the most popular male and female oriented
        magazines" just doesn't stand up.
        
        JimB. 
296.23ARMORY::CHARBONNDThu Apr 30 1987 07:4512
    I dunno, maybe I'm old-fashioned. I strongly believe that
    commitments are made to be KEPT. Nowadays it seems okay
    to a lot of people to break commitments, then excuse them-
    selves by saying "I forgot" or " I didn't feel like it".
    (Remember the Steve Martin routine on that first ? Did you
    laugh ? Still laughing ?) People think nothing of making
    small commitments ( I'll call you at 8 ) and then, when you
    say "where were you ?" they brush it off as a small thing.
    Having personally been through this routine many 'small'
    instances, I wonder if I can believe in *major* commitments.
    If you want another person to make a commitment to you,
    you have to have credibility yourself. 
296.24JimB don't countVINO::MCARLETONReality; what a concept!Thu Apr 30 1987 09:3727
    
    Re: .22
    
    Well Jim, it is true that I did not see your name anywhere in the
    book so I guess the author must not have contacted you to check
    whether the fantasy is universal.
    
    The point of this note is that some women have trouble getting
    some men to commit.  Since in .4 you proclaimed you yourself
    "fully believe in commitment" it is not surprising that you
    also do not show other characteristics of those for which
    commitment is a problem.  If you don't have the disease you probably
    don't show the symptoms either.
    
    I have read the book and I don't think that his theories will just
    just dry up and blow away with a puff of rhetoric.  I have a healthy
    distrust of statistics but I still think that he makes his case.
    His theories have the same characteristic of all good theories;
    the theory explains much more than the phenomena it was devised to
    explain.
    
    Re: .*
    
    The fact that a man is unwilling to commit does not imply that
    there must be something wrong with the man.
    
    						MJC O->
296.25I am an individual!ERIS::CALLASSo many ratholes, so little timeThu Apr 30 1987 11:3411
    Yeah, obviously since fellas like JimB and myself don't fit the theory,
    we're not really men. I would be suspect of anyone who tries to make
    the world fit a pet theory. Statistics is a great way to do this. You
    just call everything that doesn't fit the theory "an outlier" and
    discard them. Presto, the theory works. 
    
    I'm reminded of a quote I once read that went something like, "There is
    only one evil, treating an individual as a member of a group. All the
    others fall from that." 
    
    	Jon
296.26Atempting to avoid the ratholeVINO::MCARLETONReality; what a concept!Thu Apr 30 1987 13:1126
    Oh no ... There it is ... the *STATISTICS RATHOLE*.
    
    Well I guess that since I'm in this rathole now I might as well
    say a few words.
    
    The standard defense against even the most overwelming statistics
    is "I can find one exception so it must not be true."  So many
    people insist on throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
    
    Someone said "It is a sign of a great mind when a person can me
    moved by statistics".
    
    All of this statistics stuff misses the point though.  The original
    theories were developed out of years of starting men's groups and the
    things that the author herd men say about their relationships in those
    groups.  The statistics are only used (used well I think) to support
    the theories. It could be that the people who could be found in those
    groups where having more problems with commitments than some of the men
    here.  You don't have these problems...Great...good for you...but what
    about the rest of the world.
    
    I believe that the book sheds some light on the Male-Female power
    struggle.  Have a look at it.  You might even agree.
    
    						MJC O-> 
    
296.27ARMORY::CHARBONNDThu Apr 30 1987 13:111
    Individuality is the shit end of the bell curve
296.28Looken' for a Hardheaded Woman...YODA::BARANSKI1&#039;s &amp; 0&#039;s, what could be simpler?!Thu Apr 30 1987 16:1121
"I've heard just as many women back out at minute last as men..." .18

As a male, I can assure you of that... :-)

"Ask yourself though...Would you need him to commit as much if it was understood
that as soon as he did he could quit his job and that you would support him?".20

Very good question!  Any of you ladies want to answer that? :-}

"The fact that a man is unwilling to commit does not imply that there must be
something wrong with the man." .24

You got that right!  Let's just face it (no abuse intended) you were not 'right
for him' enough for that man at that time for him to give up *, to make a
commitment to you.  It happens *all* the time to *everybody*.  (well at least me
:-)) 

Personally, I'm looking for a relationship where I don't *have* to "give up"
*anything* (that I don't want to on it's own merits). 

Jim.
296.29Take it easy!CSC32::C_HAMPTONThu Apr 30 1987 17:4343
    
    


OOOOOOOOOOOO, this is getting hot and heavy!  

YES, if I found the right guy that didn't have a problem with
commitment, and our relationship grew  to the point that we would
get married, I would do anything for that person!!! 
I have already done it.  My soon-to-be-ex needed to move
back to Calif. to work for his father so I sold the house that
I owned before I met him and quit my job here at DEC.  I gave
up everything for him and when we got there he was a different
person.  I won't get into the reasons why I am divorcing him.
Luckily I got my job back here and I will never leave again (I
don't think).

Anyway, the gripe that I was making is about the guy that goes
along for months acting like he is in "seventh heaven" along 
with you and then turns to you one day and says, "I don't think
I want to spend the rest of my life with you"  when he had
said the day before, "let's buy a house" and  "This summer I want
to meet your parents" all talk about "future" type stuff.  One
day it is all over!  They say they really didn't feel the way
they said and so on and so on...I would appreciate it a lot more
if the guy would say "I am leaving you for someone else", I think
I could handle that, instead I am left angry from the mixed
up feelings of a person I cared for and still wanting him to be
happy, but he won't let me.
If he didn't decide from the beginning that I wasn't the one
for him then we would have never gotten started and visa versa.
     I've been there before and it doesn't hurt NEAR as bad!

I have just been seeing too much of it lately with friends
of mine and wanted to see everyones view on the problem.

RE .28( I think)   DON'T TAKE IT PERSONALLY!!!!!
                                     

Keep those replys coming!

Carole...
    
296.30honesty, integrity, responsibilityCREDIT::GROFFThu Apr 30 1987 19:4939
    Well, I think it IS A BAD YEAR for a lot of people...
    
    Friends of mine who know Astrology are quick to explain why... :-)
    
    But, when we look at the topic... COMMITMENT...  one could also
    say RESPONSIBILITY.  Both, are frightening words to children and
    youth.  I contend that there is a point within the make-up of an
    individual where he or she determines that they want a relationship
    that involves commitment.  THIS DECISION IS CONSCIOUS.  Sometimes,
    it is made after their "partner" has WAITED A LONG TIME.  This is
    one of the milestones towords maturity (another open question, what
    is maturity?)
    
    Women, seem to come to this decision earlier (maybe they are more
    mature?) than men, IN GENERAL.  (So... all you men who were committed
    (pun intended) at 19 can keep quiet :-)  
                     
    Unfortunately, when we "shop" for mates, we do not always find the ones
    capable of this commitment.  I do not know what the "secret of finding
    a mate capable of commitment", but starting out with honesty and
    demanding honesty from them, is a first.  My EX-fiance' had a problem
    with honesty... she led me to believe that the relationship had
    a future and was on sound ground.  Her dis-honesty caused the greatest
    amount of pain in the loss of this relationship.  Expectations,
    hopes, and dreams came tumbling down with the relationship.  It is
    harder to recover from such a disaster.
    
    What I look for now...
    
    HONESTY
    Integrity
    Responsibility
    
    are necessary before I can "honestly" consider the women as my mate.
    (And, yes, there are some other qualifiers too :-)                
    
    good luck to all,
    
    dana
296.31CSC32::KACHELMYERDavid Lee KakThu Apr 30 1987 21:2724
    Yeah, rather than a problem with commitment itself, this is sounding
    more like a problem with honesty and responsibility in some individuals
    (both male and female).
    
    I, moi-self have experienced something along this line in some
    relationships in the past.  The partner starts behaving a little
    'flakey', so one comes right out and ask if they're no longer
    interested in the relationship.  In these cases, the partner will
    without fail, profess ye olde undying interest.  However, they're still
    acting a bit flakey. So, after couple of cycles of this, one can't help
    but to get the message and move on. 
    
    Also, I knew an aquaintance who did one of the previously-mentioned
    switcheroo numbers to someone.  This person got up to the point of
    'engaged to be married' before admitting to the partner that things
    weren't going to work out, leaving the partner in a state of *extreme*
    suprise. 
    
    I agree with Carole that it's much easier (on oneself) to have someone
    be honest and leave when things are still uncomplicated, rather than to
    have them try to hold out for the emotionally devastating breakup later
    on.

    Kak
296.32manipulationVINO::MCARLETONReality; what a concept!Thu Apr 30 1987 23:2746
    Re: .29
    
    > ... then turns to you one day and says, "I don't think
    > I want to spend the rest of my life with you"  when he had
    > said the day before, "let's buy a house" and  "This summer I want
    > to meet your parents" all talk about "future" type stuff. 

    Sounds like manipulation to me.  Some of these same phrases are
    actually quoted in the book.  He seeks to get you to provide what
    he wants by giving you the impression that he will give you what
    you want.
    
    Try this, let's say that instead of the "let's buy a house" phrases
    you were hearing "If we are still together next month, do you want
    to go on a vacation together?"  What if his indications had been
    that he was thinking of only a temporary thing.  Would you have
    dumped him?  If he thought that you would than he may have decided
    to resort to the "we have a future" manipulation to hide is true
    feelings until he was ready to move on.
    
    Men ,of course, are not the only ones who use manipulation.
    There are many things mentioned in the book that you could have been
    doing to manipulate him too.  How did you respond to his "future"
    talk?  Was if different if he did not say anything about future
    plans in some time?
    
    I am not trying to be judgmental here (Please do not misunderstand).
    I only wish to shed some light on the subject.  I am very slow
    to condemn.
    
    Re: .30
    
    Once again, by saying that a man will not commit because he is not
    mature enough is blaming the man.  Why this insistence that there
    is something wrong with the man?  Why is a man abnormal for wanting
    to stay uncommitted and a woman normal for wanting the commitment
    (or vice-versa).  We could just as easily say that there is something
    wrong with the partner that seems to need to push the other to commit
    
    Is commitment such an important part of a relationship that
    anyone who does not yearn for it is considered abnormal?
    
    
       						MJC O->
    
      
296.33Its in the honor of itKRYPTN::JASNIEWSKIFri May 01 1987 10:0524
    
    	re .32 "abnormal"
    
    	I think the expectation for Commitment from a Woman in her
    relationship is a matter of honor. Just as you honor "God" by
    your commitment to attend (to) the religious service at whatever
    the prescribed interval is. Just as you honor your country by
    your commitment to go fight it's battles.
    
    	Why not "honor" another person by your commitment to being
    with *them* -only- for all time? If viewed in a positive way, this
    could be benificial for both parties.
    
    	Maybe no one "gets off" on honor anymore...its too "long term"
    a thing - doesnt have the immediate "zing" society conditions us
    to want.
    
    	What is "honor" anyway?
    
    		...esteem, respect, glory, distinction, great privelege,
    		   personal integrity, special recognition, validate?
    
    	Joe Jas
    
296.34Friday morning meanderingsDEBIT::RANDALLBonnie Randall SchutzmanFri May 01 1987 10:4047
    BUT COMMITMENT ISN'T A SYNONYM FOR MARRIAGE!!!!!!!!!!! 
    
    I know it's been watered down to that, but taking it that way is the
    source of a lot of misunderstanding and grief between the sexes. 

    There's nothing abnormal about a man who doesn't want to make a
    particular commitment to a particular woman -- or vice versa, either.
    It might not be a problem if one is consciously afraid to make promises
    that one might have to live up to later on. (I'm not saying that this
    applies to anybody in this notes file; I'm discussing this issue in the
    abstact.)  It's certainly a problem when one acts in a way that
    makes the other person think there has been a commitment!
    
    Commitment is the conscious decision that something -- not necessarily
    even a person, and certainly not always a mate -- deserves my
    attention, my effort, my concern, and if necessary my sacrifice.
    Commitment can be partial -- my commitment to a new acquaintance,
    however congenial, would take second place to a commitment to the needs
    of an old friend -- or temporary. It can conflict with other
    commitments. 
    
    For example, I made a commitment to my writing: I will be only the best
    writer I can be, I will tell the story as it must be told, I will not
    take the easy way out simply because exploring the depths of the story
    causes me pain, I will not take shortcuts to achieve success.  This
    is a lifetime commitment, a deep part of who and what I am. I also
    made a commitment to my job at DEC to give it my best effort, to go
    beyond the call of duty if I had to. 
    
    Last year I discovered that I could no longer be true to both those
    commitments. I could have gone on a long time giving my DEC job minimal
    attention and devoting myself to my own writing, but that would have
    violated my personal integrity and my concept of honor, so I left the
    company. (Note that I never promised to work here forever!) Now, while
    I'm on contract, I'm again giving my job the whole effort. 
    
    There are lots of people in this society who are afraid to make any
    commitments that aren't temporary or partial.  Psychologists who write
    books appear to believe, based on their experience, that more men than
    women have trouble making this kind of commitment, though my personal
    opinion is that women and men, for reasons I discussed in an earlier
    note, have equal trouble making commitments; it just shows up in
    different areas. Women tend to be ready to make personal commitments
    while men are more willing to make career-oriented commitments.
    But to be a whole and healthy person, you need both.
    
    --bonnie
296.35why not live for nowPRANCR::SCOTTTFri May 01 1987 13:2615
    What is commitment anyway, if we believe that we all have a time to
    go and leave this earth. why not enjoy the time you have now. people
    put so much time in tring to get a commitment, that they can't see what
    they really have. time will tell, if you do not push the issue,
    then there is a good chance that the right thing will happen. i
    know you would not want someone to commit, if there whole heart
    is not into it. In the long run you will hurt much more. we can
    not tell people how to feel to suit us, sometimes we are just not
    the right person and as hard as it is for us to accept, it all comes
    from that weird thing called "LOVE". on the issue of changing the
    things we like to do, or our life for a relationship. everything
    we change, is that much less of the person we fell in love with
    in the first place. why change who you wanted to spend your life
    with anyway. just my personal feeling, thank you for your time.
                                  terry
296.37CEODEV::FAULKNEResqSat May 09 1987 17:155
    too many of the rapid fire two month meeting 
    now we get married
    relationships that I see happening 
    go up in smoke in less tha the two months 
    prior to the initial meet
296.39long winded opinion from the inside looking outWATNEY::PITTFri May 15 1987 19:4146
    I hate to hear people actually guaging ones maturity by ones
    willingness to make a committment. Lets first look at "committment"
    as most people looking for one define it.
    
    committment: I want you to be with me and me alone and love me and
    me alone for the rest of your life on earth even if
    that's another 75 years.  I want you to from this moment on never
    'sleep' with another person for that 75 years. (I'll keep it clean)
    etc.(I think you get my point)   
    
    When you think about a committment like marriage (if that is the
    big C we're talking about here), you better think about the next
    75 years, or you may as well look elsewhere.                             
                             
    If you REALLY HONESTLY think about the depth of what you're asking
    from that person, maybe you can understand why they may
    reconsider when  the word committment (IE marriage) comes up. 
    
    
    Maybe we should look at the person who runs away from that committment
    and realize that it is a pretty mature decision to say "no" and leave
    a comfortable relationship when they ARE 'lonely' and will continue
    to be lonely, because they have realized that they cannot, in all
    HONESTY to themselves and to you, say "I want to love only you for
    the next 75 years"
                                     
    I can say this as one who has said 'goodbye' a few times when things
    got a little more intense then I was prepared to live with. I could
    have just as easily said 'lets not make comittments yet but go on
    seeing each other'....neither of us would have been happy in the
    end.  
    
    I agree stongly with .35....well said. 
    
    Long winded...I know. This is only opinion, Carole. Not based on
    any person or persons either living or dead.....actually, maybe
    this is based on my pre-committment days and my current committed
    days. 
    Just one more opinion, then I'll shut up.   Sometimes its easier
    to say "I'm not ready for a committment" then it is to say "I really
    do like you and its been fun but I don't LOVE you enough to be there
    when we're both 92".
    
    just opinion.
    
    
296.40it's been fun; I'd like this to last at least a year or two...YODA::BARANSKI1&#039;s &amp; 0&#039;s, what could be simpler?!Sun May 17 1987 18:0312
RE: -.1

Actually, my interpretation of .0 was not so much commitment as in marriage, but
more like commitment as in 'well we've been keeping each other busy for the past
couple of months, and I've really enjoyed it, and I'd like it to last a year or
two...'.

There seem to be plenty of people running from that type of commitment too, too
busy looking for "the right one" to bother dealing with real people and keeping
people as friends... 

Jim.
296.41maybe I'm missing the pointWATNEY::PITTMon May 25 1987 13:1029
    I guess the big question I have is:  If you're not talking about
    marriage, then why the need for a commitment??
    
    Why make a concious promise to another person to be only with that
    person for x period of time if you're not getting married?? That's
    what married is for.......
    
    ok...I should get jumped on for that one.....but I guess I just
    don't understand.  When you're 'dating' someone, what is the need
    or reason for commitment besides the fact that you're afraid of losing
    that person to someone else??  If the reason for that commitment
    is to keep the person from getting lose, then I don't see the logic.
    
    In my opinion, if someone wants to be with someone else, the he
    will....flat out. If one of the two people in this 'couple' wants
    to be able to see other people, then, who are you to blame them
    for their lack of commitment?  When two people are ready for the
    same commitment at the same time, it usually ends up with 4 kids
    and a white picket fence. If not, then one or the other of them
    gets accused of being immature, irresponsible etc.  
    Sure it hurts when you find out the person you want to be with 
    doesn't necessarily want to be with you. But is it their FAULT?????
    
    I guess what I'm trying to say is: I am not going to make a commitment
    to be with 'you' just so that I won't hurt 'your' feelings. If I want
    to be with 'you' then I will, commitment or not......unless of course
    we're married, then we're playing by a whole differant set of rules.
    
     
296.43I'll commit to having a good time!ORION::HERBERTWalk in the sunshineTue May 26 1987 14:2645
Re: .41

There's a different way of viewing commitments...that may be the
reason some people find value in them.  

We make commitments all the time to lots of people.  We commit to
jobs, relationships, ourselves, etc.  One way of looking at a
commitment is that it is an agreement of mutual understanding
about the guidelines for a relationship between two people.  For 
instance, two people might want it understood and agreed upon that 
their relationship is to be sexually closed.  If they both agree, 
they are making that personal commitment to themselves and each 
other.  Some form of agreement and understanding is necessary or 
the relationship could be very undefined and confusing.  

This could be considered making a commitment.  I don't think 
marriage is necessary for that...and I don't think that's what 
marriage is "for".  Commitment is not a word to be feared.  Just 
like anything else...to understand it is to be able to find some 
benefit from it.

I think some people are afraid of making commitments because they 
feel it traps them somehow.  Since they're not sure what they want 
to do, and may fear that they're making a decision now that they'll 
regret later, they run away from commitments as if the commitment 
itself is the problem.  But the commitment is just a temporary tool 
for setting up something the way we want it.  Things are always 
changing, and just because a commitment gets broken doesn't mean the 
commitment is bad...it just means it's through serving it's purpose 
and now it's time to change.  Some commitments are not wise choices, 
but many times it's our insecurity and fear that causes the problems.

Unless it is an obviously bad commitment to make, fear of commitment
can come from a fear of failing or being unable to change later.  Since
you will definitely fail and change again *sometime*...why let that 
stop you from the fun interaction of making valuable agreements and 
plans with people and yourself now?  Nothing is that serious.  

Commitments can be very valuable in setting up comfortable conditions 
and for defining a direction you want to follow.  Nothing is ever 
permanent or unchangeable...not even commitments.  But they can be 
beneficial to everyone if you use wisdom in making them and applying 
them to your situations.

Jerri
296.44commitmentYODA::BARANSKIMAIL hates my NOTES nameTue May 26 1987 15:3115
RE: .41

"Why make a concious promise to another person to be only with that person for x
period of time if you're not getting married?? That's what married is for......"

That's not what marriage is for.  Marriage is not "for X period of time".

I believe that what the original question was more like 'Why do people get
scared when you say "Hey, I enjoy being with you, and I'd like it to last
for a while."'
    
I think that that is a reasonable thing to say at some point, and I think that
there *are* people who have a problem hearing such, and take off.

Jim. 
296.45maturityNOVA::GROFFWed May 27 1987 14:0712
    
    MATURITY -
    
    a mature person will commit to XXXX, 
    a mature person will be able to say the he/she cannot commit to
    XXXX,
    an IMMATURE person wil WANT to commit to XXXX but is AFRAID of the
    consequences.
    
    an IMMATURE person does not want the RESPONSIBILITY of commitment.
    
    - dana
296.46I agree: It all comes down to maturityRSTS32::COFFLERJeff CofflerThu May 28 1987 10:3914
    re: .43
    
    Very well said, Jerri.  I agree wholeheartedly.
    
    re: .45
    
    I've never seen the issue stated that clearly before.  I agree with
    this; however, I think that you need to understand yourself very well
    to really understand who you are, what you are, and what you want.  I
    know many people that don't understand themselves to this degree, and
    so they have problems making commitments; that's is a sign of
    immaturity in and of itself, though.
    
    	-- Jeff
296.47semantics, anyoneAMULET::FARRINGTONstatistically anomalousThu Jun 04 1987 13:427
    re .45  A _more_ mature person may see further "down the road",
    realize that a long term commitment is undesireable or untenable.
    
    There are many reasons for refusing to commit, even though there
    may be the desire to -
    
    Dwight
296.48GROUNDED IN HIS WORDACE::MOORETue Jun 20 1989 12:0997
                       OUR WORD IS OUR BOND
    
    God never gives authority without accountability. But who holds us
    accountable when we give our word and don't keep it. Many among us
    have grown up with parents who don't keep their word. Who holds them
    accountable? Or our boss, friends, neighbors? Who holds us accountable
    for failure to keep our word?
    
    As men, we must be mature enough to become accountable for our word, we
    must see that we keep it when we give it.
    
    One of the reasons many Christians live unfulfilled lives is because
    they have given God their word, and not kept it. Then they blame God
    for not answering their prayers or supplying their needs when in fact
    it is due to their own failure to keep their word.
    
    Many men pile load upon load of guilt upon themselves by not keeping
    their word, then wonder why they have problems.
    
    A man's name is only good as his word.
    
    His word is only good as his character.
    
    True of God - true of men. 
    
    A man's word is the expression of his nature. You can tell a man's 
    character by his words. Our word, when given, is a source of faith
    to those who receive it, and determines their conduct. When a man tells
    a woman he will take her out for dinner, she acts upon that word and is
    ready when the time comes. When the word is not kept, unbelief
    develops.
    
    Being a man of honor is being a man of your word. Truth is the essence
    of the word. Many men today have litte respect for truth. Authors mix
    fact and fiction with no apology and called it faction or literary
    license. Film-makers do the same and call it art. Ministers do it
    and call it evangelistically speaking. Its a lie by any name.
    
    A father who keeps his word can combat the influence of the world 
    on his children and turn to his son and explain the difference
    between the truth and a lie.
    
    Fathers who punish their children for not keeping their word when they
    are guilty of the same only teach their children not to get caught.
    
    Many times bosses are hesitant to hire people of integrity because they
    are afraid they might expose the unethical behavior and fradulent
    practices prevalent in the workplace.
    
    The only place men who love truth are popular in heaven or among other
    men of goodwill. The contest between a truth and a lie is constant.
    To be able to walk in truth, every man needs to be grounded in the
    Word of Truth, and submitted to the Spirit of Truth which bears
    witness with his own spirit.
    
    No lie can serve the purposes of God. Knowing the truth and not living
    it is a lie in itself. Knowing you gave your word and did not keep it
    is living a lie. Knowing you gave your word but need to rescind it, or
    repent of it, and not doing it is living a lie.
    
    When you have spoken a hasty word, the best thing to do is to ask
    forgiveness and try to get out of that negative situation.
    Small children do not know the difference between a broken promise and
    a lie.
    
    God says we are going to give an account of every idle word. Some men
    need to think back, find what idle words they have spoken, what vows
    they have made to God and broken, what promises to their families they
    have not kept and repent of it so they can be rid of the results of
    walking after the flesh and not after the Spirit.
    
    Peace is the umpire for doing the will of God. Many's the man who
    missed
    God's way because he based his decision on outward circumstances rather
    than an inward witness. If you endorsed a note for someone you hardly
    know, guaranteeing his debt, you are in serious trouble. You have
    trapped yourself by your agreement. Quick! Get out of it! Swallow your
    pride, dont let embarrassment stand in the way. Go and beg to have your
    name erased. Dont put it off. Do it now. Pride is the strength of sin.
    Pride wont let us humble ourselves to admit wrong or even suffer being
    wronged. Death and life are in the power in the tongue.
    
    Satan not only wants to rip off Gods Word from men's lives, he also
    wants to steal their word. If the devil can cause a man to fail to keep
    his word, he can keep that man from total manhood.
    
    No matter what others do, keep your heart and mind clear and clean by
    washing them constantly with the water of the Word of God. Then your
    words will follow with truth and integrity.
    
    Great works are built on great words. Let your words be great in God.
    Let God be great in your words. Be a man of the word, and a man of your
    word.
    
    
                        Ray
    
296.49it's not a bad word...it's not realistic...SALEM::SAWYERbut....why?Wed Jul 05 1989 15:0994
re: Note 296.0               Is COMMITMENT such a bad word?         
    
    
:Is everyone afraid of COMMITMENT? 
    beyond what our parents and society have brainwashed us into
    believing....why is it so important that people make so many
    commitments?
    especially when, in reality, nobody knows how long they will love
    another person...?
    is it really reasonable to expect a person to commit "forever" when
    neither party kows how they will feel in 2 or 3 years?
    
    i'd rather hear people commit...."to stay until i want to leave"....
    
:  Saying stupid things like "Oh, I just felt that I needed
:someone to be with for a while"
    what's so stupid about that?

:         or after 2 months "I don't feel
:like your the one I want to live the rest of my life with". 
we might all be better off if we stopped looking for mythical mr/ms
    right and just started accepting from people what they can honestly
    give....
    perhaps that guy would have stayed longer if he wasn't frightened
    by fear of "committing forever"
    
    
    :Who gave them an alloted time frame to decide if the person is
:right for them or not?
i do.  i give everyone the right to take as much time as they need or
    want.  i give them the right to change their mind. i give them the
    right to not make commitments......
    i also give them the right to not worry about "committments forever"
    
    
:I seem to run across men that have been severely scared by
:the mean and terrible things that women can do, I am amazed
:what some of these guys have been through.
    and some men just don't believe that making commitments forever
    is a sensible thing to do....
    i carry no scars from any relationship....and i hope i left none...
  but when a woman starts talking "commitment forever", if i can't get
    her to understand a more reasonable point of view, i back off....
      
 
:And the worst part of it is that the guy will walk around moping
:saying things like" I am so lonely, I want to get married",
i don't want to get married!...i don't care if statistics do me in
    earlier than married men....i like being single and intend to
    remain this way....
    and i aint lonely!.....and guess what....i'm not even a good looking
    macho kind of guy that can get lots of women!....


:He said he wanted to break up,  that he wasn't ready for such a 
:commitment after he had been telling her all along that she was 
:the best thing that ever happened to him.  Does that make sense?
to me it does.  i think one of the reasons that so many people have
    trouble making these "forever commitments" is the fact that
    making "forever commitments" makes no sense...cus nobody knows
    how long they will love another person....
    
:I am wondering if people all over are experienceing the same
:thing, or if their friends are?  Or is it just a bad year
:for me?
i would suggest that your problem is.....you've been brainwashed
    into believing that you can only find true happiness in a
    "forever commitment"...and...since you still believe this...
    and you still want this....you have trouble...
    try NOT believing it for awhile and see what happens...
    maybe you'll realize that "forever commitments" are not
    the only way to travel in life....

:Can anyone convince me that all us singles aren't doomed, and
:that this problem isn't going to manifest itself because of
:people continuely going through bad relationships?
doomed?...
    well, if i'm doomed to the lifestyle that i want then bring
    on doomsday!
    i'm ready for it!!
    
:I am to the point where I am seriously considering becoming
:a NUN!
don't do that!...become a realist!....realize that
    	a. it's not important how long love lasts
    	b. you can have many different loving relationships in life
    	c. you don't need "commitment forever" to be happy
    
:Carole (SWISOMWAGMAOCOHOTMU)
good luck
    rik
Translated to: Single Women In Search Of Men Who Aren' Gay, Married,
	       AFRAID OF COMMITMENT, Or Hung-up On Their Mothers, United
    
296.50Gort rambles on about commitment.........CSC32::GORTMAKERwhatsa Gort?Thu Jul 06 1989 06:4326
    Not long back I ended a relationship with a woman I had been involved
    with for over 9 months. The main reason was any form of commitment
    be it to go skiing new years weekend a month in advance or for a date
    friday night scared her to death. To ask her to even say maybe would 
    actually make her mad mind you all I wanted was to be able to make
    plans one way or the other. (Am I off base asking someone to make a
    decision so that I am not left hanging? )
    Even when there was a commitment to do something our plans would often
    change(no doubt a better deal came along) or she would be late. Example:
    For valentines day I had a dinner planned that was to be prepared by
    the chef of the wealthiest family in town the menu was to be 1st class.
    I had already paid $250.00 in advance for the dinner ingredients,
    wine,flowers ect a few hours before we were to meet she backed out
    because of "work". She later found out that dinner was prepaid and
    went non-linear because now it was all her fault that "my" dinner plans
    dident pan out because of her. She then said all that "was too
    expensive, probably not worth it for the money(I know better as this
    chef put down a plate that looks too good to take the first bite almost
    art).
    
    I know this rambles but just typing it in makes me feel better as I
    still am angry a month later I think because I was being used and I
    knew it all along. 
    
    -j(still willing to commit and tired of those too afraid to try)
    
296.51re .-1SHIRE::DICKERKeith Dicker, @Geneva, SwitzerlandThu Jul 06 1989 08:2210
    re .-1:
    	That's RIDICULOUS!  I can understand being afraid of commitment
    to stay with someone for the rest of your life, but to refuse to
    commit to a dinner???  What you asked was not (in my humble opinion)
    AT ALL unreasonable.   Is sounded like she was unwilling to "give"
    in the relationship in any way that might restrict her own wishes
    in the slightest way.  Maybe some people like to live that way --
    but it sounds like you're not one of them.
    
    Keith
296.52SSDEVO::GALLUPthis is hot meat metallic bloodThu Jul 13 1989 12:2724

	 RE: .50 et al

	 Sometimes people don't like making commitments in advance
	 with a person because they are really not interested in that
	 person, yet don't wish to lose that person's friendship, nor
	 hurt them.  I was in a similar situation a little while back
	 where I wasn't interested romantically with the guy at all,
	 yet I enjoyed his frienship.  It made it really hard to
	 commit to anything with him, when I knew that he wanted it to
	 be a romantic date, and I did not.

	 All I can say is....if you start getting treated like this by
	 someone....take a minute and try to understand WHY they are
	 acting this way.....perhaps they aren't interested
	 romantically.

	 Commitment to ANYTHING is very hard when you have that kind
	 pressure on you.
	 


	 /kath