[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference bookie::movies

Title:Movie Reviews and Discussion
Notice:Please do DIR/TITLE before starting a new topic on a movie!
Moderator:VAXCPU::michaudo.dec.com::tamara::eppes
Created:Thu Jan 28 1993
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1249
Total number of notes:16012

1201.0. "Evita" by PCBUOA::CHENARD () Mon Jan 13 1997 14:01

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1201.1good movieSTOWOA::JACOBSON_AMon Jan 13 1997 14:5714
1201.2RIOT01::SUMMERFIELDSic Transit Gloria MundiTue Jan 14 1997 04:4112
1201.3Madonna is EvitaAYOV22::KKEARYTue Jan 14 1997 08:0224
1201.4BRAT::JENNISONAngels Guide Me From The CloudsTue Jan 14 1997 13:241
1201.5CLUSTA::MAIEWSKIBraves, 1914 1957 1995 WS ChampsMon Jan 20 1997 11:0734
1201.6OBSESS::BEAUPREMon Jan 20 1997 12:403
1201.7CLUSTA::MAIEWSKIBraves, 1914 1957 1995 WS ChampsMon Jan 20 1997 14:327
1201.8Background, please? - Thank youWMOIS::LYONS_STue Jan 21 1997 13:3210
1201.9A brief bioDYPSS1::s_coghill.dyo.dec.com::CoghillSSteve Coghill, NSIS Solution ArchitectTue Jan 21 1997 13:4572
1201.10CLUSTA::MAIEWSKIBraves, 1914 1957 1995 WS ChampsTue Jan 21 1997 16:0431
1201.11WRKSYS::LASKYWed Jan 22 1997 08:2011
1201.12Good informationWMOIS::LYONS_SWed Jan 22 1997 13:297
1201.13highly recommended!chayna.zko.dec.com::xanadu::eppesNina EppesWed Jan 22 1997 17:5810
1201.14Two sides of a coin!AYOV22::KKEARYThu Jan 23 1997 08:1019
1201.15MOVIES::POTTERhttp://www.vmse.edo.dec.com/~potter/Fri Feb 14 1997 18:3124
I was apalled when I heard that Madonna was getting the lead part in this
movie.  I love the work of Rice/Webber, I love the theatre.  Giving the part
to a pop star like Madonna whom I thought to be incapable of decent singing
astonished me - it was to me an obvious case of Madonna getting the part
because she was a big name, rather than talent.

So, I was very surprised and pleased when I a colleague lent me a CD of the
soundtrack.  It was very good, and Madonna was even pretty good.  So tonight
we went to see the film.

I was sorely disappointed.  Madonna's arm gestures were really irritating, and
she didn't really come over as being able to dance at all.  She was meant to
be fifteen at the start of the film (from memory); she never looked a day
under thirty.

I know that the production crew only got one shot at the Casa Rosada scenes,
but why did they let the crowd wave the same banners for "Don't Cry For Me..."
and "I want to tell the people", two scenes separated by...a decade?  more?

Sorry, I didn't expect Madonna to be able to sing, I did expect her to be able
to move.  She sang well, but her moving seemed really wooden.

regards,
//alan
1201.16Not enough.PEAKS::IANNICELLIMon Feb 17 1997 11:338
    I saw this movie last weekend and was disappointed.  A friend of mine
    told me that is was very true to the play, but when it was done I
    couldn't figure out if I liked it.  Modona was fair in her role, but I 
    don't think that the play in a movie form worked.  I'm not going to say
    what happens at the end but I found myself not careing!
    
    Oh well... ** out of *****
    
1201.17took signing lessonsGRANPA::JBOBBJanet Bobb dtn:339-5755Tue Feb 18 1997 14:1414
    Saw a TV interview with Madonna (can't remember what show) where she
    talked about going to a voice/singing coach in order to prepare for
    this movie. she herself made the comment that she'd never had any voice
    training before this - but needed it for this role.
    
    haven't seen the movie yet, but have heard the soundtrack. Like the
    musuc (but have liked it since it was first released as a play).
    there's also another cd out with "alternate" soundtracks. As far as I
    could tell, the entire CD is 6 or so renditions of "don't cry for me"
    all with different beats, some wording changed, etc. the one they were
    playing in the music stay sounded to me like a disco version - pretty
    bad - imho!
    
    janetb.
1201.18CLUSTA::MAIEWSKIBraves, 1914 1957 1995 WS ChampsTue Feb 18 1997 14:5714
  Joyce Kilhawick of WBZ TV panned the movie mostly because she didn't like
Madonna's performance from a Broadway show biz point of view. I'm sure lots of
people who are Broadway musical fans 1st and drama fans or history buffs 2nd
will feel this way since they tend to prefer the spectacular type of singer
with more stage presence and big voice. 

  In the movie I think it works better this way since Evita herself was not a
spectacular singer or actor, more a borderline actor who relied on timing and
wits to win over a crowd rather than show biz charisma.

  Madonna may not have duplicated the Broadway performance but she did do a
1st rate job of portraying the character of Evita Peron.

  George