[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference bookie::movies

Title:Movie Reviews and Discussion
Notice:Please do DIR/TITLE before starting a new topic on a movie!
Moderator:VAXCPU::michaudo.dec.com::tamara::eppes
Created:Thu Jan 28 1993
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1249
Total number of notes:16012

990.0. "Cutthroat Island" by RNDHSE::WALL (Show me, don't tell me) Wed Dec 27 1995 09:06

    I thought surely there was a note in here for this film, but maybe it
    was a thread in another topic.  Neither a dir/title nor a search
    revealed anything relevant.  In any event:
    
    Capsule Review:  Fun, but surprisingly subdued, largely due to Geena
    Davis's performance.  Matthew Modine looked like he was having a better
    time and he spent most of the movie getting beat up.
    
    You don't go to a pirate movie expecting high art, and most of the
    people who worked on this movie appeared to have a very good grasp on
    what the genre was like and what people coming to this movie were
    likely to expect, and they delivered in large measure.  Aside from one
    completely-over-the-top moment during a chase scene in Port Royal,
    there was lots of good swash being buckled.  The dialogue could have
    used a little more periodness, but that's a highly subjective matter.
    Frank Langella made a terrific villian and Matthew Modine a good
    sidekick.  The pirate crews were good, the stodgy British officers were
    good.  Everyone appeared to be in it for all they were worth.
    
    The notable exception to this was Geena Davis.  Why she chose to think
    she was making a movie in the temperment of The Accidental Tourist
    rather than Earth Girls Are Easy is beyond me.  This was all the more
    mystifying because she had all these *great* moves.  She had the
    physical aspects of the part down perfectly, but her voice and facial
    expressions just didn't seem to fit.  She looked bedeviled rather than
    devil-may-care. I'm surprised Renny Harlin let all this drift,
    considering what he managed to get out of Janine Turner in Cliffhanger,
    but maybe being married to her had something to do with it.  I kept
    expecting the evil British governor to tell her she'd hang by the neck
    until she cheered up.
    
    My other minor quibble was with the opening sequence, where I had a
    little trouble understanding the dialogue because the music was
    stepping all over it.
    
    I'd probably see this again, but only because I'm a big fan of this
    sort of movie.  People who are just looking for an action picture might
    want to wait for a matinee.  But see it, if only to encourage Hollywood
    to do it again and do it better still.
    
    DFW
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
990.1Saw it, liked itBEMUS::KELLEYThu Jan 04 1996 11:0310
Saw this movie last week and liked it.
It's getting trashed by critics though.
And it's not doing well at the box office.

I think they're being unfair.

One of the loudest movies I ever saw.
The soundtrack was overpowering at times.

JK
990.2Geena Davis wasn't having a good time in most of the movieTNPUBS::NAZZAROSyracuse fan for a weekThu Jan 04 1996 13:2115
    I must disagree with the base noter regarding Geena Davis' performance
    in this movie.  Through most of the film, there wasn't much for her to
    be happy about, starting with the fate of her father.  I wasn't
    expecting a devil-may-care swashbuckler, and I don't think that is what
    the director intended.  I think Rennie Harlan set out to make exactly
    what he did - an adventure.  And for what he was aiming for, I think he
    did a very good (not great) job.
    
    Except for the location of the tresure, I really enjoyed this movie,
    and tyhough Geena Davis was wonderful.  I dislike snob reviewers like
    Gene Siskel who didn't like the film because it didn't break any new
    ground.  I would like critics to judge films on their own merits.  This
    movie stands up well on its own.
    
    NAZZ
990.3Find a theater with a *clear* sound systemRNDHSE::WALLShow me, don't tell meFri Jan 05 1996 08:4210
    
    Well, I liked it enough to see it again.  A better sound system (or
    possibly a better quality of print) significantly improved the movie's
    opening moments for me, when it can be hard to pick the dialogue out of
    the music.
    
    I still think Geena Davis wasn't quite up to being the heroine of an
    adventure like this, but as I say, I liked it enough to see it twice.
    
    DFW
990.4definity would see againFABSIX::T_SULLIVANMOMENTARY LAPSE OF REASONSat Jan 06 1996 12:089
	Saw the movie over Christmas and plan on seeing it again with my daughter(the kids wanted to see Jurmanji
	again!).  I thought the special effects were outstanding and yes the music in the beginning was a little
	overpowering.  It was nice to see a strong womans role for an action adventure movie.  I kinda get tired
	of the damsil in distress that predonminates alot of action movies. Geena Davis held her own wonderfully
	in this picture.  Matthew Modine did a good job also.

	It was fun. It was on the edge of your seat type excitment.

	T 
990.5Reformatted to fit your screenBUSY::SLABOUNTYIt's inevitableMon Jan 08 1996 11:1017
    
      <<< Note 990.4 by FABSIX::T_SULLIVAN "MOMENTARY LAPSE OF REASON" >>>
                         -< definity would see again >-

	Saw the movie over Christmas and plan on seeing it again with my
    	daughter(the kids wanted to see Jurmanji again!).  I thought the
    	special effects were outstanding and yes the music in the beginning
    	was a little overpowering.  It was nice to see a strong womans role
    	for an action adventure movie.  I kinda get tired of the damsil in
    	distress that predonminates alot of action movies. Geena Davis held
    	her own wonderfully in this picture.  Matthew Modine did a good job
    	also.

	It was fun. It was on the edge of your seat type excitment.

	T 
    
990.6KERNEL::PLANTCBeam me up Scotty!Mon Apr 01 1996 09:0614
    
    Saw this with my partner over the weekend and we both liked it!
    Very action-packed and a strong leading role for women performed by
    Geena Davis ( I thought she did a good job ).
    
    Over-all very good!
    
    why the heck did her dad tatoo the map on his head?
    
    Must have been incredibly painful and definitely sets him up to
    be chopped!
    
    Chris
    :)