[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference bookie::movies

Title:Movie Reviews and Discussion
Notice:Please do DIR/TITLE before starting a new topic on a movie!
Moderator:VAXCPU::michaudo.dec.com::tamara::eppes
Created:Thu Jan 28 1993
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1249
Total number of notes:16012

758.0. "Nobody's Fool" by TROOA::TRP109::Chris (if not now, when?) Wed Feb 01 1995 10:27

	This was a thoroughly enjoyable movie, well written and directed
	by Robert Benton and starring Paul Newman, Jessica Tandy, Bruce
	Willis and Melanie Griffith. Paul plays a crusty, crippled (both
	physically and emotionally) part time construction worker who is
	a tenant of Jessica Tandy's character (his 8th grade teacher). The
	story is set in a small town in New York. Bruce owns the 
	construction company and spends his days chasing his secretaries,
	gambling, boozing it up and avoiding his wife (Melanie G). (Still
	manages to be likeable to me, but that's probably because I enjoy
	Bruce's smart-alecky wise guy character in all his movies). I am
	still (and have always been) a great admirer of Newman's. His 
	artistry makes his acting efforts look so effortless, so natural, 
	so believable - he has retained all his sensuality and the
	scenes with both Tandy and Griffith show off his flirting ability.
	I usually can't stand Melanie Griffith, but she shares great
	chemistry with Newman in this movie.  The story shows Newman's
	every day interactions with a lot of the other town's characters, 
	but also with his estranged son and grandson who have to come to
	the town to see Paul's ex-wife for Thanksgiving. The son is played
	by Dylan Walsh - can anybody tell me where I have seen him?  The 
	movie concerns itself with how Newman's character measures the
	real effect he has on his family and odd assortment of friends.
	It is wonderful and I could have sat in the theatre for another
	3 hours watching his interactions with the rest of the actors.
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
758.1Very Good FlickWRKSYS::LASKYWed Feb 01 1995 16:288
    Chris,
    
    I couldn't have agreed with you more.  This is one excellent film, if 
    your looking for blood and guts stay far away from this one but if your
    looking for a slice of life, with people who you can relate to then 
    check this one out.
    
    				Bart
758.2RussoMAL009::RAGUCCIWed Feb 01 1995 20:4010
    
    
    R. Russo the writer, is from Mass.  And teaches at a local college.
    
    
    
    
    I heard it was a good movie.......
    
    
758.3Paul inspires greatnessFXODEV::PONCELoRyderThu Feb 02 1995 11:176
    It's a great movie experience.....everyone rallies around Newmans
    acting....I believe he brings out the best in the total cast.
    
    A total pleasure.....
    
     Jp
758.4Sounds excellent!GMASEC::CLARKThu Feb 02 1995 20:5918
    Wow! Three "excellent" reviews in a row. The reviews here have
    certainly peaked my interest and hope to view it soon. I cannot recall
    ever seeing Newman do other than an outstanding job. Newman story
    alert!  One of my friends worked for a tree trimming outfit and they
    got a job at Newman's home in Ct. While limbing out the tree, one large
    branch landed on a little tree (which Newman's wife had just recently
    planted). Buried that sucker. So, my friend got "elected" to go to the
    door and let the Newmans know about it. Paul Newman came out, took a 
    look, and said, "YOU guys are telling my wife. Not me." So, in they 
    went, explained the whole story, and then Newman said, "Sit down and
    have some lunch  with me". My friend said the rest of the afternoon was
    sitting in Newman's living room while his wife, Joanne Woodward, kept 
    supplying them with more sandwiches and beers. The one comment my 
    friend made was about how down-to-earth Newman is and thought he was
    just a great guy to talk with, etc. Definitely hasn't let Hollywood go
    to his head. Everytime I see Paul Newman all I can think is , "hey,
    it's Cool Hand Luke!" My all time favorite Newman film. "I'm a-shaking,
    boss! I'm a-shaking!" 
758.5Very disappointing movieTNPUBS::NAZZAROUMass to the Final Four!Mon Feb 13 1995 13:3629
    See this movie as a tribute to Jessica Tandy, perhaps, or to see
    another bravura performance by Paul Newman, but as a film, this is a
    lightweight bit of nothing.  I was extremely disappointed.
    
    Bruce Willis overacts, as usual.  His character's actions make no
    sense.  For that matter, nmost of what Newman does in the movie doesn't
    make any sense either.  Jessica Tandy is sweet and kind and does a nice
    job being herself.  
    
    A few more pointed comments after the ff
    
    
    1) Do we know why Willis ignores his wife?  Does that make any sense?
    
    2) A bit too coincidental for me to have the lottery ticket come in.
    
    3) Leaving the kid outside for two minutes was not a big deal. 
    Comparing it to abandoning his son at age one was a bit much.
    
    4) Why didn't he drive up to "Rub" instead of following him on the
    sidewalk?  Was that the only way the writer could think of to get
    Newman thrown in jail?
    
    5) Was his life so great in Bath that Newman wouldn't have gone to
    Hawaii?
    
    4.5 out of ten - 2 for Newman, 2 for Tandy, .5 for gratuitousness
    
    NAZZ
758.6I give it ***/*****EVMS::HALLYBFish have no concept of fireSun Feb 19 1995 13:1920
    Whence came the title? I see this movie as sort of Newman's version of
    "The Unforgiven": stars showing their age to an audience of boomers
    who themselves are starting to feel pains of age.
    
    Spoilers follow:
    

>   5) Was his life so great in Bath that Newman wouldn't have gone to
>   Hawaii?
    
    This is even more unbelievable than the trifecta coming in. I would
    have enjoyed a twist at the end of the movie: scene shifts to Hawaii,
    Melanie Griffith holding a baby in her arms on a porch in a ramshackle
    house somewhere in the low rent district, Newman driving up in an old
    red Ford pickup rusted from all the rain...just like Bath...
    
    6) And who was surprised to hear the amusement park pulled out of the
    deal? That was telegraphed right from the start.
    
      John
758.7A fine Newman vehicleEVMS::MARIONThose thunderdrums are callingMon Feb 20 1995 11:4018
    I loved this movie.  Not for the action oriented, the only action is
    in the mind and heart of Sully, an aging man who's eschewed
    responsibility all his life.  Late in years, he finally comes to know
    his son and grandson, and to feel some responsibility and care for
    them.
    
    I felt that Newman played his part to perfection.  It could easily
    have turned maudlin or absurd, yet he played his part with a quiet
    dignity that kept me interested in his growth.  
    
    I love the strange, friendly rivalry with Bruce Willis' character, 
    and I love the Doberman.  And Jessica Tandy was fine in her last
    performance.  In fact, the only moment that choked me up was in the
    final credits where they dedicated the film to her.
    
    I give it ****.5 out of *****.
    
    Karen.