[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference nyoss1::market_investing

Title:Market Investing
Moderator:2155::michaud
Created:Thu Jan 23 1992
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1060
Total number of notes:10477

1058.0. "Long term "buy & hold" of stocks" by 2155::michaud (Jeff Michaud - ObjectBroker) Fri Mar 07 1997 20:23

	Well there's no real topic on "buy and hold" for long term vs.
	selling when a stock turns bleak or you believe it's reached
	it's peak or just hasn't plain done anything.

	As some of you know, I'm notorious for selling stocks at the
	wrong time.  However from reading some notes from others, I'm
	not the only one who feels the market sees any stock I sell as
	a signal to buy that stock.

	To provide some data, I've compiled a list of every stock that I've
	sold (and no longer own any shares of) to see how much profit I
	either left on the table or how much profit (or in most cases
	for me, how much further loss) I protected.  This is all within
	the last 2 3/4 years when I started investing directly in stocks
	(after I had lost money investing in mutual funds the prior couple
	of years).

	In my case it turns out that if I had continued to hold these
	stocks and sold at today's closing prices, that I would have
	over an additional $113,000 profit!  In reality however it's
	more difficult to determine how much profit I lost out on because
	I would of been unable to have all these stocks (at least with
	the number of shares I owned) in my portfolio at the same time.
	However had I not sold some of these stocks (like US Air [U]),
	I would not have had the money to buy some of the stocks I ended
	up selling at a loss.  The "what if" game is hard to play :-)

	Since I started holding stocks longer, my current portfolio
	is doing MUCH better.  I believe I've learned my lesson.  I
	just hope we don't have a major correction or crash that
	proves this theory wrong.

As of close on Friday, March 6, 1997

Symb LastTrad  SoldAt	Diff	#Shares
   U  22.375	6.625	15.75	4000	$63,000.00
 ATC   5.1875	1.25	3.9375	3000	$11,812.50 see note at end
MSFT  96.75	45.5#	51.25	200#	$10,250.00
 RHI  41.25	24.75	15.50	500	$ 7,750.00
INTC 143.5	71.5	72	100	$ 7,200.00
 AMD  39.5	17.375	22.125	200	$ 4,425.00
BOST  31.25	17.5	13.75	300	$ 4,125.00
 GTY  20.375	11.25	9.125	400	$ 3,650.00
 MAN  39.625	26.5	13.125	250	$ 3,281.25
 UNH  53.75	37.75	16	150	$ 2,400.00
USHC  52.75	39.25	13.50	150	$ 2,025.00
 GTE  46.75	34	12.75	100	$ 1,275.00
  HD  56.625	43.5	13.125	100	$ 1,312.50
TACO   5.25	6	.75	2000	$ 1,500.00
 HUM  22.5	18.25	4.25	250	$ 1,062.50
 WMT  27.375	22.375	5	200	$ 1,000.00
 TOY  28.625	22.125	6.5	150	$   975.00
AKSEF   3.9688	2.875	1.0938	300	$   328.14
 TSO  11.75	10.875	.875	300	$   262.50
DEC1A  25.5	24	1.5	100	$   150.00
HRVY   7.5	6.875	.625	200	$   125.00
==================================================
				       $123,821.89

  DR   2	6.125	-4.125	600	-$2,475.00
CATH   5.875	11	-5.125	400	-$2,050.00
SYBS  14.1875	22.875	-8.6875	200	-$1,737.50
 DJT   9.75	14.375	-4.625	300	-$1,387.50 peaked @ 35.5 after I sold
  KM  12.625	13.75	-1.125	800	-$  900.00
CRUS  13.3125	20.125	-6.8125	125	-$  851.56
WALL  16.5	18.5	-2	250	-$  500.00
 SBP   0.6875	1.125	-.4375	1000	-$  437.50 stock no longer trades
 NSH  12.375	13.75	-1.375	200	-$  275.00
==================================================
				       -$10,614.06

Net: $113,207.83

# = split adjusted

Notes:

ATC (Atari Corp)
    bought out by another co and peaked at 9 3/16 after i sold i
    actually had 5,000 shares total but sold 2,000 shares several
    months before I sold the remaining shares @ 3.5, which would
    have been another $3,375.00

Key to symbols:
    Symbol: U (USAIR GROUP) [NYSE]
    Symbol: RHI (ROBERT HALF INTL INC) [NYSE]
    Symbol: MAN (MANPOWER INC) [NYSE]
    Symbol: CATH (CATHERINES STORES CP)
    Symbol: SYBS (SYBASE INC)
    Symbol: BOST (BOSTON CHICKEN INC)
    Symbol: KM (K MART CP) [NYSE]
    Symbol: GTE (GTE CP) [NYSE]
    Symbol: UNH (UNITED HEALTHCARE CP) [NYSE]
    Symbol: TSO (TESORO PETROLEUM) [NYSE]
    Symbol: DJT (TRUMP HOTELS & CASINO RESORTS) [NYSE]
    Symbol: TOY (TOYS R US HLDG CO) [NYSE]
    Symbol: DEC1A (DIGITAL EQUIPMENT  8 7/8 PR A) [NYSE]
    Symbol: GTY (GETTY PETROLEUM CP) [NYSE]
    Symbol: HD (HOME DEPOT INC) [NYSE]
    Symbol: NSH (NASHUA CP) [NYSE]
    Symbol: ATC (ATARI CP) [AMEX]
    Symbol: MSFT (MICROSOFT CP)
    Symbol: WALL (WALL DATA INC)
    Symbol: HRVY (HARVEY ENTERTAINMENT CO)
    Symbol: AKSEF (ARAKIS ENERGY)
    Symbol: WMT (WAL MART STORES) [NYSE]
    Symbol: CRUS (CIRRUS LOGIC INC)
    Symbol: SBP (STANDARD BRANDS PAINT) [NYSE]
    Symbol: TACO (TACO CABANA INC CL A)
    Symbol: AMD (ADVANCED MICRO DEVICES) [NYSE]
    Symbol: INTC (INTEL CP)
    Symbol: HUM (HUMANA INC) [NYSE]
    Symbol: DR (COASTAL PHYSICIAN GRP INC) [NYSE]
    Symbol: USHC (US HEALTHCARE INC)
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1059.1"hold" is the keyword2155::michaudJeff Michaud - ObjectBrokerWed Mar 12 1997 21:1417
> As of close on Friday, March 6, 1997
> Symb LastTrad  SoldAt	Diff	#Shares
>    U  22.375	6.625	15.75	4000	$63,000.00
>  AMD  39.5	17.375	22.125	200	$ 4,425.00

As of close on Wednesday, March 12, 1997
Symb LastTrad  Change %Chg    Bid      Ask    DayLow   DayHigh  52Wlow   52WHigh
   U  26.5    +1      +3.9   V:  1541500      25.25    26.625   15.125   26.5
 AMD  45.375  +3.625  +8.7   V:   318300      43.625   47.75    10.25    42.25

	which translates to an additional 4.125/share gain (or another
	$16,500.00!) I missed out on US Air[ways] and 5.875/share
	gain (or $1,175.00) on AMD.

	AMD was upgraded from buy to strong buy by some analyst, and U
	was given as the top airline stock to buy by the guest market
	analyst on last Friday's NBR.
1059.2AOSG::HITTI break for ACCVIOsThu Mar 13 1997 10:5423
I believe you're basically right Jeff - in the short time I've traded stocks,
I would have done much better to just 'sit tight' on some of them rather than
sell off. Some notables for me have been AMAT (bought at ~37, dropped to mid
20s, sold when it rebounded to 39, now it's about 51), CPQ (similar story -
sold off at about break-even around 47, now around 79), and others - all just
in the past year.

I've been hurt by watching my portfolio too closely and seeing negative
numbers next to a certain stock for too long. I end up feeling that I'd better
cut my losses, when instead I end up locking them in and missing a potential
gain.

If the health of the company really isn't a question in your mind, you should
probably just hold the stock until it comes back in favor. But if a stock goes
down and the reasons you bought the stock in the first place change, you do
need to evaluate whether or not you'd buy it at the current price (ignoring
the fact you already own it). If not, then you may want to sell. However if
the long term prospects still look good, you may want to hang on.

I've gone to both extremes, however in this market it appears that eventually
every dog has its day.

-Jeremy
1059.3We are in the same boatNCMAIL::YANUSCFri Mar 14 1997 09:3741
    Jeff,
    
    I commend you for putting out there what many have suspected for some
    time now - that you don't know stocks from a hill of beans!
    
    Just kidding.  I commend you for admitting what many find unable to do,
    which is admit that we tend to misstime the market when purchasing
    individual stocks.  It is easy to do - we don't have nearly the time to
    research the markets correctly, we rely upon our human emotions, and so
    forth.  I, too, can admit that I have made many mistakes in this
    regard, Digital stock being the most apparent.  And while I have had
    some notable successes, where I have doubled or tripled my $ in a short
    period of time, I suspect that I would have been further ahead by
    following another path, namely:
    
    1. Invest in a solid portfolio of mutual funds, such as a variety of
    index funds, not just the S&P500.  This group has not always had the
    success it has had recently, so be prepared for its eventual downturn
    by investing in other indices, too.
    
    2. If you want to continue to invest in individual stocks, and are not
    that speculative of an investor, build a portfolio of strong, dividend
    paying (if possible) stocks.  They weather downturns much better than
    non-paying stocks, and generally give excellent returns over time.
    
    One of the problems I think many investors have right now is this push
    to deliver market-beating returns.  While admirable, it causes many of
    us to take undo risks, which is murderous to our net worth over time. 
    For recent market investors, used to seeing 20+% returns from the last
    few years, it is difficult to imagine the historic market average over
    time of 10% or so.  At 10% your money will double in approximately
    seven years.  That is a solid return, but most people are very
    dissatified with that.  But I suspect that the approach I mentioned
    above in #1 and #2 will give at least those rates of returns.  For
    those who try individual stocks, especially the uninitiated, I daresay 
    the returns will be somewhat less.
    
    Enjoy reading your notes, Jeff.
    
    Chuck
                
1059.42155::michaudJeff Michaud - ObjectBrokerWed Mar 26 1997 20:5216
> I commend you for admitting what many find unable to do,
> which is admit that we tend to misstime the market when purchasing
> individual stocks.

	I think you mis-understood, my problem is not mis-timing the
	market when "purchasing" individual stocks, but when "selling"!

> 2. If you want to continue to invest in individual stocks, and are not
> that speculative of an investor, build a portfolio of strong, dividend
> paying (if possible) stocks.  They weather downturns much better than
> non-paying stocks, and generally give excellent returns over time.

	Well there is a downside to dividend paying stocks, at least
	if living here in NH.  We don't have a broad based income tax,
	but we do have a dividends and interest tax (with an exemption
	for the first so much $).  But we have no capital gains tax.
1059.5:-(((((((((((((((((2155::michaudJeff Michaud - ObjectBrokerThu Apr 24 1997 00:5325
>> As of close on Friday, March 6, 1997
>> Symb LastTrad  SoldAt  Diff	#Shares
>>    U  22.375	6.625	15.75	4000	$63,000.00
> As of close on Wednesday, March 12, 1997
> Symb LastTrad  Change %Chg    Bid      Ask    DayLow   DayHigh  52Wlow   52WHigh
>    U  26.5    +1      +3.9   V:  1541500      25.25    26.625   15.125   26.5

	:-((((((((((((  Talk about selling the goose that lays the golden
	eggs :-((((((((((((

	That's *exactly* $110,000 of *additional* gain/profit I missed
	out on by selling 2 years too early :-((((((((((((((((((((((((

Symbol: U (USAIR GROUP) [NYSE]
Last Trade: 34 3/8, Change 5 1/2 (19.05%) at Apr 23  4:01:46
Low & High: 29 1/4 & 34 3/8 (spread 5 1/8)
52 Week Low & High: 15 1/8 & 29 1/8 (spread 14)
Volume/# of Trades: 4167400 / 793 (5255 shares/trade)
P/E: 10.70, EPS: 2.70, Market Cap: 1573.00, Beta: 1.11, EPS Growth: 82.80

	FWIW, the airline released MUCH better than expected earnings today,
	a good profit compared to a loss same Q last year.

	From $4/share on Dec. 30th 1994, to almost $35/share today,
	talk about a growth stock!!!