T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
286.1 | Craps anyone? | PCCAD::DINGELDEIN | PHOENIX | Fri Oct 02 1992 20:07 | 10 |
| I suggest you burn that letter. If you're interested in futures you
better start doing some heavy reading. There's a lot to this game. One
thing inexperienced investors tend to overlook is that futures are a
hedging vehicle to protect capital, not a pure investment vehicle. Only
the most experienced sophisticated professional with years of
experience (and the proper software tools) has a shot in hell of having
a chance at being consistently profitable. You can get lucky though,
but you better be willing and ready to loss a lot of money.
I'm no expert , just my semi-informed opinion.
Dan D
|
286.2 | | VMSDEV::HAMMOND | Charlie Hammond -- ZKO3-04/S23 -- dtn 381-2684 | Mon Oct 05 1992 10:42 | 12 |
| RE: .1
Dan -- My own "semi-informed opinion" is right in line with yours.
I've read that the average futures account last less than 6
months. I assume this isn't because the investors make all the
money they want in that amount of time.
I was/am considering Ken Roberts / British American as an
educational experience first and only then as a possible
investment direction.
Does anyone know anything specifid about this operation?
|
286.3 | This is not a lot of money compared to potential value | VMSDEV::HALLYB | Fish have no concept of fire. | Mon Oct 05 1992 14:01 | 18 |
| At one time Howard Ruff was telling his readers that Ken Roberts was on
the up-and-up. Apparently Ken teaches the basics of futures and some
sort of chart-based technical analysis. I believe at one time he
offered a money-back guarantee, if you traded his system for 6 months
and still lost money. (Proof was required).
The reason so many futures traders go broke is lack of discipline and
consequently failure to take losses, or follow system signals. Even then
you can run into a bad streak that discourages all but the strongest of
minds. I have several systems that make money on paper but are too hard
for me to trade in real life.
Of course a lot of flame-outs are people who go to make a lot of money
in no time. Predictably (and statistically) after 3 losses and $3000
in losses, these people quit trading. If you can't take more than that,
stay out.
John
|
286.4 | | VMSDEV::HAMMOND | Charlie Hammond -- ZKO3-04/S23 -- dtn 381-2684 | Tue Oct 06 1992 17:31 | 21 |
| re: .3
Thanks for the comments, John.
> At one time Howard Ruff was telling his readers that Ken Roberts was on
> the up-and-up. Apparently Ken teaches the basics of futures and some
> sort of chart-based technical analysis. I believe at one time he
> offered a money-back guarantee, if you traded his system for 6 months
> and still lost money. (Proof was required).
The "PERFORMANCE GUARANTEE" in the brochure I have states:
"Read my Manual and all supporting materials. Follow the
specific instructions in each of the three Monthly Bulletins
and on each of the twice-a-week telephone updates. Do this on
paper only for the three-month Program. You man call, write,
fax, or come by my office for help as often as you need. If
you do not realize net profits, including your enrollment fee,
you may return the training materials and your paper-trading
records within four months for a full refund of your
enrollment fee."
|
286.5 | tried it...didn't work for me | GUMBAH::DAWSON | this is NOT a Problem... | Fri Oct 09 1992 10:53 | 16 |
| I enrolled in Ken's course about 1.5 years ago. I diligently followed
it for 3 months, bought the WSJ every day and tracked all the picks that
Ken gave on his phone hot-line. I admit I learned a lot, but I also
would have lost about $1500 over that time period. Thankfully, it was
on paper. I kept careful records, sent them into Ken, returned all the
material he had sent me, and received a full refund as per the
agreement.
About a month ago I got a phone call form British American asking me
how I was doing in the course...I told them I hadoabtained a refund a
long time ago...they then wanted to sell me another course on the
Japanese Candlestick Method.. I was not interested.
My personal experience.
Mike
|
286.6 | How do they avoid large losses? | MPGS::DONADT | | Wed Jan 27 1993 12:14 | 7 |
| RE .5:
How does British American avoid big losses if the market turns against
you? Do they use some type of hedging or is it up to you to closely
watch your position and sell (or place stop loss order) when you've
sustained as much loss as you can handle?
Ray
|
286.7 | Tried it...didn't work fo rme | GUMBAH::DAWSON | Subvert the Dominant Paradigm | Mon Feb 01 1993 16:01 | 6 |
| They (Ken Roberts) suggest using stop loss orders to minimize your
losses when the market turns against you. I tried his recommendation
on paper for 3 months...would have lost about $1000 if it was real...so
I didn't continue...but he was good about refunding my purchase price.
Mike
|
286.8 | Anybody keep the course? | NECSC::EINES | CSC/MA SNA product support | Mon Oct 25 1993 16:05 | 8 |
| I'd like to borrow the Roberts course to compare his techniques to
others I've been reading about. It sounds like it would be a good
review. The one I never had!
Anybody have one to lend/sell? Send mail or call dtn 237-7356.
Fred
|
286.9 | If I have it, your welcome to it | USCTR1::BJORGENSEN | | Mon Oct 25 1993 16:56 | 33 |
| I enrolled in the "Ken Roberts" course a couple of years back. He
sure makes trading commodities sound simple, fun and profitable.
I still have the course material - might be in the attic, though
I think I lost about $200 in the first three months - on paper. I wrote
the company a letter with all my records, and they offered to
refund my money or give me a year of their advisory service for free.
I did enjoy following his recommendations and "paper trading" so
I opted to take the years subscription. I ended the year some $20k
ahead. Arguably, paper trading is not like real trading, though.
I don't think that I have the stomach to trade my real dollars - yet.
Perhaps when I get further ahead of the mortgage and diaper bill I'll
give a try. *Unemotional discipline* seemed to be a key in this
business.
I think Ken Roberts offers several classes now. Perhaps up to eight.
I got a mailer from him just a few weeks ago. The course that I was
in taught trading techniques with future contracts. He sells one for
options, and a host of other investment vehicles. He teaches a "1-2-3"
formation to "avoid"(help avoid) getting in before a bottom or top and
uses stops to avoid/limit losses and protect profits. Again, I enjoyed
the course, and for the cost and guarantee, I say it's worth it. I've
learned fare less in some graduate level management business classes
for $1500! He does guarantee all of his courses. If you don't make
money in 3 months on paper, you get your money back. Trading *can* be
very profitable.
Incidentally, before I enrolled, I had my older brother, who frequents CA
often, stop by his office to make sure that there was really a
"Ken Roberts" company. He said they were friendly and legit.
If I can find the material, you are welcome to borrow it.
-Brian
|
286.10 | Thanks! | NECSC::EINES | CSC/MA SNA product support | Tue Oct 26 1993 10:48 | 5 |
| Thanks for the offer, Brian. Let me know if you locate the
materials. I will be happy to dust them off if you do!
Fred
|