[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::sf

Title:Arcana Caelestia
Notice:Directory listings are in topic 2
Moderator:NETRIX::thomas
Created:Thu Dec 08 1983
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1300
Total number of notes:18728

806.0. "Patricia McKillip" by JEREMY::EYALW () Tue Jun 27 1989 14:47

    "Hi Hi Hi, my drugies";
    
    I was quite surprised not to find even a single note on Patricia McKillip
    and her great trilogy on the prince of Hed.
    I admit that I myself only came to read the books a couple of weeks
    ago, but they were out more than 10 years ago.
    Having read all three (to those who forgot or are not farmiliar with
    the names, these are 'The riddle master of Hed', 'Heir of sea and
    fire' and 'Harpist in the wind') within a week or so (I wished it
    would never end,but I could'nt stop reading!), I decided to try and
    find other books by McKillip. Well, I could'nt find any in the
    bookstores around here, so I was wandering if anyone out there
    might know of any, and if they are as good as the trilogy.
    I'll be happy to get replies on the subject, and would,of course
    love to hear opinions/questions/remarks/additions on the the
    'Riddle master..' trilogy.
    
    Write, 'ye 'oll.
    
     E. Weiss
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
806.1TCC::HEFFELAliens made me write this.Tue Jun 27 1989 23:558
    
    	She also wrote "The Forgotten Beasts of Eld".
    
    	It's been a while since I read it (years), but I remeber enjoying
    it.
    
    tlh
    
806.2Here's some...WECARE::BAILEYCorporate SleuthThu Jun 29 1989 12:1323
    Ah, one of my favorite trilogies and one of my faviorite authors!
    
    From Books in Print:
    
    The Changeling Sea (for kids)
    The Forgotten Beasts of Eld
    Harpist in the Wind
    Heir of Sea and Fire
    The Moon & the Face (for kids)
    Moon-Flash
    Moonflash (same title, different publisher's version)
    The Riddle-Master of Hed
    Stepping from the Shadows
    The Throme of the Erril of Sherrill
    
    Moonflash has a sequel which may be Stepping from the Shadows --
    I read them both but I forget these details! ;^)  Anyhow, they are
    more sci-fi than the Riddle-Master trilogy, but they have a good
    flavor.
    
    Her short stories are good too -- in many sf anthologies.
    
    Sherry
806.3What else can I say?JEREMY::EYALWThu Jun 29 1989 14:357
    
    Thanks for the info, Sherry.
    I needed that.
    
    
    E. Weiss
    
806.4Good booksWMOIS::B_REINKEIf you are a dreamer, come in..Fri Jun 30 1989 13:575
    The triology about the prince of Hed is one of my all time favorites
    - I've reread it quite a few times. I find that I just plain *like*
    the people involved.
    
    Bonnie
806.5Oh, I'd forgotten about her!CIVIC::SWANSONStitch-aholicFri Jul 07 1989 10:216
    Yup, one of my all-time favorites, too.  I don't remember too many of
    her other books, though -- I guess I haven't read them.  Time to reread
    the wonderful trilogy, I think!
    
    Jennifer
    
806.6Fools Run ?YUPPY::MCINTYRETue Aug 29 1989 07:1412
    
    
    I think she also wrote FOOLS RUN...I'll look it up tonight and confirm
    before the end of the week. 
    
    I read the riddle master trilogy about 5 years ago, and I must admit
    I remember enjoying it and promising I would re-read it at some
    stage in the future...I guess that time has arrived..
    
    I also enjoyed Fools Run, though it was a very different book from
    the Riddle Master Trilogy, I won't go any further with this just
    in case I have got my Authors wrong.
806.7Yes on Fool's RunTLE::D_CARROLLOn the outside, looking inThu Sep 14 1989 16:519
>    I think she also wrote FOOLS RUN...I'll look it up tonight and confirm
>    before the end of the week. 

Yup.  Read it mere months ago, on "strong" (as in, "If you don't read it,
I will disown you") recommendations from my father.  Not sure what I thought
of it, but I sure didn't like it enough that I would disown my (hypothetical)
children for not reading it.

D!
806.8Anyone awake?CGVAX2::STEVENSONFri Sep 25 1992 15:0919
    This note has been quiet awile, but here goes, anyway...
    
    The Riddlemaster trilogy has long been a favorite; I first read it when
    I was in the 7th grade.  I didn't fully understand it then, but I have
    probably re-read the three books once a year for almost every year
    since!  I am a little embarassed to admit this, but I am putting my
    pride under my feet in order to end my confusion and ignorance...
    
    I have never fully understood the ending!!!
    **SPOILER if you haven't read it yet!**
    
    At the end, why can't Morgan and Raederle get married?!?!  So he's the
    High One and she's kin of Ylon and a shape shifter?  Seems to me they
    would only be happy with someone else who could understand the
    glories/pain of power.  Can someone explain this?  Am I being too
    romantic in wanting a happy ending?
    
    Thanks!
    Tricia  
806.9Conjecture...GENSIS::LAVEYDr. Heckyll & Mr. JiveSat Sep 26 1992 13:3322
Having just reread this... a possible spoiler answer....



>    At the end, why can't Morgan and Raederle get married?!?!  So he's the
>    High One and she's kin of Ylon and a shape shifter?  Seems to me they
>    would only be happy with someone else who could understand the
>    glories/pain of power.  Can someone explain this?  Am I being too
>    romantic in wanting a happy ending?
    
Who says they don't get married?  I know it's not in the book, but I always
assumed they would.  To me, the resolution to the whole story was more
about Morgon solving the mystery of who he is, and about both Morgon and
Raederle coming to terms with and accepting their power and their
responsibilities.  Thus, the close, with the two sitting on a dock in Hed,
as "peace sent a tendril, like a taproot, into Morgon's heart" (or whatever
the quote is), seemed a more appropriate ending to me than going on for
another chapter or two to describe the wedding....  Yes, they both needed
some time to themselves, and spent time throughout the realm being
different, err, things :-), but they always came back to each other.....

-- Cathy