[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::equitation

Title:Equine Notes Conference
Notice:Topics List=4, Horses 4Sale/Wanted=150, Equip 4Sale/Wanted=151
Moderator:MTADMS::COBURNIO
Created:Tue Feb 11 1986
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2080
Total number of notes:22383

704.0. "Pasture Mate (Herd Dominance) Problems" by WMOIS::J_BENNETT (Janice Bennett DTN 241-3522) Tue Sep 06 1988 14:11

	Here is a bizarre problem that I have managed to create for myself.

	I recently bought a pony to keep my gelding company.  So far, things
aren't working out as well as I had hoped.  First of all, they are both
geldings: Jazz is 7 and the pony is 5.  They have been together for a month
now.  They have been seperated for the past two weeks because of the "damage"
to my horse.  Jazz has acquired some nasty bite marks and cuts all over his 
head, neck and shoulders - the pony is unblemished.  Also, Jazz has very
brittle feet and keeping shoes on them is an ordeal.  His feet are getting
destroyed because he has the habit of stamping his feet (with much gusto)
when he is irritated.  When they go out together, they stand together and
fight for hours on end.  The pony clashes his teeth at Jazz, and often chomps
skin or he rears at him while biting for a higher spot.  Jazz rarely bites
back and just stomps his feet and tosses his head and takes the abuse.  It
reached the point, after 2 weeks, I had to seperate them as Jazz was lame.
Also, let me add that Jazz's head tossing has been an ordeal in itself to
correct for almost a year now.  When I first purchased him, he was worked
with a standing martingale because of it.  With Melinda's help (Dressage
instruction) - he has improved considerably.  I get sick watching him toss
his head for hours on end and wonder if everything we've done is going down
the tubes.

	My plan of attack is to subdivide the pasture so that they can't 
get close enough to bite (double fencing) and to haul in some soft footing 
(sawdust/manure) for Jazz's turnout (the paddock is dirt and has rocks growing
in it - he have been picking rocks out of it all summer to no avail).  What I'm
afraid of is that they will just stand at the fence and do what they've been
doing right along - since this "battle" doesn't seem to have an end.  Also,
the subdivision will eliminate the area I have for riding/schooling - we will
need to do more extensive bulldozing to level another section for an arena -
not impossible - just inconvenient as we probably won't be able to finish
it until the spring.

	On top of all this, they experience seperation anxiety when I take one
to the grooming area - which is out of sight of the stalls.  They both act like
recent weanlings and it's very annoying.  I have yet to take Jazz for a trail-
ride away from his pony and I'm not looking forward to his reaction.  

	Did I mention that the pony is around 10 hands and Jazz is 15.2?  Would
I have the same problems if I were to get another horse or pony for Jazz?  Would
a quiet older mare be a better match?  What about a goat?  Before the pony moved
in my Golden Retriever was his buddy and would follow him everywhere - now the
dog barely escapes the paddock area with his life - Jazz practically attacks 
him.  Needless to say, the dog has been depressed about this situation also.
I hate to think it, but would Jazz be better off alone?  Are there any "horse 
psychologists" out there?  Why won't he fight the pony and establish the
pecking order?  

Thanks,

	Janice

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
704.1NHL::KEIRANTue Sep 06 1988 15:5014
    Janice,
    
    I would try him alone and see how he does, he may suprise you. 
    The problem you now have will only continue to get worse, and
    of you have children or like you said, the dog, someone could
    get seriously hurt by their stupid antics.  Horses do get quite
    used to staying alone.  When I got my mare off the track, she had
    never been alone, and lived at my house with my border, then the
    border left, and the mare wasn't even lonely.  She had never been
    alone in her life.  It sounds as if the situation would be more
    pleasant of you kept the horse by himself, and gave him tons of
    attention in the beginning until he got used to it.
    
    
704.2PONY'S BACKGROUND???MILVAX::NICKERSONTue Sep 06 1988 17:0411
    It would be interesting to know what type of a situation the pony
    came from before he came to your place.  Was he alone?  Was he king
    of the pasture?  Was he gelded properly or does he still feel he
    has to conquer the world?  Was he with mares or geldings?  Was he
    alone?
    
    Sorry I have no real answer for you but possibly knowing his background
    will help you solve your problem.
    
    GOOD LUCK
    
704.3WMOIS::J_BENNETTJanice Bennett DTN 241-3522Wed Sep 07 1988 10:2720
	Thanks for the info - things WERE going much better when Jazz was
alone ... I like having him outside for most of the day ... he really seems
happier for it and has been a different horse since bringing him home in July.

	I don't know alot about the pony - I bought him from a local stable.
He spent very little time turned out - was used for pony rides for kids (and he
is good with kids, to lead around with little ones on his back and for them
to brush, etc...)  My inexperienced son has no problems handling him and the
pony lunges, knows voice commands, is good in his stall, etc.  (My kids are
not horse crazy - so giving him up or getting something else won't be a big 
problem).

	I was told that he had a previous people biting problem 
that was cured by not giving him treats by hand - and he hasn't attempted to
bite anyone.  I'm not sure when he was gelded - a good question to ask.  I 
talked to the stable owner about this problem and she instructed me to not
let the pony out as he is used to being indoors anyway.  This doesn't solve
any problems - and I don't like leaving him in all day, but for now, this is
what I'm doing.
704.4Ponies: stallions in disguise!SALEM::DOUGLASWed Sep 07 1988 10:3834
    Hi Janice,
    
    I recently went through the same situation, got a pony to keep my
    horse company. They had several "arguements" but everything has
    ironed out. The pony would nip, chase, kick, and the gelding took
    it all. Now they're inseperable and even share their hay with each
    other.
    
    re size: Size means nothing as my pony is 14.1 and my gelding is
    16.1 ! it's survival of the fittest.
    
    re pecking order: As to your wondering why Jazz won't fight back
    and establish the pecking order? It's already been established and
    the pony is the boss.
    
    I feel that the previous owners should have mentioned to you that
    the pony did not get along with geldings (or stallions). Some ponies
    get along with mares only.
    
    If you feel the pony is worth keeping, then definitely make a divider.
    If not, an old brood mare would make great company for Jazz. They're
    are plenty around and you can get them for free in many cases.
    
    Jazz will become very neurotic if kept in that situation for much
    longer. As far as his hooves go, I wouldn't recomend a floor of
    sawdust/manure as the sawdust retains moisture (i.e. rain) and the
    manure may cause him to get thrush if he has pads on. You can order
    a load of "dead sand" which is good for riding rings and acts as
    a shock absorber to the feet. (I got 18 tons for my gelding's turnout
    which works well for his navicular.)
                                                                  
    Good luck,
    Tina
    
704.5TIME/BUFFER??EMASA2::NICKERSONWed Sep 07 1988 14:587
    It seems a shame to give the pony up as he sounds like he is super
    with kids...they are rarities.  Don't really have an answer other
    than time or putting the buffer in between.  They seem to enjoy
    each others company other than the "who is boss" problem.
    
    GOOD LUCK
    
704.6protect your priorityMJOSWS::FAGLEYleavin' early...golf to playWed Sep 07 1988 16:4312
      Dump the pony.  It seems as though Jazz is your main intrest.
    An old mare would probably be better.  My horse gets along much
    better (7yr old mare) with passive horses so thats who she's 
    pastured with.  She's a loner.  Being the biggest horse of 15 in
    the stable didn't make her want to kick any butt either.  She
    originally was kept with the aggressive horses, and had buddies,
    but still would run off to a corner of the pasture to graze in 
    peace when she didn't want company.  One or two horses picked on
    her a little while, but it gradually stopped.(I think they got 
    tired trying to catch her)
    
    rick
704.7...yup - get rid of the pony.THRSHR::DINGEEJulie Dingee, VAX Forms DevelopmentThu Sep 08 1988 13:0132
	I've got to agree with .6 - get rid of the pony. If
	he's so good with children, that shouldn't be a
	problem. You got him for a purpose, and he's not
	serving that purpose; in addition to which, as an earlier
	reply mentioned, the pecking order HAS been established,
	and there's not a darn thing you're going to be able to
	do about it. It might calm down some, but that pony is
	going to nip Jazz every chance he gets, as long as he's
	there.

	And keeping them in separate paddocks isn't really
	serving the purpose, either. Horses which are companionable
	like to scratch each others' withers with their teeth,
	huddle together on windy days, and just graze side by side
	for hours. Also, each should feel very comfortable and safe
	lying down and going to sleep while the other watches out for
	danger. It's great to see when they are happy with each other!
	That will never happen with this (mis)match.

	My vote is "the pony goes"! You can usually find out from
	owners with multiple equine types whether an animal you
	want to buy is a dominant or submissive type. I had a pony
	for my horse, and they were great together. Now I have a
	mare for him, and although he sometimes torments her, they
	still get along very well. So it doesn't appear to me that
	a mare or gelding, pony or horse makes a difference, it's
	whether they are generally submissive or aggressive. Apparently
	that's determined both before, and within a few short months of,
	birth. 

	-julie