T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
2865.1 | | STOWOA::SWFULLER | | Mon Oct 10 1994 09:26 | 7 |
| Don't get hung up on frame size. If you go with a Fischer, there 21"
is HUGE, especially for single track. Think more in top tube length.
Stay away from the Quadra 10, it does little. Probably the Rudy, or
Mantou would be best...even though my preference is for Cannondale
headshock...The new Fischers look great, be aware the model you are
looking for isn't expected into dealers until January.
steve
|
2865.2 | Right down my alley... | DECWET::TEAGUE | | Thu Nov 10 1994 19:49 | 79 |
|
What I'd like: Durable/quality front suspension bike, LX or better,
clipless pedals, bar-ends. Lean towards chrom-moly and away from
aluminum. Since I'm 6'3", 190 lbs., need a long top tube and probably
a 21" frame. (The Diamond Back was 22")
I'll spend up to $1,100. Or maybe a little more. :>)
This sounds like exactly what I'm looking for, and the price is what
I'm planning to pay, so I thought my comments might be relevant. My
only difference is that you couldn't pay me to have clipless pedals.
I tip my hat to those who know and love SPDs and their clones, but...
<begin mild tirade>
...many riders find them difficult to get used to, a pain in muddy
conditions, they are expensive, unless you already have SPD-compatible
shoes they will require you to buy new ones, SPDs require an odd-sized
little allen wrench for adjustment that is used on no other part of your
bike. I contrast this with my clips and straps that work perfectly well
for me and have none of these drawbacks. Get SPDs if you want, of course,
but don't assume every new Shimano gizmo is an improvement (take the U-brake
they gave us in 1987, for example).
<end mild tirade>
Re: the bar-ends, don't sweat them. I actually prefer many of the after
market bar-ends to those included with most bikes. So these can be cheaply
and easily installed later.
New '95 models I've heard about but haven't riden yet:
(Be sure to ride before you buy...)
Rock Hopper FS (around $700 with STX/gripshifter; steel frame (whose
tubes?) Rock Shock Quadra; would have to add pedals and bar-ends)
Nice bike, but not the same caliber as the Stumpjumper, and I am not
fond of Rock Shox. My current top contender is a '95 Stumpjumper rigid fork
model with Manitou Fours added afterwards...total price is $1150. ('95
Stumpjumpers are suspension compatible, but the '94s are not.) The
Stumpjumper is a much better match for your price range than a Rockhopper.
Marin Eldridge Grade ($1100; "Marin-specified Tange butted chrome-
moly [?]; Manitou 3 fork; not sure on group?; bar-ends)
Marin makes a fabulous bike, but with an equally fabulous price tag. I
found that I would pay $400-$500 more for a Marin equipped similarly to a
Specialized Stumpjumper. I like Manitou forks better than any others on
the market.
Trek 970SHX ($970; True Temper chrome-moly; Rock Shox Quadra 21 fork;
Deore LX-C/gripshift and LX RapidFire+ [aren't those mutually
exclusive?; bar-ends)
I don't know squat about Trek. But as I said I'm not fond of Rock Shox.
Also, I prefer Gripshift over RapidFire+.
Fisher Cronus ($1200; triple butting True Temper; Judy XC Rock Shox
(way cool!); XT/LX gripshift; Onza clipless pedals; bar ends; Tioga
Psycho-K tires [?]. Leaning towards this because it is "complete.")
Sounds hot! I've heard of them but haven't ridden one. Judy's are supposed
to be really something.
Questions: Comments on the above? Are there others I should consider?
(I'm especially interested in the Judy shock; heard good things about
it, and I believe a Rock Hopper model comes with...any experiences
with Judy? ;>)
You won't find Judy on anything but the *top* of the line bikes. No chance
on a RockHopper.
Any comments on Gary Fisher bikes? Seems like the best value to me...
The only bikes that are a good value are the ones you like after you
ride them. Taking a test ride will quickly trim down your list of
finalists above.
|
2865.3 | Now is a good time to buy... | SALEM::SHAW | | Fri Nov 11 1994 07:19 | 18 |
|
re:-1
Although have not tried the Fisher bike, but looks like the best
combination of components. The Trek would be my least favourite.
Simply because I am not found of Rock Shox Quadras. I have the
quadra on one of my bikes, it is great for little bumps and small
pebbles and such but for higher speeds, going down hill or over
bigger bumps, the fork bottoms out in the softer settings. When I
tighten the setting making it firmer, it has a jerky movement that
irritates me. This compared to my Manitou 2 on the KHS, no comparison.
If you are close to a Rodgers ski and bike, (Hampton, NH) or Lincoln,
or any other KHS dealer, check out the KHS bikes the Pro FZ is
great bike, I love the KHS frames, very light but strong, you get
the manitue 3 forks, and XT/XTR group set. for around $12,000.
Shaw
|
2865.4 | Such a Deal! | NWD002::REID_PA | SI - Lookin' for a bigger hammer | Fri Nov 11 1994 11:38 | 9 |
|
re:-1
>> great bike, I love the KHS frames, very light but strong, you get
>> the manitue 3 forks, and XT/XTR group set. for around $12,000.
$12,000 8^o ... I'd expect better than XT/XTR components!
PR
|
2865.5 | that was just monopoly money | SALEM::SHAW | | Fri Nov 11 1994 13:24 | 6 |
|
Sorry that was 12,000 drakma's ;-)
I realy meant $ 1,200 , but you already knew that ;*)
Shaw
|
2865.6 | | PCBUOA::KRATZ | | Fri Nov 11 1994 18:20 | 11 |
| I'll second .2's recommendation/review of a Stumpjumper + shock +
grip shifts + rollerblader skewers... er, bar ends. I've had pretty
good luck with mine (although a stick just munched the rear XT
derailleur; 2nd one this year); the bike was about $1200. I tried SPD,
but put titanium pedals on... my 4E wide feet couldn't deal with the SPD
shoes. The bike saw over 2000 miles this year; @6000 miles on it total.
No major screwups, although the headset, chain rings, XT shifters, a
front brake (pin sheared), a wheel (brakes wore thru its side), and the
usual stuff (chain, cluster) have needed replaced... oh, and the fork
got recalled.
Kratz
|
2865.7 | Proflex??? | NEMAIL::FISHER | | Mon Nov 14 1994 13:17 | 9 |
| I've been looking at bikes lately and one that seems like a good
idea in theory and price are the Proflex fully suspended bikes
that use use an "elastomeric foam spring". I've talked to some
people that ride these, but most of them work for bike shops
that sell them....has anyone ridden this type for any period of
time. I would be using this on all kinds of conditions including
like Sunday River.
Thanks Saul
|
2865.8 | | DELNI::CRITZ | Scott Critz, LKG2/1, Pole V3 | Mon Nov 14 1994 13:20 | 8 |
| Saul,
I don't own a Proflex and I don't ride one on TV.
However, Ed Kross rode a Proflex road bike this year for
the Race Across AMerica.
Scott
|
2865.9 | Happy Proflex owner | SWAM2::BURDICK_JI | | Wed Nov 16 1994 15:49 | 7 |
| I have had a Proflex 854 for a few months, and have had it on a few
rough rides. I like it a lot. It is a much more stable and forgiving
ride than my previous Stumpjumper FS. Really handles the washboard and
rocks well. I'm not a very fast rider, so I can't really comment on
how it handles large bumps going fast, but the bike doesn't seem to
have any handling flaws at all. I think the fork allows more precise
steering that the FS/Rock Shox fork.
|
2865.10 | Second look: Trek 970 | DECWET::TEAGUE | | Tue Nov 29 1994 14:25 | 11 |
|
I got some more information on the Trek 970 this past weekend, and
it looks pretty good. (The 970 is the same bike as the 970SHX without
bar-ends and shocks...and the 970 has GripShift).
It is comparable to the Stumpjumper in price and componentry...now I
just have to find one to ride. I'll report on how it compares to
the Stumpjumper after I give one a whirl.
Jim
|
2865.11 | Trek 970 report | DECWET::TEAGUE | Windows NT Distributed Technologies | Wed Dec 07 1994 22:39 | 14 |
|
Well, I rode a Trek 970 last weekend at Gregg's Greenlake Cycle in
Seattle. Nice bike. So nice that it has eclipsed the Stumpjumper,
and I liked it as much as the Marin Pine Mountain I rode.
It is steel, $30 less than the Stumpjumper, weighs less than 24 pounds,
and is built in the U.S...even the frame!
I will go back when I get closer to buying, so that I can do a good
A/B comparison (Gregg's sells both Trek and Specialized), but
right now it's gotta be Trek.
Jim
|
2865.12 | Still lookin' | NEMAIL::FISHER | | Mon Mar 13 1995 08:10 | 8 |
| I'm still looking at bikes, but more seriously now that I have money,
I sold my landcruiser yesterday. Anyway, I've kinda narrowed it down
to Proflex 555 or 755 about a $300 difference. A Biancchi Grizzly.
I'm pretty sure I want full suspension and there doesn't seem to be
much available in the Boston area in the $1000-1400 price range to
try out.
Saulf
|
2865.13 | Finally!!!!! | NWD002::THOMPSOKR | Kris with a K | Tue Mar 28 1995 21:45 | 30 |
| Here's what I got. Yesterday.
All XT (front, rear, crank, BB, cassette, brakes, hubs, chain).
DiaComp SS-7 levers were put in place of the XT levers when I upgraded
to X-Ray gripshift. Was told they were as good or better as the XT
levers (?? any comments??) (Isn't a lever a lever here?)
Cro-moly, double-butted frame. Bontrager BCX-1 and -2 (rear) rims and
Panaracer Dart HC and Smoke HC Comp (rear) tires. Added Onza bar-ends
and Performance clipless pedals.
Weighs a *very* light 23.8 lbs for a 21" frame (with a stiff fork).
Under their special offer, I'll add the Judy XC for only $220 (reg.
$400) when it arrives in two weeks, and that should top it out at
~25.3 lbs.
Great fit. Kool components. Probably 6 lbs. lighter than my
DiamondBack. Unbelievable price: $1025 with the Judy.
Guesses?
I got a 1994 Performance M104. I had pretty much decided on the
Fisher and went into the local Performance store for shoes.
Ha! Well worth the wait.
It'll be mondo muddy on Sunday.
:>)
|
2865.14 | me too...Finally!!! | NEMAIL::FISHER | | Wed Mar 29 1995 12:46 | 11 |
| I finally broke down and bought a Fisher Paragon. Buying a bike is like
buying a PC....you can look forever and know what your buying will be
obsolete or something better will come out next week. So I bought
what fit my needs best today. This one comes with clipless pedals
standard and I got the shoes for free. So far I'm still gettin'
the hang of them. About half the time I stop when I'm in the woods
I fall over.....kinda like that old guy on LAUGH-IN who rode the
tricycle. If any one wants a new TREK or Cannondale catalog send me
mail..
Saul
|