[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::bicycle

Title: Bicycling
Notice:Bicycling for Fun
Moderator:JAMIN::WASSER
Created:Mon Apr 14 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:3214
Total number of notes:31946

2595.0. "Bridgestone vs. Trek" by POCUS::HUSTON () Tue Jun 15 1993 14:02

    I've been out looking at many hybrids and talking to a lot of shops.
    I've narrowed the search to Trek 720 and the Bridgestone XO-5. I'll
    spend 90% of the time on the road, often with a child on back, usually
    on hilly but not mountainous areas. I'm getting a hybrid because 10% of
    the time I'll be off-road, usually on some sort of packed trail.
    
    Here are a few differences that matter to me. Are they important?
    
    TREK 720				Bridgestone XO-5
    
    F. Derail.  Altus A10		Altus C20
    Rear	Altus A20		Altus A10
    Shifter	Gripshift SRT300	200GS Top Mount
    Dealer Svc.	One-year		3 months (same warranty)
    Support	?			?
    
    1. Since I won't typically be too demanding on it, do derailleurs
       make a difference here?
    
    2. Is Gripshift reliable? It seemed convenient but maybe gimmicky.
    
    3. Does 9 months extra dealer free service matter if I ride under
       50 miles a week on the road?
    
    4. Trek dealer made a big point of its being a US-based company.
       Since all components are Shimano anyway, can't any bike store
       fix either model?
    
    5. I test road both and loved the Bridgestone, liked the Trek. All
       things being equal, or nearly so, I'd go for the Bridgestone,
       because it was so fun to ride (and their catalog is not only
       humorous, but really informative).
    
    
    Any comments appreciated.
    
    dh
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
2595.1Go for the one you liked most.SALEM::SHAWTue Jun 15 1993 14:5312
    
    Both bikes offer about similar componants and probably price. 
    You say you loved the Bridgestone, go for it......
    
    Shaw
    
    P.S 9 months free service doesn't realy mean anything, it's not like
    you are bying a car. The only service that you will need in 9 months
    with as little riding as you are considering might be derailure
    adjustment, lubrication etc. Most of these are more fun when you
    do it yourself anyways. 
             
2595.2STRATA::HUITue Jun 15 1993 14:5928
    I would buy what you LOVE over what you LIKE. You will be second 
    guessing yourself if don't by the bike you love. 

    As for the components, the two system are pretty comparable.  but the 
    thumb shifters will be more reliable then the grip shifters in the long
    run. Also, the replacement cost of a thumb shift should cost a lot lower 
    then the grip shifters if it ever fails.

    As for the service, usually after the dealer readjust the bike once due to
    cable stretch. The bike should be fine until the next season tune up unless 
    you plan to do over a thousand miles this year.

    As for the US base company status. I always like to buy US products also.
    But like you said, both of these bike components are made in Japan and 
    both bikes are assembled in Taiwan. But the Trek are probably 
    designed in the USA rather then Japan. 

    If both was a toss up, I would probably buy the Trek sine it is a USA 
    company. But in your case, I think your are favoring the XO3. 
   
    Good luck and enjoy,

    Dave 
    
 
    
    

2595.3XO3 ExperiencePSDVAX::HITZWed Jun 16 1993 09:2717
    
    	A year ago April I purchased an XO3 Bridgestone.  That year they
    	only had XO1s, 2s and 3s.  This year they added 4s and 5s and I
    	am told the XO5 is the same as my XO3.
    
    	Last year I proceeded to put 1200 miles on the bike and so far this
    	year I have done 1000.  It suits my needs quite nicely.  I do road
    	touring almost exclusively, but some of the roads I use might
    	better be described as 'cross country' :^).  
    
    	I did change the seat to an Avocet C20 which is very comfortable
    	and I changed to a smoother tread on the tires.
    
    	While I cannot compare it to a Trek, I can say I am very pleased 
    	with the XO3.
    
    	FWIW,  George
2595.4"GO FOR IT"MKOTS3::RONEYWed Jun 16 1993 10:3510
    I also did wha tyou have done. Try them all and go with the one that
    feels good to you. I ended up buying GT hybrids. I really like mine and
    I also bought one for my wife. I've never seen her enjoy riding like
    she does now. when we had road bikes I could never get her to ride. She
    did not like the caharacteristics of riding road bikes. These hybrids
    are"GREAT"! We also changed the seats to Avocet 20's. 
    
    good luck with your purchase, and enjoy,
    
    Bob 
2595.5Consider swapping for road tires initiallyKYOA::32925::boyleDirty Jobs Done Dirt CheapWed Jun 16 1993 15:1810
Just a general comment.

I own a Hybrid and I know a number of people with Hybrids.  EVERYONE replaces their 
knobby tires with "smoother" road tires (In my case, the Avocet Cross).  It may be in 
your best interest to attempt to get a deal where you get the new tires thrown in, or at 
least at a severe discount.  

Just a thought,

Jack Boyle
2595.6ThanksHOCUS::HUSTONWed Jun 16 1993 23:319
    Actually this model comes with Ritchey Tom Slick tires. Maybe everyone
    was asking for smoother tires. The seat is Velo VL, Avocet on the
    higher end models.
    
    Thanks for all your advice. I'll go with the bike that's the most fun
    to ride.
    
    dh