[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference terri::cars_uk

Title:Cars in the UK
Notice:Please read new conference charter 1.70
Moderator:COMICS::SHELLEYELD
Created:Sun Mar 06 1994
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2584
Total number of notes:63384

1807.0. "Diesel ZX vs Diesel Golf??" by MACNAS::RNOONE () Wed Jun 24 1992 11:17

    
    
    I'm considering the purchase of either a diesel Citroen ZX or a diesel
    Golf (new). Anyone got comments on either/both.
    
    Thanks
    Robert
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1807.1Comments on AXARRODS::BARRONDSnoopy Vs the Red_BarronWed Jun 24 1992 12:5014
    Robert
    
    Take a look in this weeks Autocar and motor. They have a report on the
    new ZX 1.9 turbo diesel.
    
    Looks good 92bhp @ 4,000 rpm, 148lb/ft @ 2250rpm( with 130+@1750rpm)  
    It does 0-60 in 10.3, 115mph all with 50+ mpg.
    
    Costs
    Advantage �11370
    Aura      �11970
    
    The summary comment included "...The best diesel in the world? 
    Probably"
1807.2so sad...MACNAS::RNOONEWed Jun 24 1992 13:0213
    
    
    sounds great....alas I don't have the cash for that sort of machine. 
    A basic diesel advantage costs �12,800 over here (Ireland), for that you 
    get four wheels and power steering, no sunroof, no central locking
    no....  :-(
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
1807.3Buy in the UK?ARRODS::BARRONDSnoopy Vs the Red_BarronWed Jun 24 1992 14:026
    Robert
    
    Whats stopping you buying it here in the UK? Assuming you have got the
    loot.
    
    dave
1807.4Local Car Tax VOGON::MORGANClouds of Anger, Tears of RainWed Jun 24 1992 14:087
    
    Probably have to pay some sort of import tax to Eire much the same
    as you do to the U.K. when you buy a car in mainland Europe and then 
    bring it to the U.K.
    
    Rich
    
1807.5ecoEEMELI::HAUTALAGreasy Joe's Bottomless Grill PitWed Jun 24 1992 14:187
    
    re .1
    
    I think Golf diesel is equipped with that eco diesel 1.9 litre.
    Don't know other details.
    
    Hannu
1807.6how the cost worksMACNAS::RNOONEWed Jun 24 1992 14:3416
    
    In short, covered elsewhere in detail, I would have to pay 20% of Irish
    list price (12,800) in excise duty PLUS 21% VAT on purchase price.
    
    Buy it for 10,000 (no VAT)   
    Excise      2,560
    VAT         2,100
               ------
               14,660
    
    I understand that the base price (no duty or VAT) of many cars is
    cheaper in Ireland (reduced feature models) so that we can afford to
    pay the government share of buying a car.
    
    
    
1807.7Do some researchROCKS::ARBISERIf you want it done well - DIYThu Jun 25 1992 10:5117
    
    Not sure what criteria you have but I'd think about second-hand values.
    The Veedubs certainly seem to have a good track record in this area so
    if it's return that concerns you I'd pick that. If it's out and out
    speed I think the Citro�n comes out on top, it may also be slightly 
    quieter both inside and from without. 
    
    The various rags I've read have slated the Golf interior as being
    boring but that is very much in the eye of the beholder. There are
    certainly not vary many optional extras so here too the ZX scores.
    
    Lastly I'd call the service agents and check out the likely charges
    for regular oil etc changes.
    
    Ian
    
    PS. I drive a diesel Golf and wouldn't have any other...
1807.8silent vs strong !MACNAS::RNOONEThu Jun 25 1992 11:1216
    
    
    I went for a drive in a Golf last night, it is a real truck compared to
    the ZX (loud, heavy and slow). It feels really strong and well put 
    together but the biggest plus factors are probably the second hand value 
    and the reliability.
    
    The ZX has better looks (says my wife), faster aceleration and a quieter 
    engine.
    
    I also went to see the Astra diesel, horrible !
    
    I think we will be having a Golf....
    
    
    
1807.9More choiceTIMMII::TOMMII::RDAVIESAmateur ExpertFri Jun 26 1992 14:529
Did you see the Astra Turbo diesel?, a different engine so maybe better.

The non-turbo ZX diesel you can get in the reflex trim also.

What about the AX or BX,  Pug 205,  309, or 405 all good cars and good 
engine's (the same, except for the AX which has the TUD 1.4 engine, now going 
into the metro!).

Richard
1807.10LARVAE::IVES_JBad Karma in the UKTue Jun 30 1992 17:1215
    I have the BX 19TGD which is a fleet car and I'm pleased with (in fact
    my second). It's due for replacement July 93, but I definitely will go
    for another diesel. Having had 2 BX's I'm tempted to try something else
    next time, though I love the quirkiness of the BX , niether of which
    have ever let me down. 
    
    In addition to the above mentioned how is the Renault 19 Diesel ?
    
    I test drove the GTD Golf , but rejected it as ity did'nt come with
    power steering and the BX did. maybe I'm a wimp but a Golf without p/s
    is not on for me, Shame as I confer with the previous results i.e. well
    built solid, good radio (BX one is poor). With only a year to go, just
    enough time to start testdriving :-)
    
    
1807.11`Servo-lenkung' standard on German carsROCKS::ARBISERIf you want it done well - DIYWed Jul 01 1992 11:538
    
    As I understand it power steering is standard on the Golf range now,
    that is except for the lowest entry 1300cc petrol versions. 
    
    I believe there is a move among the European manufacturers to fit this
    as standard in the future.
    
    Ian
1807.12Keep the faithTIMMII::TOMMII::RDAVIESAmateur ExpertWed Jul 01 1992 18:214
And the new BX may be out by July 93!

Richard

1807.13MAJORS::ALFORDlying Shipwrecked and comatose...Thu Jul 02 1992 10:205

complete with pre-fitted rear windscreen blinds...

:-)
1807.14Stirrer! :-)TIMMII::RDAVIESAn expert AmateurThu Jul 02 1992 13:222
       <<< Note 1807.13 by MAJORS::ALFORD "lying Shipwrecked and
    comatose..." >>>
1807.15What kind of blinds?HEWIE::RUSSELLHAL -&gt; IBM; VMS -&gt; Windows/NTFri Jul 03 1992 14:468
re the last few;

what kind of rear blinds does the ZX have? Is is the same as the BX, which
is two seperate blinds, as I find it really annoying to have the driver
behind trying to peer through the �" gap in the middle, to see what is
going on...

Peter.
1807.16ZX has one-piece...\SUBURB::DELANYSFri Jul 03 1992 16:5121
    Peter,
    
    The ZX has a one-piece blind that extends across most of the rear
    window. The blind is ingeniously built into the parcel shelf.
    
    BTW, I can't see the fuss about these things. If nothing else, they
    dramatically cut down the amount of heat from the sun when the car is
    parked, not just when on the move (when presumably most people would
    have their ventilation going anyway, so heat need not build up too
    much).
    
    I would agree that they cut out a lot of light/ability to see through
    them clearly, but as someone else has pointed out, it means you're too
    close to the vehicle in front if you're relying on seeing THROUGH the
    vehicle to find out what's going on ahead. After all, they don't ban
    trucks and vans just because you can't see through them, do they?
    
    
    
    Rgds,                                 
    S
1807.17fuel consumptionCOMICS::MISTRYWed Jul 15 1992 13:186
Hi,

Does anyone know the fuel comsumption figures are for the Golf GTD as opposed to
the Astra or Citroen.

Bipin.
1807.18MAJORS::ALFORDlying Shipwrecked and comatose...Wed Jul 15 1992 13:3512

From the "blurb-book" for the hatchback...Estate version slightly lower 
figures.

in mpg

	urban	56mph	75mph

1.7D	40.9	67.3	47.1	

1.7TD	39.8	58.9	42.8
1807.19ARRODS::BARRONDSnoopy Vs the Red_BarronWed Jul 15 1992 13:3812
    
    re.17
    
    The overall/touring MPG is as follows
    
    	ZX Reflex 1.9D	 39/47
    	Astra 1.7D Merit 38/47
    	
    I don't have figures for Golf GTD but 1.9CL TD (Umwelt) it is
    36/43.
    
    Dave